Discussion on: CSRF Protection in Next.js

[David Rhoderick]

So I'm trying this in my current project and I'm unable to get it to work. Are you using any other dependencies?

I first tried to implement it based on my project, which utilizes RTK Query, but then I just thought I'd re-add the hello.js endpoint and copy and paste your code exactly and it just gives me an "invalid csrf token" error.

UPDATE: I was sure it had something to do with my project so I did "create next app" and copied and pasted your tutorial in there but it just gives me a 500 error when I try to hit the home page. I'm thinking there's something missing OR maybe versions may be off.

[Adel]

just pushed the working example to github.com/adelhamad/nextjs-csrf

I also added try catch to hello.js if you want to customize the response and not just have 500 error

[David Rhoderick]

Thanks for adding that example, it certainly helps a lot. However, when I run it locally, this is what I get:

u.pcloud.link/publink/show?code=XZ...

Looks like it's not working because I assume one of those buttons should have a different response than the other. Is that CORS error in the console an issue? Could it be a browser-related issue (I'm on Firefox)?

[Adel]

I don't think it's browser issue, I see in the video you are running the app on port 3001, and the axios call is going to 'localhost:3000/api/hello' which are different origins

So I suggest either run the app on port 3000 or change the request url to port 3001 in pages/index.js

[David Rhoderick]

Bingo that was it! Thanks for the tutorial. Hopefully I can get it working with my project.

[Kishor Gembali]

Thanks Adel. It is really helpful.

@dejvo - I am going to implement this as part of a POC, are you able to make it work. Just would like to know if you come across any other challenges.

[David Rhoderick]

@kishorgembali I couldn't get the await csrf(); lines to work. Instead, I had to chain the middleware, but that could be an issue with our specific containerized deployment.

In the end, we also decided against double submit because it seemed the Next.js API routes were always directly accessible even then from any browser so we didn't want that.

We went with the synchronizer token pattern in the end. To achieve that, we basically use the Next.js server to hold the CSRF secret and then the middleware just confirms the CSRF token against that.

[Kishor Gembali]

ohk. Got it. Thank you @dejvo. Is it possible to share any reference or sample implementation, I am new to Next JS, dont want to reinvent the wheel. Just checking if it is something available. Appreciate your quick response.

[David Rhoderick]

Basically the way the CSRF is implemented is like this using the csrf NPM module:

import Tokens from 'csrf';
import { GlobalRef } from './global-ref';

const tokens = new Tokens();
const secret = new GlobalRef('domain.csrfSecret');

export const createSecret = () => {
  secret.value = tokens.secretSync();
};

export const resetSecret = () => {
  secret.value = undefined;
};

export const createToken = () => {
  if (!secret.value) {
    return new Error('No secret set');
  }

  return tokens.create(secret.value as string);
};

export const verifyToken = (csrfToken: string) => {
  if (!secret.value) {
    return new Error('No secret set');
  }

  return tokens.verify(secret.value as string, csrfToken);
};

It uses this GlobalRef hack I found online and tweaked to store the CSRF secret:

export class GlobalRef<T> {
  private readonly sym: symbol;

  constructor(uniqueName: string) {
    this.sym = Symbol.for(uniqueName);
  }

  get value() {
    return (global as never)[this.sym] as T;
  }

  set value(value: T) {
    // eslint-disable-next-line @typescript-eslint/no-explicit-any
    // eslint-disable-next-line @typescript-eslint/no-unsafe-member-access
    (global as any)[this.sym] = value;
  }
}

Then you can use those functions in your API endpoints in Next.js. Like I said, I had trouble implementing the middleware how it is in the documentation so I used a callback like this:

export const verifyCsrf = async (
  req: NextApiRequest,
  res: NextApiResponse,
  callback
) => {
  if (req.headers['csrf-token']) {
    if (verifyCsrfToken(req.headers['csrf-token'].toString())) {
      await callback();
    } else {
      console.error('No permissions to perform the request');

      res.status(403).json({
        code: 'access_denied',
        message: 'No permissions to perform the request',
      });
    }
  } else {
      console.error('No permissions to perform the request');

      res.status(403).json({
        code: 'access_denied',
        message: 'No permissions to perform the request',
      });
  }
};

And then call it like this in an endpoint:

export default async function someEndpoint(
  req: NextApiRequest,
  res: NextApiResponse
) {
  await verifyCsrf(req, res, async () => {
      const data = doSomething();
      res.status(200).json(data);
    });
}