Why TDD Feels Like a Trap (Sometimes): A Rant

sanket pathak — Mon, 07 Apr 2025 14:02:04 +0000

I come from a consulting background, having worked with companies similar to TW. Naturally, TDD was drilled into our brains. I’m well-versed with it.

For those unfamiliar, Test-Driven Development (TDD) flips the usual process: instead of writing code first and tests later, you write the test first—watch it fail—then write just enough code to make it pass. Rinse, repeat.

There are some solid advantages:

It forces you to focus on the input/output contract of functions.
You tend to write only the necessary code to pass the test—promoting cleaner, leaner implementations.
You think through edge cases before jumping into implementation.

Sounds clean, right?
But even after trying it seriously, I find myself not loving it. Here's why:

When clarity is missing, it's hard to TDD. At early stages of dev, I often don’t know the exact input/output—I’m still exploring the shape of the problem.
It demands iteration. Write a test. Make it pass. Refactor. Repeat. But in real-world scenarios with time pressure and legacy systems, this ideal workflow can feel like a luxury.
For known problems, where I already know what to build, TDD sometimes feels like a ceremony for ceremony’s sake. When you already have clarity, writing the code first is simply faster and more intuitive.
Mild OCD here. I hate seeing red tests or compilation errors, even temporarily. It bugs me more than it should, but it does affect my focus.

Recently, in an interview, I mentioned that I prefer writing code first and testing later—and that it's a controversial take. The interviewer laughed, said “Yeah, that’s controversial,” and shut down the conversation without hearing me out.

That rubbed me the wrong way. Not because I wasn’t challenged—I'm open to being wrong—but because it felt dismissive.
So, fellow devs: Am I missing something here? Are these real drawbacks, or am I just bad at sticking to the process?

Would love to hear what other folks think.

First post

sanket pathak — Thu, 15 Oct 2020 08:19:34 +0000

What I Learned From Hacktoberfest

Well It was my first hacktober fest and I quite enjoyed it.

DEV Community: sanket pathak

Why TDD Feels Like a Trap (Sometimes): A Rant

First post

What I Learned From Hacktoberfest