Working on an international project has its unique set of challenges and opportunities. Our current project involves a frontend application leveraging a Backend for Frontend (BFF) pattern running on a kubernetes (k8s) cluster and a robust backend infrastructure on AWS. We employ a variety of AWS resources, including DynamoDB, Step Functions, Lambda Functions, and CloudWatch, among others. However, among these advanced cloud solutions, I have encountered several frustrations that stem from the over-complication of software design.
The Over-Engineering of Cloud Solutions
One of the primary issues I have observed is the tendency of developers to become addicted with cloud solutions, leading to overly complex, heavily layered, and tightly coupled architectures. This obsession with cloud technology often results in systems that are not only slow but also significantly prevent the Developer Experience (DX).
A Case in Point: Error Notification Workflow
To illustrate, let's look into a specific scenario from our project. We have a Step Function that eventually triggers a Lambda function. This Lambda performs several validations and throws an exception in case of an error. Our goal was to notify a chat service whenever this Lambda encounters an error. The solution designed for this apparently simple requirement turned out to be unnecessarily convoluted:
- Lambda Error Handling: The Lambda function executes and throws an exception if it encounters an error during validation.
- CloudWatch Alarm: If the Lambda throws five exceptions within a specified timeframe, a CloudWatch Alarm is triggered.
- SNS Notification: The CloudWatch Alarm publishes a message to an Amazon Simple Notification Service (SNS) topic.
- Lambda Subscriber: Another Lambda function subscribes to the SNS topic, receiving the alarm notification.
- Chat Notification: Finally, this Lambda function sends the alert to the chat service.
The Issues with Over-Engineering
This elaborate workflow, while functional, exemplifies the pitfalls of over-engineering:
- Complexity: The multi-step process introduces unnecessary complexity, making the system harder to understand, maintain, and troubleshoot.
- Latency: Each step in the process adds latency, which can lead to slower response times.
- Tight Coupling: The design is tightly coupled to AWS services, making it challenging to migrate or adapt to other environments.
- Poor Developer Experience (DX): The intricate setup detracts from the overall developer experience, leading to frustration and reduced productivity.
Simplifying for Better Developer Experience
In hindsight, a simpler approach could have been more effective. The entire cloud backend suits well in a k8s micro-service...but it is also a good story for another day.
Conclusion
While cloud solutions offer powerful tools for building scalable and resilient systems, it's crucial to balance their use with simplicity and developer experience in mind. Over-complication not only hampers performance but also detracts from the overall efficiency and satisfaction of the development process. As developers, we must strive to design systems that are not only functional but also elegant and easy to maintain.
By sharing these experiences, I hope to encourage a more mindful approach to software design, where simplicity and developer experience are given the consideration they deserve.
Feel free to share your thoughts and experiences on this topic in the comments below. Let's continue the conversation and work towards more efficient and developer-friendly solutions.
Photo by Scott Rodgerson on Unsplash
Top comments (0)