Yes, hooks do that because a reconciler requires it, but it's not a law that you must obtain new values all the time even if nothing changed and certainly a deviation from reactive patterns – which is why doing things different makes for great performance and even more control in your reactive code. There's a reason solid's primitives are called differently than react's hooks: to avoid confusion.
The issue I see here is that you have some preconceived notions about how things should work that are clashing with the improvements made by solid and therefore you don't like it. That's fine, everyone is entitled to an opinion. But that's all it is.
I clearly know the good and bad of each framework. Neither solidjs nor svelte can guarantee the absolute unity of semantics. This is a fact, not my preconception.
In addition, even so, solidjs has made remarkable improvements in many aspects, which I don't deny.
Good and bad are merely subjective value judgements. And as I already remarked, you see a division where there is none because you are used to a different concept. Neither your judgement nor your views are a fact.
For further actions, you may consider blocking this person and/or reporting abuse
We're a place where coders share, stay up-to-date and grow their careers.
I think you should have a look at Ryan's reply.
Yes, hooks do that because a reconciler requires it, but it's not a law that you must obtain new values all the time even if nothing changed and certainly a deviation from reactive patterns – which is why doing things different makes for great performance and even more control in your reactive code. There's a reason solid's primitives are called differently than react's hooks: to avoid confusion.
The issue I see here is that you have some preconceived notions about how things should work that are clashing with the improvements made by solid and therefore you don't like it. That's fine, everyone is entitled to an opinion. But that's all it is.
I clearly know the good and bad of each framework. Neither solidjs nor svelte can guarantee the absolute unity of semantics. This is a fact, not my preconception.
In addition, even so, solidjs has made remarkable improvements in many aspects, which I don't deny.
Good and bad are merely subjective value judgements. And as I already remarked, you see a division where there is none because you are used to a different concept. Neither your judgement nor your views are a fact.