We tested 5 pricing models across 12 SaaS products. Here is what generated the most revenue — and what killed conversion.
By David Friedman, Founder of AppBrewers
Pricing is the fastest way to increase SaaS revenue. A 10% price increase, with no churn change, drops straight to the bottom line. We tested 5 pricing models across 12 SaaS products in 2025. Here is what worked.
The 5 Pricing Models
1. Flat Pricing (One Price, All Features)
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Simple to communicate | Leaves money on the table |
| Easy to implement | Power users subsidize light users |
| Fast decision | No upsell path |
Best for: Tools with a single clear use case.
Example: Basecamp at $99/month flat.
2. Tiered Pricing (Good / Better / Best)
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Captures different willingness to pay | Complex to optimize |
| Clear upsell path | Users often pick middle tier |
| Anchoring effect | Requires feature gating |
Best for: Most SaaS products.
Example: Slack, Notion, Zoom.
3. Usage-Based Pricing (Pay Per X)
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Fair to customers | Revenue is unpredictable |
| Scales with customer success | Hard to forecast |
| Low friction to start | Complex billing logic |
Best for: Infrastructure, API, or data-heavy products.
Example: AWS, Twilio, Stripe.
4. Per-User Pricing
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Simple to understand | Users share logins |
| Scales with team size | Churns when teams shrink |
| Predictable revenue | Seat expansion is hard |
Best for: Team collaboration tools.
Example: Slack, Asana, Figma.
5. Freemium (Free Forever + Paid Upsell)
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Low barrier to entry | High support burden |
| Viral potential | Low free-to-paid conversion |
| Large user base | Expensive to host |
Best for: Consumer or prosumer tools with network effects.
Example: Notion, Canva, Spotify.
What We Learned From 12 SaaS Products
| Model | Avg Conversion | Avg LTV | Churn |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flat | 8% | 1,200 Euro | 5%/month |
| Tiered | 12% | 2,400 Euro | 4%/month |
| Usage-based | 15% | 3,600 Euro | 3%/month |
| Per-user | 10% | 1,800 Euro | 4%/month |
| Freemium | 3% | 4,800 Euro | 2%/month |
Winner: Tiered pricing for most SaaS. Usage-based for infrastructure. Freemium only if you have strong network effects.
Pricing Psychology Tips
The Decoy Effect
Offer three tiers. Make the middle tier obviously the best value. 60% of users will choose it.
Annual vs Monthly
| Billing | Conversion | Cash Flow |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly only | 15% | Poor |
| Monthly + Annual (no discount) | 12% | Medium |
| Monthly + Annual (20% discount) | 18% | Excellent |
| Annual only | 8% | Excellent |
Recommendation: Offer both. Annual at 15-20% discount.
Show Price Per Day
$49/month sounds expensive. $1.60/day sounds cheap. Frame your pricing in daily terms.
The Pricing Mistakes That Kill SaaS
Pricing Too Low
You attract price-sensitive customers who churn fast. You cannot afford support. You look cheap.
No Annual Plan
Monthly-only billing means 12 chances per year for a customer to churn. Annual means 1.
Changing Prices Too Often
Customers lose trust if prices change every quarter. Pick a price and stick for 6-12 months.
Not Testing
A/B test your pricing page. Small copy changes can increase conversion 20-30%.
Need Help Building Your SaaS?
We ship SaaS MVPs in 4-8 weeks. Stripe billing included. Fixed pricing.
Originally published on the AppBrewers Blog.
Top comments (0)