I Compared 6 Dunning Tools for Stripe SaaS -- Here's What I Found

If you run a Stripe-based SaaS, you're losing revenue to failed payments. The question is: which tool do you use to get it back?

I looked at 6 dunning/payment recovery tools and compared them on price, features, and setup complexity. Here's what I found.

The contenders

Tool	Starting Price	Pricing Model
Rebill	$19/mo	Flat monthly
ChurnWard	$29/mo	Flat monthly
Baremetrics Recover	$58/mo	Flat monthly
Stunning	$99/mo	Flat monthly
Churn Buster	$249/mo	Flat monthly
Paddle Retain	~2-4% of recovered	Revenue share

Feature comparison

Feature	Rebill	ChurnWard	Baremetrics	Stunning	Churn Buster	Paddle Retain
Dunning emails	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Custom templates	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Limited
Analytics	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Expiring card alerts	Yes	No	No	No	Yes	No
Win-back campaigns	Yes	No	No	No	No	No
API access	Pro plan	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes
Stripe Connect setup	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No*
Setup time	2 min	5 min	10 min	10 min	15 min	Days**

*Paddle Retain requires migrating to Paddle as your billing provider.
**Migration to Paddle is a multi-day process involving code changes.

My take on each

Rebill ($19/mo)

The newest player. Full-featured for the price: dunning sequences, expiring card alerts, win-back campaigns, and analytics. Connects via Stripe Connect in about 30 seconds. The Pro plan at $39/mo adds API access, white-label emails, and unlimited Stripe accounts. Also offers a $59 lifetime deal for early adopters.

Best for: SaaS companies that want full dunning features without paying enterprise prices.

ChurnWard ($29/mo)

Simple and focused. Sends dunning emails when payments fail. No analytics dashboard, no custom templates, no expiring card alerts. Gets the basic job done.

Best for: Solo founders who just want basic dunning and nothing else.

Baremetrics Recover ($58/mo)

Part of the Baremetrics analytics suite. Good dunning emails and analytics, but no expiring card alerts or win-back campaigns. The analytics are great if you're already a Baremetrics customer.

Best for: Existing Baremetrics customers who want to add recovery.

Stunning ($99/mo)

Solid mid-tier option with dunning emails, custom templates, and analytics. No expiring card alerts though, which means you're only recovering failures instead of preventing them.

Best for: Mid-size SaaS that wants a proven tool and doesn't mind the price.

Churn Buster ($249/mo)

The established player. Full-featured with dunning, analytics, custom templates, and expiring card alerts. But at $249/mo, the ROI math gets harder for smaller SaaS companies. No win-back campaigns.

Best for: Larger SaaS companies ($50K+ MRR) where $249/mo is noise.

Paddle Retain (2-4% of recovered)

Formerly ProfitWell Retain, now part of Paddle. The revenue share model means you pay nothing if you recover nothing, but costs scale with success. The catch: you need to be on Paddle's billing platform, which means migrating away from Stripe.

Best for: Companies already on Paddle. Not practical if you're on Stripe.

The bottom line

For most Stripe-based SaaS companies under $50K MRR, the sweet spot is a tool in the $19-$99/month range. You're looking for:

1. Dunning email sequences (must have)
2. Analytics dashboard (should have)
3. Expiring card alerts (nice to have)
4. Win-back campaigns (bonus)
5. Quick Stripe setup (must have)

The most expensive tool isn't necessarily the best. Compare features against your actual needs, not brand name.

---

Disclaimer: I built Rebill, so I'm obviously biased. But the comparison data above is accurate and I encourage you to verify. Try the free churn calculator to see how much failed payments are costing you.