re: How do you manage deployment configs? (Especially large scale cloud agnostic ones) VIEW POST


Sounds like you need to start working on simplifying the problem before you can start simplifying the solution.

I say that 👆🏽 because your title question was "how to manage deployment configs?" with emphasis on managing the configuration files, which in my opinion in itself is an interesting problem.

But as I read further it sounds more like the real question is... How do you perform multi-cloud deployments with various tooling and tech with a small team?

And... if that's the problem at hand then:

  • Complex solution: spinnaker might be a viable option, but it adds yet another tech layer to learn and use. Definitely solves multi-cloud deployments at scale, the tradeoff is... probably not the best fit for a "small team" (small being relative 🤷🏽‍♂️. I have no idea what you mean by small 3 or 300 people). Spinnaker can be a job in itself-- deploying, maintaining, and admining.

  • Quick solution: Hire or promote more people to be SME (subject matter experts) for each respective cloud and tech stack deployment. I say quick because I think of this more as a short term solution to either get things stable or to buy more time for business reasons. But personally in my opinion, the ROI of man power to productivity is a bad tradeoff. Plus more cooks in the kitchen and all that... which has high potential of creating more problems especially over time. I think of this more as a bandaid and is dependent on circumstance of time and resources.

  • Simple solution: Prune cloud support, prune tooling and technologies. I understand this is wayyy easier said than done--incredibly hard to implement/migrate to... but if you don't foresee an increase in man power (people count) you would see a a huge ROI on people to productivity and quality deployments.


Hmm might be lack of clarity on my part. It is still mainly a "config" issue more than a multi-cloud issue.

The multi-cloud part just multiplies the problem by forcing multiple tools to be used.

X servers, with their IP and configs (like certificates), needing to be passed along to Y servers in another cloud environment. The problem between the permutation and combination of configuration settings of X*Y*Z, would still have a problem (abit greatly simplified) if it's within a single cloud provider on a larger scale.


Ah gotcha...

Yes as aforementioned 👇🏽

"with emphasis on managing the configuration files, which in my opinion in itself is an interesting problem."

So far "generally" speaking yaml files with interpolation is a safe suggestion. Otherwise there's always machine learning to predict the interpolation 😆

code of conduct - report abuse