DEV Community

Shiva Charan
Shiva Charan

Posted on

Waterfall Model & Its Failure

  • Waterfall is a linear, phase-gated software delivery model where work flows downward through fixed stages, and each stage must be completed before the next begins.
  • It was designed for predictability, not speed.

Definition

  • Waterfall is a sequential software delivery model where each phase is completed once, changes are costly, and feedback arrives late.

The Waterfall Phases

Requirements
    ↓
Design
    ↓
Development
    ↓
Testing
    ↓
Deployment
    ↓
Maintenance
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Each phase is:

  • Completed once
  • Signed off
  • Locked before moving forward

No looping back without formal change requests.


Why Waterfall Made Sense (Historically)

Waterfall worked well when:

  • Software requirements were stable
  • Releases were rare
  • Systems were simple
  • Hardware was expensive
  • Changes were risky

Industries like:

  • Government
  • Banking
  • Defense
  • Telecom

used it heavily because control and documentation mattered more than speed.


How Work Actually Happened

Requirements

  • Business wrote large requirement documents
  • Assumed full clarity upfront
  • Changes were discouraged

Design

  • Architects produced detailed designs
  • Decisions were frozen early
  • Future assumptions were baked in

Development

  • Dev implemented based on specs
  • Minimal user feedback
  • Problems surfaced late

Testing

  • Testing happened near the end
  • Bug fixes were expensive
  • Time pressure was extreme

Deployment

  • Manual, risky
  • Often after months or years
  • Rollbacks were painful

Core Characteristics

Aspect Waterfall
Flow Linear
Feedback Late
Change cost High
Release size Large
Risk discovery End of cycle
Automation Minimal

Why Waterfall Fails for Modern Software

1️⃣ Assumes Requirements Will Not Change

They always do.

2️⃣ Delays Feedback

Bugs and design flaws appear too late.

3️⃣ Encourages Big Bang Releases

Large blast radius, hard rollback.

4️⃣ Separates Builders from Operators

Developers rarely see production issues.

5️⃣ Optimizes for Documentation Over Outcomes

You can follow the process and still fail users.


Relationship to DevOps

Waterfall is not evil. It is misused.

Problems arose when:

  • Waterfall delivery
  • Plus functional silos
  • Plus manual operations
  • Plus frequent business change

DevOps emerged to fix what Waterfall could not:

  • Continuous feedback
  • Automation
  • Shared ownership

The Harsh Truth.

Waterfall fails not because people are bad, but because it assumes certainty in a world that is uncertain.

Top comments (0)