Java Nested Classes and Lambda Expressions

[Java WIL🤔 Post #2]

Java has a very rich set of features that gives developers a lot of options to choose their implementation from, two of them, nested classes and lambda expressions.

I was reading a certain part of a code base and realized that I have not really fully understood the differences between the types of nested classes. The section below is heavily based from the Java Documentation for Nested Classes, so in-depth explanations can be checked here.

Table Of Contents

• Nested Classes
• Why Use Nested Classes
• Inner Classes
• Static Nested Classes
• Shadowing in Nested Classes
• Serialization of Nested Classes
• Local and Anonymous Classes
• Lambda Expressions
• Functional Interface
• Target Typing In Lambdas
• Method References
• When to Use Nested Classes, Local Classes, Anonymous Classes and Lambda Expressions

📌 Nested Classes

A nested class is a class within another class, i.e. a member of its enclosing class. It is divided into two categories: non-static and static.

1. Non-static nested classes are called inner classes. They have access to other members of the enclosing class, even if they are declared private.
2. Nested classes that are declared static are called static nested classes. They DO NOT have access to other members of the enclosing class.
3. As a member of the outer class, a nested class can be declared private, public, protected or package-private.
4. Note that outer classes can only be declared public or package-private.

📌 Why Use Nested Classes

1. It is a way of logically grouping classes that are only used in one place.
2. It increases encapsulation.
3. It can lead to more readable and maintainable code.

📌 Inner Classes

1. An inner class is associated with an instance of its enclosing class and has direct access to that object's methods and fields.
2. As an inner class is associated with an instance, IT CANNOT DEFINE ANY STATIC MEMBERS ITSELF..
3. Objects that are instances of an inner class exist within an instance of the outer class. Thus an instance of an inner class can only exist within an instance of the outer class and has direct access to the methods and fields of the enclosing instance.
4. To instantiate an inner class, the outer class must first be instantiated.
5. There are two special kinds of inner classes: local classes and anonymous classes.

public class OuterClass {
    private class InnerClass {
        // class content here
    }
}

📌 Static Nested Classes

1. As with class methods, a static nested class is associated with its outer class.
2. A static nested class cannot refer directly to instance variables or methods defined in its enclosing class. It can use them only through an object reference.
3. A static nested class interacts with the instance members of its outer class and other classes just like any other top level class. Thus a static nested class is behaviorally a top-level class that has been nested in another top-level class for packaging convenience.

public class OuterClass {
    static class StaticNestedClass {
       // class contents here
    }
}

📌 Shadowing in Nested Classes

1. If a declaration of a type in a particular scope has the same name as another declaration in the enclosing scope, then the declaration shadows the declaration of the enclosing scope.
2. The shadowed declaration cannot be referenced by its name alone. Note, you can actually do this : ShadowTest.this.x. Go to shadowing section of this link.
3. Refer to member variables that enclose larger scopes by the class name to which they belong. For example, the ff. statement accesses the member variable of the class ShadowTest from the method.

System.out.println("ShadowTest.this.x = " + ShadowTest.this.x);

📌 Serialization

1. Serialization of inner classes, including local and anonymous classes is strongly discouraged. When the Java compiler compiles certain constructs such as inner classes, it creates synthetic constructs; these are classes, methods, fields and other constructs that do not have a corresponding construct in the source code. Synthetic constructs enable Java compilers to implement new Java language features without changes to the JVM. However, they may vary among different implementations.
2. Might have compatibility issues if an inner class is serialized and then deserialize it with a different JRE implementation.
3. Read more at the Serialization section of this link

📌 Local and Anonymous Classes

1. There are two types of inner classes : local and anonymous. An inner class within the body of a method is called a local class. An inner class can also be declared inside the body of a method without naming them, i.e. an anonymous class.
2. The same modifiers used for other members of the outer class can be used for an inner class. For instance the access modifiers private, public, package-private protected can be used in an inner class just like how they are used for the instance fields of the outer class.

📌 More on Local Classes

public class SomeClass {
    public void someMethod() {
        class SomeLocalClass {
            // class contents here
        }
    }
}

1. Local classes are classes defined in a block, which is a group of zero or more statements.
2. Local classes can be defined inside any block, i.e. in a method body, a for loop or an if clause.
3. A local class has access to the members of its enclosing class. It also has access to local variables.
4. IMPORTANT: A local class can only access local variables that are declared final. When a local class accesses a local variable or parameter of the enclosing block, it captures the variable or parameter.
5. Starting Java 8, a local class can access local variables and parameters of the enclosing block that are final or effectively final. A variable or parameter whose value is never changed after it is initialized is effectively final.
6. Starting also in Java SE 8, if you declare the local class in a method, it can access the method's parameters.
7. Local classes are similar to inner classes because they cannot define or declare any static members.
8. Local classes in static methods, can only refer static members of the enclosing classes.
9. Local classes are non-static because they have access to instance members of the enclosing block. Consequently they cannot contain most kinds of static declarations.
10. An interface cannot be declared inside a block. Interfaces are inherently static.
11. Static initializers or member interfaces cannot be declared inside a local class.
12. A local class can have static members provided that they are constant variables. A constant variable is a variable of primitive type or type String that is declared final and initialized with a compile-time constant expression. A compile time constant expression is typically a string or an arithmetic expression that can be evaluated at compile time.

📌 Anonymous Classes

    SomeAnonyMousClass anonClass = new SomeAnonyMousClass(){
        // instance field declarations
        // methods 
        // should contain no constructor
    };

1. Anonymous classes makes the code more concise. It enables declaration and instantiation of class at the same time. They are similar to local classes except that they do not have a name.
2. While local classes are class declaration, anonymous classes are expressions, which means that the class is defined in another expression.
3. The syntax of an anonymous class expression is like the invocation of a constructor, except that there is a class definition contained in the code block.

HelloWorld helloWorld = new HelloWorld() {
  // code here
};

1. The anonymous class expression consists of the following: new operator, the name of an interface to implement or a class to extend, parentheses that contain the arguments to a constructor, just like a normal class instance creation expression and a body, which is a class declaration body.
2. Because an anonymous class definition is an expression, it must be part of a statement. This explains why there is a semicolon after the closing brace.

📌 Accessing Local Variables of the Enclosing Scope and Declaring and Accessing Members of the Anonymous Class

1. Like local classes, anonymous classes can capture variables; they have the same access to local variables of the enclosing scope.
2. An anonymous class has access to the members of its enclosing class.
3. An anonymous class cannot access local variables in its enclosing scope that are not declared as final or effectively final.
4. Like a nested class, a declaration of a type in an anonymous class shadows any other declarations in the enclosing scope that have the same name.
5. Anonymous classes also have the same restrictions as local classes with respect to their members: static initializers or member interfaces cannot be declared; an anonymous class can have static members provided that they are constant variables.
6. Note, the ff can be declared in anonymous class a. Fields b. extra methods c. instance initializers d. local classes
7. IMPORTANT: You cannot declare constructors in an anonymous class.
8. Anonymous classes are ideal for implementing an interface that contains two or more methods.

To summarize the hierarchy stated above, the image below shows the types of nested classes.

📌 Lambda Expressions

1. Lambda Expressions enables developers to treat functionality as a method argument, or code as a data.
2. For classes with only one method, an anonymous class, much more a named class is a bit excessive and cumbersome. Lambdas express instances of single-method classes more compactly.

📌 Syntax of Lambda Expressions

A lambda expression consists of the ff.

• A comma-separated list of formal parameters enclosed in parentheses. The data type of the parameters in the lambda expression can be omitted. Moreover, the parentheses can be omitted if there is only one parameter.
• The arrow token ->
• The body which consists of a single expression or a statement block. The return statement can also be used, however, keep in mind that a return statement is not an expression in lambdas, so they must be enclosed in braces. Lambdas can be treated as anonymous methods - methods without names. For instance,

p -> p.getAge() >= 18
    && p.getAge() <= 25

📌 Functional Interface

A functional interface is any interface that contains only one abstract method. It may contain one or more default methods or static methods. Because it only contains one abstract method, the name can be omitted when implementing it. By doing this instead of using an anonymous class expression, a lambda expression is used. The JDK defines several standard functional interfaces which can be found in the package java.util.function.

📌 Accessing Local Variables of the Enclosing Scope in Lambda Expressions

1. Like local and anonymous classes, lambdas can capture variables; they have the same access to local variables of the enclosing scope. However, unlike local and anonymous classes, lambdas do not have shadowing issues.
2. Lambdas are lexically scoped. This means that they do not inherit any names from a supertype or introduce a new level of scoping. Declarations in lambdas are interpreted just as they are in the enclosing environment.
3. If the parameter passed to a lambda is declared in the enclosing scope, then the compiler generates an error, Lambda expression's parameter {} cannot redeclare another local variable defined in an enclosing scope. This is because lambda expressions do not introduce a new level of scoping. Consequently, lambdas can directly access fields, methods and local variables of the enclosing scope.
4. Like local and anonymous classes, a lambda expression can only access local variables and parameters of the enclosing block that are final or effectively final (value should not be changed after initialization).

📌 Target Typing in Lambdas

So how can the type of a lambda expression be determined, e.g. the type of p in the example below?

p -> p.getAge() < 18

When the Java runtime invokes the method where the lambda is passed, it is expecting a specific datatype, so the lambda expression is of this type.The data type that these methods expect is called the target type. To determine the type of a lambda expression, the Java compiler uses the target type of the context or situation in which the lambda expression was found. Thus, lambda expressions can only be used in situation in which the Java compiler can determine the target type, i.e. in :

• variable declarations
• assignments
• return statements
• array initializers
• method or constructor arguments
• lambda expression bodies
• conditional expressions
• cast expressions

📌 Target Types and Method Arguments

For method arguments, the Java compiler determines the target type with two other language features overload resolution and type argument interface.

For instance, if the functional interfaces java.lang.Runnable and java.util.Callable<V> are implemented and overloaded by a certain class like this,

void invoke(Runnable r) {
    r.run();
}

<T> T invoke(Callable<T> c) {
    return c.call();
}

Which method will be invoked by the statement below?

String s = invoke(() -> "done");

The method with argument Callable<V> will be invoked because the lambda returns a value, in this case the string done. Note that the method invoke(Runnable) does not return a value.

📌 Serialization of Lambdas

A lambda can be serialized if its target type and its captured arguments are serializable. However, like inner classes, 🛑 the serialization of lambdas are strongly discouraged.

📌 Method References

Lambdas can be used to create anonymous methods. However, there are times when it does nothing but call an existing method. In these cases, it is often clearer to refer to the existing method by name, called method referencing. They are compact, easy-to-read lambdas for methods that already have a name.
For instance this can be done in sorting an array of Person objects by age.

Arrays.sort(personListAsArray, Person::compareByAge);

The method reference Person::compareByAge is semantically the same as the lambda expression where compareByAge is a static method of the Person class.

(person1, person2) -> Person.compareByAge(person1, person1)

Kinds of Method References

There are four types of method referencing

Kind	Syntax	Example
Reference to a static method	ContainingClass::staticMethodName	Person::compareByAge
Reference to an instance method of a particular object	containingObject::instanceMethodName	person1::compareByName
Reference to an instance method of an arbitrary object of a particular type	ContainingType::methodName	String::concat
Reference to a constructor	ClassName::new	HashSet::new

📌 When to Use Nested Classes, Local Classes, Anonymous Classes and Lambda Expressions

Nested Classes enable the logical grouping of classes that are only used in one place, increase the use of encapsulation, create more readable and maintainable code. Local classes, anonymous classes and lambda expressions also share the same advantages but they are usually used for more specific situations:

• Local Class . Used if creating more than one instance of a class is needed, access its constructor and/or introduce a new, named type.
• Anonymous Class . Used if declared fields or additional methods are needed

• Lambda Expressions .

  • Used for encapsulating a single unit of behavior that is passed to the other parts of the code.
  • Used if a simple instance of a functional interface is needed and some other criteria like constructor, named type, fields or additional methods are not needed

• Nested Class . Used for reasons similar to those of local classes, i.e. it is necessary to make the type more widely available, and access to local variables or method parameters are not needed.

  • Inner class should be used if access to an enclosing instance's non-public fields and methods are required.
  • Static class should be used if there is no instance field that needs to be accessed from the class.

Getting used and familiar with nested classes and advanced lambdas with generics certainly takes a lot of reading code and practice. We will eventually get there.

As always, cheers to continued growth and learning 🍷!

REFERENCES

[1] Java Nested Classes
[2] Nested Classes in Java