You've spent three hours building a GA4 dashboard. It has 17 metrics, color-coded charts, and a beautiful layout. Your boss looked at it once, said "interesting," and never opened it again.
Sound familiar?
Here's the thing: GA4 gives you access to roughly 47 million data points (okay, slight exaggeration, but have you seen that interface?). The problem isn't getting data—it's figuring out which 5-7 metrics actually matter for your business. Everything else is just noise that makes you feel productive while accomplishing nothing.
I've built dozens of GA4 dashboards over the past two years. Most of them were terrible. A few actually changed how companies made decisions. The difference wasn't technical complexity—it was ruthless focus on what drives action.
Why Most GA4 Dashboards Fail
Let's start with the uncomfortable truth: your stakeholders don't care about your metrics.
They care about their problems. The marketing director needs to know if the rebrand is working. The product team wants to understand why signups dropped last month. The CEO is wondering if that $50K conference sponsorship was worth it.
Your dashboard showing "engaged sessions" and "average engagement time" answers none of these questions. It just makes everyone nod thoughtfully in meetings while privately wondering what any of it means.
The second reason dashboards fail? They're built backwards. Most people open GA4, get overwhelmed by the options, and start adding every metric that sounds important. Then they wonder why nobody uses the dashboard.
Professional dashboards work differently. They start with a specific business question and work backwards to the metrics that answer it.
The Framework That Actually Works
Forget everything you know about "comprehensive" reporting. (Translation: forget the dashboard with 23 widgets that takes 8 seconds to load and answers zero questions.)
Here's the framework:
Step 1: Identify the actual decision
Not "track website performance." That's not a decision. "Determine which traffic source to increase budget for" is a decision. "Identify which product pages need content updates" is a decision.
Write down the specific action someone will take based on this data. If you can't articulate it, you're building the wrong dashboard.
Step 2: Define success metrics (maximum 3)
Three metrics. That's it.
Yes, you could track 15 things. You could also read every email in your inbox, but we both know you're not going to do that either. Pick the three numbers that most directly indicate whether the decision was right or wrong.
For an e-commerce site deciding on traffic sources: conversion rate by source, revenue per session by source, and customer acquisition cost by source. Everything else is supporting context.
Step 3: Add context layers (not more metrics)
Context isn't the same as additional metrics. Context is the stuff that helps you interpret the three metrics you already have.
Time comparisons (week over week, month over month). Segmentation by user type (new vs. returning). Filtering by specific campaigns or product categories. These don't add new numbers—they help you understand the numbers you have.
Step 4: Build for scanning, not studying
If someone needs more than 30 seconds to understand your dashboard, it's too complex. Period.
Use comparison cards for your main metrics. Add a simple line chart showing the trend. Include a table only if people need to drill into specific segments. That's it. Save the fancy visualizations for the presentation deck.
Setting Up Custom Reports in GA4
Now for the actual mechanics. GA4's interface is... let's call it "feature-rich." The good news is you only need to master about 20% of it to build effective dashboards.
Explorations vs. Reports vs. Looker Studio
GA4 gives you three ways to build custom reporting, and choosing the wrong one wastes hours.
Standard Reports are fast but inflexible. Use them when you need quick answers to common questions. They're perfect for daily check-ins but terrible for custom analysis.
Explorations are GA4's built-in custom reporting tool. They're more flexible than standard reports but live inside GA4 (which means sharing them is awkward). Use explorations when you're the primary user and need to dig into data regularly.
Looker Studio (formerly Data Studio) connects to GA4 and gives you full design control. It's the right choice for dashboards that multiple stakeholders access regularly. The learning curve is steeper, but the output is actually shareable.
For most business-critical dashboards, Looker Studio wins. For personal analysis, explorations are faster.
Building Your First Useful Exploration
Let's build something specific: a dashboard that answers "Which blog posts are actually driving conversions?"
In GA4, navigate to Explore and create a new Free Form exploration. Here's what you need:
Dimensions:
- Page path and screen class (this is your blog post URL)
- Session source/medium (where the traffic came from)
- Device category (because mobile behavior is different)
Metrics:
- Sessions (total traffic)
- Conversions (whatever you've defined as a conversion)
- Conversion rate (the ratio that actually matters)
- Average engagement time (context for content quality)
Drag page path to rows. Add your metrics as values. Sort by conversions descending.
Congratulations. You now know which blog posts drive actual business results, not just which ones get traffic. This is the kind of insight that changes content strategy.
Custom Dimensions You Actually Need
GA4's default dimensions miss some critical business context. Here's what to add:
User Type Beyond New vs. Returning
Set up a custom dimension for customer status: prospect, customer, high-value customer. This requires passing data from your CRM or database, but it transforms your analysis. Suddenly you can see which marketing channels attract customers vs. tire-kickers.
Content Category
If you publish content, create a dimension for content type or category. Blog posts, product pages, landing pages, resource content—each behaves differently. Lumping them together obscures what's actually working.
Campaign Intent
UTM parameters tell you the campaign name. They don't tell you if it was a brand awareness campaign, lead generation, or direct response. Add a custom dimension that tags intent, and your attribution analysis gets 10x more useful.
Setting these up requires some technical implementation (usually through Google Tag Manager), but the payoff is enormous. Without this context, you're analyzing data with one eye closed.
The Metrics That Actually Matter
Time for some tough love: most metrics in GA4 are vanity metrics dressed up as insights.
Pageviews? Great, people looked at your page. Did they do anything? Bounce rate is gone in GA4 (replaced by "engagement rate"), and honestly, good riddance—it never told you much anyway.
Here's what to track instead:
Conversion Rate by Segment
Not overall conversion rate. That number is useless. Conversion rate by traffic source, by device, by user type, by content category. The segments are where you find actionable insights.
If your mobile conversion rate is 60% of desktop, you have a mobile experience problem. If organic search converts at 8% and paid search at 2%, you have a targeting problem (or possibly a landing page problem).
Revenue Per Session
For e-commerce, this metric cuts through the noise. High traffic with low revenue per session? You're attracting the wrong audience. Low traffic with high revenue per session? You have a traffic volume problem, not a quality problem.
This metric also helps you value different traffic sources accurately. A source with 100 sessions at $50 revenue per session beats a source with 500 sessions at $8 revenue per session. Obvious in hindsight, invisible if you're only looking at session counts.
Time to Conversion
GA4 tracks this in the conversion paths report, and it's criminally underused. How long does it take people to convert after their first visit?
If 80% of conversions happen within 24 hours, you need strong first-visit experiences. If the average is 14 days, you need nurture sequences and remarketing. Different insights, different strategies.
Engagement Rate (With Caveats)
GA4 defines an engaged session as lasting longer than 10 seconds, having a conversion event, or having 2+ page views. It's imperfect, but it's better than the old bounce rate.
Use it as a content quality signal. If a blog post has 5,000 sessions but a 20% engagement rate, something's wrong—probably the headline promises something the content doesn't deliver. If another post has 500 sessions and an 85% engagement rate, you've found something worth promoting.
Just don't obsess over the absolute number. The trends and comparisons matter more.
Building Dashboards for Different Stakeholders
The dashboard for your CEO should not look like the dashboard for your content team. Different roles, different decisions, different metrics.
Executive Dashboard: The 60-Second Version
Executives need to know if things are generally getting better or worse. That's it. Save the nuance for the follow-up conversation.
- Total conversions (month over month)
- Revenue or leads (month over month)
- Cost per acquisition (if you have ad spend data)
- One trend chart showing the primary metric over the past 6 months
Add a text box with 2-3 bullet points of context. "Traffic down 12% but conversion rate up 18%, net positive revenue." Done.
Anything more detailed and you've lost them.
Marketing Team Dashboard: Channel Performance
Your marketing team needs to know what's working so they can do more of it.
- Conversions by source/medium
- Conversion rate by source/medium
- Assisted conversions (GA4's attribution reports)
- New vs. returning user breakdown by channel
Include week-over-week trends. Marketing moves fast, and monthly comparisons miss important shifts.
Add a table showing campaign-level performance for the current month. This is where you can include more detail because these are the people who will actually use it.
Content Team Dashboard: What Resonates
Content teams need to understand what content drives engagement and conversions.
- Top pages by engaged sessions
- Conversion rate by content category
- Average engagement time by content type
- Traffic sources to content (are you attracting the right audience?)
Add a section showing new content performance separately from evergreen content. They behave differently and require different optimization strategies.
Common GA4 Reporting Mistakes
Let's talk about what not to do, because I've done all of these and they're all terrible.
Mistake #1: Tracking everything because you might need it later
No. You won't. You'll never look at 80% of those metrics. They just make your dashboard slow and confusing. Be ruthless about what you include.
Mistake #2: Comparing metrics that aren't comparable
Comparing this November to last November makes sense. Comparing November to October doesn't—seasonal patterns matter. GA4 makes it easy to add any date comparison, but not all comparisons are meaningful.
Mistake #3: Ignoring data thresholds
GA4 applies data thresholds when user counts are low to protect privacy. That's fine, but it means some of your segmented data might be hidden. If you're seeing gaps in reports, thresholds are probably why. You can't disable them, so plan your segments accordingly.
Mistake #4: Building dashboards before defining goals
I mentioned this earlier, but it's worth repeating because everyone does it. Opening GA4 and exploring data is fun. It's also how you end up with dashboards that answer questions nobody asked.
Start with the decision. Work backwards to the data.
Making Dashboards People Actually Use
You can build a technically perfect dashboard that nobody opens. Here's how to avoid that fate:
Make it dead simple to access
If people have to log into GA4, navigate to Explorations, and find the right report, they won't. Bookmark the direct URL. Better yet, set up a Looker Studio dashboard and share the link in your team Slack channel.
Update it regularly (or automate it)
Stale data kills dashboard adoption. If someone opens it and sees data from three weeks ago, they'll never trust it again. Either commit to updating it or build it in a way that updates automatically.
Add context, not just numbers
A metric without context is just a number. Add brief annotations when something significant happens. "Traffic spike due to Product Hunt launch." "Conversion rate drop during site migration." These notes make the data interpretable.
Schedule a regular review
Put a recurring 15-minute meeting on the calendar to review the dashboard with stakeholders. Sounds corporate, but it works. When people know they'll discuss the data weekly, they start paying attention to it.
The Tools That Make This Easier
GA4 alone is powerful but clunky. Here's what makes the workflow smoother:
Google Tag Manager for implementing custom dimensions and events without bugging your dev team every time. Learning curve is real, but worth it.
Looker Studio for dashboards that don't look like they were built in 2008. Free, integrates directly with GA4, and actually shareable.
GA4 API for pulling data into other tools. If you're technical (or have someone technical), the API lets you combine GA4 data with CRM data, ad platform data, whatever. This is where reporting gets truly powerful.
Supermetrics or Windsor.ai if you want to combine GA4 with other data sources but don't want to code. They're paid tools, but they save dozens of hours.
What Success Actually Looks Like
You'll know your dashboard is working when people start asking questions based on the data.
"Why did organic traffic drop last Tuesday?" means they're looking at it regularly. "Can we break this out by product category?" means they're thinking about how to act on it. "This shows we should shift budget from X to Y" means you've actually influenced a decision.
That's the goal. Not beautiful charts. Not comprehensive metrics. Decisions.
Start with one dashboard for one specific decision. Build it simple. Make it accessible. See if people use it. Then iterate.
GA4 is overwhelming because it can do everything. Your dashboard shouldn't try to do everything. It should do one thing well enough that someone changes their behavior based on what they see.
That's the difference between a dashboard and a decoration.
Top comments (0)