Every side project starts the same way. "This will be simple. A few pages, some date, maybe a week of work."
I said that about building a software comparison directory. That was 2,500+ listings, 70+ categories, and many humbling lessons ago.
If you've ever built (or thought about building) a content-heavy platform, here's what I learned about what breaks when your dataset grows past the "manageable" stage.
Lesson 1: Your Category System Will Be Wrong
I designed a clean taxonomy. Tools sorted into neat buckets: SEO, Design, Project Management, CRM, and so on. Logical. Intuitive. Completely wrong.
The problem is that tools don't fit into one box. Is Notion a project management tool or a documentation tool? Is Canva a design tool or a marketing tool? Users expect to find them in multiple places, but your data model probably has a single category field.
What I ended up doing with ManyTools was supporting multiple categories per listing and building role-based filters on top. A marketer browsing "Design Tools" sees Canva. A developer browsing the same category sees Figma's developer handoff features highlighted instead.
What I'd do differently: Start with tags, not categories. Categories feel clean but they're rigid. Tags let things live in multiple places without restructuring your database later.
Lesson 2: Stable Data Is Worse Than No Data
Here's a number that will haunt you: 2,500+. That's how many listings I need to keep accurate. Pricing changes, featuring get deprecated, products get acquired, free tiers disappear.
When you have 50 listings, a monthly manual check takes an afternoon. At 2,500, it's a full-time job. And here's the thing: one wrong price erodes more trust than a hundred correct ones build. A user who sees outdate pricing assumes the whole site is unreliable.
My approach now is a priority queue. High-traffic listings get checked more frequently. Low-traffic ones get checked on a longer cycle. User-reported inaccuracies jump to the top of the queue. It's not perfect. But "mostly right with a fast correction loop" beats "verified once and never updated."
Lesson 3: Users Don't Browse the Way You Expect
I built the site assuming people would land on the homepage, pick a category, and explore. Clean top-down navigation.
Reality: 80%+ of traffic comes from search engines landing directly on individual tool pages. People search for "Mailchimp alternatives" or "Asana pricing comparison" and land deep in the site. Most never see the homepage.
This changed everything about how I think about page structure. Every single listing page needs to work as a standalone landing page. It needs context, related tools, and category navigation, because for most users, it's the first (and maybe only) page they see.
Takeaway for builders: Design every page as if it's the homepage. Because for someone, it is.
Lesson 4: Community Input > Your Roadmap
I had a feature roadmap. It was detailed. It was prioritized. Users ignored it entirely.
The features people actually cared about were things I considered low-priority. "Can I filter by free tools only?" "Can I see which tools work on mobile?" "Can I compare two tools side by side?"
Once I added community ratings and reviews, the dynamic shifted completely. Users started generating content that was more useful than what I could write myself. Someone who uses Trello daily for 3 years writes a better review than I ever could from a 30-minute evaluation.
The lesson: Build the feedback loop first, not last. Your users collectively know more about your domain than you do. Let them contribute early.
Lesson 5: "Just a Directory" Is Never Just a Directory
The scope creep on a directory project is real. You start with "list some tools with names and links." Then you need pricing. Then features. Then screenshots. Then comparisons. Then reviews. Then filtering. Then search. Then analytics to know what's working.
Each addition is small on its own. Together they turn a "simple directory" into a full product with data pipelines, content moderation, user accounts, and performance optimization.
If you're starting a directory project, be honest with yourself about where it's headed. Budget for 5x the complexity you're imagining right now. You'll probably still underestimate it, but at least you won't be surprised when "a weekend project" is still evolving a year later.
Would I Build it Again?
Yes. But I'd start with tags instead of categories, build the review system on day one, and treat every listing page as a landing page from the start instead of retrofitting that later.
The biggest thing I underestimated was maintenance. Building a directory is a sprint. Keeping it accurate and useful is a marathon with no finish line.
If you're building something similar, plan for the marathon part. That's where the real work lives.
Top comments (0)