Both Redis Pub/Sub and Laravel Reverb can be used for real-time functionality in Laravel applications, but they address different layers of the real-time stack and have distinct benefits and use cases:
Redis Pub/Sub is a messaging paradigm where publishers send messages to channels, and subscribers listen to those channels. It's fast, lightweight, and widely used for real-time messaging.
Laravel Reverb is Laravel's first-party WebSocket server introduced in Laravel 11, aiming to offer a robust real-time solution tightly integrated with Laravel’s broadcasting system.
Feature | Redis Pub/Sub | Laravel Reverb |
---|---|---|
Speed | Extremely fast (in-memory) | Fast with persistent WebSocket connections |
Latency | Sub-millisecond | Sub-millisecond (depending on network/WebSocket load) |
Horizontal Scaling | Tricky (no persistence) | Cluster support, queue integration |
Message Durability | None (ephemeral) | Optional via queues and Redis |
Connection Type | Stateless | Persistent (WebSocket) |
Performance
Redis Pub/Sub
Speed: Extremely fast due to being in-memory and low-overhead.
Latency: Sub-millisecond for local setups.
Horizontal Scaling: Pub/Sub doesn't support message persistence or queuing, which can be a limitation in distributed systems.
Load Handling: Handles high-throughput messaging, but can drop messages if subscribers disconnect.
Redis::publish('channel-name', json_encode(['message' => 'Hello']));
On the subscriber side, you'd need a separate process (often in Node.js or Go) to receive messages and forward to clients.
Laravel Reverb
Speed: Built on top of FrankenPHP or Swoole, it's designed for high concurrency and persistent WebSocket connections.
Latency: Excellent for WebSocket-based communication; real-time delivery with persistent connections.
Horizontal Scaling: Supports clustering and integrates tightly with Laravel queues and Redis.
Reliability: Built-in reconnection and session handling. More resilient than raw Pub/Sub.
Example:
Broadcasting Event:
event(new MessageSent($message));
Client Side (with Laravel Echo):
Echo.channel('chat')
.listen('MessageSent', (e) => {
console.log(e.message);
});
Verdict:
Redis Pub/Sub is ideal for backend-to-backend communication or ephemeral events.
Reverb shines in persistent client communication and scales more gracefully in Laravel-native projects.
Conclusion
If you're looking to build real-time features in Laravel, Laravel Reverb is the clear winner in terms of usability, integration, and developer experience. It’s made for Laravel, integrates with everything you already use, and takes away the pain of setting up a real-time infrastructure.
That said, Redis Pub/Sub is still a great choice for lightweight, internal messaging systems or cross-service communication where WebSockets aren't needed.
Top comments (0)