DEV Community

Cover image for The AI church with no Christ
Bogomil Shopov - Бого
Bogomil Shopov - Бого

Posted on

The AI church with no Christ

A note before we start: What follows is fiction. A thought experiment set in an alternate world that only looks like ours by accident. Any resemblance to real labs, real bosses, or real workplace policies is the reader’s imagination doing the heavy lifting. With that out of the way.

We’ve seen this movie before

In this imagined world, strip the hype off AI (artificial intelligence, software that learns from huge amounts of data to answer questions, write text, and so on) and you’re looking at a religion:
A new priesthood (the AI labs) telling us the details are too complex for normal people to question. Just trust them. Sacred texts nobody is allowed to check. Closed code, secret training data, “trust us, we tested it.

“Personal stories used as proof. “It changed my life” is not evidence. It’s a church testimony. End-times talk dressed up as forecasting.

Either heaven (an AGI utopia, where AGI means artificial general intelligence, a hypothetical future AI as smart or smarter than humans at almost everything) or hell (AI doom, the idea that AI wipes us out).

Notice how both endings need you to fund the church now: Pay-to-be-saved. Buy the Pro plan and your sins of being slow are forgiven. Heretics already getting punished, quietly. Critics mocked, artists ignored, workers fired for saying no.

The push from above, and where the money is really coming from

Here is the part nobody can fully explain. Every company, every government, every school suddenly has to adopt AI. Right now. Faster. The pressure does not match the actual results yet. Real productivity gains are mixed. Real profits at most AI companies are negative.

And still the orders come down from the top: roll it out, train everyone, make it mandatory.Why? Maybe it is silver dollars. Maybe it is investor money chasing the next big thing. Maybe it is governments quietly pushing because whoever controls AI controls the next century.

Maybe it is something simpler and uglier, like bosses who finally have an excuse to cut headcount. We do not really know. The order comes from somewhere above, and it does not get questioned out loud.

Christianity had the same moment. In the year 312, the Roman Emperor Constantine had a vision before a battle, won, and made Christianity the favored religion of the empire.

Almost overnight, a small persecuted sect became the official faith of the most powerful state on earth. Bishops got palaces. Pagans got pushed out of public jobs. Was it because Constantine truly believed?

Because it was politically useful to unite a fracturing empire under one faith? Because the church had become too big to fight, so better to ride it? Historians still argue.

The point is the conversion came from the top, the reasons stayed murky, and once it started, refusing was no longer a neutral choice. It was a career-ending one. That is where we are now.

The Constantine moment for AI has already happened. We just do not know whose vision it was, or what they really saw.

But who is the Jesus in this story?

Here is the strange part. We don’t have one yet. Christianity had a founder, a life, a death, and then the church came after. AI has the church first, and is still waiting for its messiah to show up. Right now there are only candidates. AGI itself is the most popular pick, a savior that has been “two years away” for about ten years now.

Some treat Sam Altman or other lab bosses as prophets, but nobody really believes they are the chosen one, including them. Others point at the next unreleased model, always the next one, never this one.That is what makes this moment odd.

The faith is huge.

The followers are everywhere.

The money is real.

But the figure at the center of it all is still missing. People are praying toward an empty chair and calling it inevitable.

The Inquisition is already here.

Forced AI use at work.

Teachers told to “embrace the tools” or lose their jobs. Writers called Luddites (a name for people in the 1800s who smashed factory machines because the machines took their jobs, now used as an insult for anyone who criticizes new tech) for refusing.

Whole jobs told to retrain or die, by bosses who keep their human staff.

The punishment is the layoff. The confession is your usage report.

A counter-movement is already forming, and they’ll be called backwards.

Parents who keep kids off screens. Musicians who stamp “100% human” on the album.

Lawyers who write by hand. Teachers going back to paper exams. They’ll be mocked as old-fashioned, anti-progress, snobs. Every insult the winning side throws at the losing one.

Christianity took 300 years to take over an empire. The empire took over AI in about 30 months. That is not a sign the tech is good.

That is a sign nobody got to vote. The real question is whether enough people will still know how to read, think, and write on their own to notice what was lost, before the tools that used to do those things for them get too expensive to live without.

Again, fiction. Any similarity to the world outside your window is between you and your window.

This post was initially created here

Top comments (0)