DEV Community

Andrew Park for Edensoft Labs

Posted on

🚨 The Pitfalls of the Agile Testing Pyramid in High-Consequence Software: Lessons from CrowdStrike 🚨

The recent CrowdStrike incident highlights a critical lesson for teams developing high-consequence software: prioritizing speed and agility without rigorous testing leads to catastrophic results. While the Agile Testing Pyramid is widely adopted, it falls short for systems where failure can have severe consequences.

In my latest article, I explore the Testing Spectrum:

Agile Testing Pyramid, Trapezoid, and Rectangle

  • The Testing Pyramid is great for lower-consequence applications because it delivers the best bang for the buck, focusing on unit and component tests to achieve sufficient quality with rapid iteration.
  • The Testing Trapezoid shifts focus toward more integration and real-world testing to account for higher risk management as the consequences of failure increase.
  • The Testing Rectangle demands rigorous testing at all levels to manage risk when the consequences of failure are highest, ensuring that unit, integration, and end-to-end tests are thoroughly conducted.

One of the key takeaways from the CrowdStrike incident is the importance of integration and end-to-end testing. Relying too heavily on unit tests, as often encouraged by the Testing Pyramid, leaves dangerous gaps in identifying critical system-level issues. The more serious the consequences of failure, the more essential it becomes to adopt a strategy that stresses rigorous testing at every level to avoid real-world disasters.

For software with serious real-world impacts, it’s essential to move beyond the traditional testing models and adopt a more comprehensive approach to prevent failures. The lessons from CrowdStrike are a reminder that testing rigor must match the risks.

Read more about evolving from the Testing Pyramid to more rigorous testing models like the Testing Trapezoid and Testing Rectangle, and what’s involved in adopting this approach for high-consequence systems: https://www.edensoftlabs.com/post/poatphcslc

AWS Security LIVE!

Tune in for AWS Security LIVE!

Join AWS Security LIVE! for expert insights and actionable tips to protect your organization and keep security teams prepared.

Learn More

Top comments (0)

A Workflow Copilot. Tailored to You.

Pieces.app image

Our desktop app, with its intelligent copilot, streamlines coding by generating snippets, extracting code from screenshots, and accelerating problem-solving.

Read the docs

πŸ‘‹ Kindness is contagious

Dive into an ocean of knowledge with this thought-provoking post, revered deeply within the supportive DEV Community. Developers of all levels are welcome to join and enhance our collective intelligence.

Saying a simple "thank you" can brighten someone's day. Share your gratitude in the comments below!

On DEV, sharing ideas eases our path and fortifies our community connections. Found this helpful? Sending a quick thanks to the author can be profoundly valued.

Okay