Performance review season is brutal. You're juggling dozens of reviews, trying to write specific, fair, constructive feedback for each person — while still doing your actual job. And then you have to write your own self-review on top of it.
AI doesn't replace your judgment, but it does eliminate the blank-page problem and helps you write more consistently across your reports. These prompts are built for that.
Manager Writing About Direct Reports
Full performance review draft:
I'm a [your role] writing a performance review for [report's role]. This person has been on my team for [X months/years]. Here are my notes on their performance: [paste your bullet points or notes — the messier the better].
Write a professional performance review with the following sections: Overall Performance Summary (2-3 sentences), Key Accomplishments (3-5 bullets with specific impact where I've noted it), Areas for Development (2-3 constructive observations), and a Forward-Looking Statement about their trajectory and potential.
Tone: honest, specific, professional. Don't use vague filler phrases like "hard-working" or "great team player" unless I've given you specific evidence for them.
Writing about a strong performer:
I want to write a glowing performance review for someone who genuinely exceeded expectations this year. Their key contributions: [list 3-5 specific things they did]. They also showed growth in: [list areas]. Write a 250-word review that makes clear this person is high-potential. I want their manager above me to read this and notice them.
Writing about an underperformer — honest but fair:
I need to write a performance review for someone who did not meet expectations this year. The gaps were: [describe gaps specifically]. To be fair, they did [acknowledge positives]. I've had [X] conversations with them about this — [describe roughly what was discussed].
Write a review that: accurately describes the performance gap without being harsh, is specific enough to be legally defensible, acknowledges effort or improvement where real, and sets clear expectations for what "meeting expectations" looks like going forward. Do not soften it to the point of dishonesty.
Mid-cycle check-in summary:
I just had a mid-year check-in with a direct report. Here's what we discussed: [paste your notes]. Write a short summary I can send to them as a written record of our conversation. Include: what's going well, what they're working on improving, and the one goal we aligned on for the next 90 days. Conversational tone, not corporate.
Self-Review Prompts
Full self-review draft:
I'm writing my self-review for [review period]. My role is [title]. Here are the things I worked on this year: [paste accomplishments, projects, challenges — messy notes are fine].
Write a self-review with these sections: Key Accomplishments (3-5 with quantified impact where I've given numbers), Challenges and What I Learned (honest, not defensive), Growth Areas I've Worked On, and What I Want to Focus On Next Year.
Tone: confident but not arrogant. I want to advocate clearly for myself while being accurate.
Quantifying impact when you don't have hard numbers:
I worked on [project/initiative] this year. I don't have exact metrics, but here's what I know about the impact: [describe what changed, what got better, what problems got solved]. Help me write 2-3 achievement bullets that honestly represent the impact without fabricating numbers. Use ranges, qualitative outcomes, and comparative language where appropriate.
Self-review when the year was rough:
This was a hard year for me professionally. [Briefly describe: layoffs, reorgs, personal challenges, difficult projects, etc.]. Despite that, I still contributed in these ways: [list]. Write a self-review that's honest about the context, doesn't make excuses, and still clearly demonstrates my value to the team. I need to strike the balance between explaining the circumstances and owning my performance.
Peer Review Prompts
Peer feedback — positive:
I'm writing peer feedback for [colleague's role]. They collaborated with me on [project or situation]. Specifically, they: [list 2-4 specific things they did]. Write thoughtful peer feedback (150-200 words) that's specific and genuine. I want my words to actually help them understand their strengths, not just be a feel-good paragraph.
Peer feedback — when someone was difficult to work with:
I need to give honest peer feedback to someone who was frustrating to collaborate with. The issues were: [describe specifically — communication problems, missed deadlines, taking credit, etc.]. Write feedback that is: specific and behavioral (not personality-based), professional, and constructive. Frame it as observations and impact, not character judgment. I want to be honest without torching the relationship.
360 feedback summary for your manager:
I've received peer feedback from [X] colleagues. Here are their responses: [paste raw feedback]. Synthesize this into a summary that: identifies the common themes (positive and developmental), highlights the most specific and actionable observations, and flags anything surprising or contradictory. Format as a brief report I can share with the employee.
Development Goals and PIP Language
Writing development goals (not fluffy ones):
I need to write a development goal for [employee] in the area of [skill gap]. The gap shows up specifically as: [describe observable behavior]. Write a SMART development goal with: a clear behavior target, measurable success criteria, a timeframe, and 2-3 specific actions or resources. Make it something we can actually track, not "improve communication skills."
Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) language:
I need to draft a Performance Improvement Plan for someone in the role of [role]. The documented concerns are: [list specific performance gaps]. What we've discussed previously: [summarize prior conversations and any warnings]. The goal of the PIP is to help them succeed, not to document termination.
Write PIP language for the Goals section that: states the expected standard clearly, identifies measurable benchmarks for weeks 30/60/90, and describes how we'll support them. Avoid punitive language — be direct and clear, not threatening.
Follow-up after a difficult performance conversation:
I just had a tough conversation with a direct report about their performance. The main points I covered: [list]. They reacted [describe reaction — defensive, upset, receptive, etc.]. Write a brief follow-up email I can send within 24 hours that: summarizes what we discussed without repeating everything verbatim, confirms the agreed next steps, and keeps the tone supportive and forward-looking.
Review Cycle Admin Prompts
Calibration prep — stack ranking notes:
I need to prepare for calibration where I'll advocate for my team. I have [X] direct reports. Here's my quick assessment of each: [list name, performance tier you'd place them in, and 1-2 sentences of evidence].
For each person, draft 2-3 sentences I can use to advocate for their calibration rating in a group discussion. I need to be concise and specific — calibration moves fast and I need strong talking points, not lengthy explanations.
Review cycle reminder to your team:
Write a short, human-sounding Slack message to my team reminding them that self-reviews are due [date]. Include: what platform they're in, what sections they need to complete, and one piece of practical advice for making self-reviews easier. Keep it under 100 words. Not corporate. Sound like a manager who actually wants to help, not an HR announcement.
Stop Rewriting These Every Cycle
The prompts above will save you hours this review cycle. But next cycle, you'll be starting from scratch again — unless you save them.
If you're on a Mac, Promptzy stores these as prompt templates you can recall instantly with a keyboard shortcut. Store them in a collection called "Review Season" and they're always one Cmd+Shift+P away.
Top comments (0)