Learn how to spot YouTube scams before wasting money. This complete guide reveals 15 red flags, hidden metrics, and free tools to protect yourself from fake "make money online" videos in 2026.
Introduction: The $2 Billion YouTube Scam Industry
Every day, thousands of people lose money to YouTube scams. In 2024 alone, an estimated $2 billion was lost to fraudulent "make money online" courses, fake investment schemes, and misleading product promotions on YouTube.
The problem? YouTube removed the dislike button in 2021, making it nearly impossible to spot scam videos at first glance. A video with 500,000 views and 10,000 likes can look completely legitimate—even when 45% of viewers actually disliked it.
I learned this the hard way after losing $800 to YouTube course scams in 2023. After that painful experience, I built TruthScore to help others avoid the same mistakes.
In this complete guide, you'll learn:
- 15 proven red flags that identify YouTube scams
- How to see hidden dislike ratios YouTube won't show you
- Which types of videos are most likely to be scams
- Free tools to check video credibility before buying anything
- Real examples of popular scam videos (with proof) Let's protect your wallet.
Part 1: Understanding YouTube Scams in 2025
What Makes YouTube the Perfect Platform for Scammers?
YouTube has become scammer paradise for three key reasons:
1. The Dislike Button is Hidden
In November 2021, YouTube removed public dislike counts. Their stated reason was "protecting creator mental health," but the real effect? Scammers can no longer be easily identified by mass dislikes.
A scam video with 47% dislikes now looks just as legitimate as a helpful video with 2% dislikes. Regular viewers have no way to know the difference.
2. The Algorithm Rewards Engagement (Good or Bad)
YouTube's algorithm doesn't distinguish between positive and negative engagement. If a video gets lots of comments (even negative ones), lots of views (even from people fact-checking), and lots of clicks (even from skeptics), the algorithm promotes it.
Scammers exploit this. They make controversial, outrageous claims that generate massive engagement—both from victims and from critics calling them out.
3. The Barrier to Entry is Zero
Anyone can create a YouTube channel in 60 seconds. Scammers create networks of dozens of channels promoting the same scam. If one gets banned, they simply make another.
They use professional video editing, purchased views, fake testimonials, and coordinated comment campaigns to appear legitimate within days of launching.
Part 2: The 15 Red Flags of YouTube Scams
I analyzed over 1,000 confirmed scam videos to identify patterns. Here are the 15 most reliable warning signs:
1. Unrealistic Income Claims
Red Flag: Titles claiming "$10,000 in 24 hours," "$50K per month guaranteed," or "I made $X my first week"
Why It's a Scam: Real businesses take months or years to build sustainable income. Anyone promising four or five-figure monthly income in days or weeks is lying.
Real Example: "How I Made $50,000 in My First Month (Step-by-Step)" - TruthScore: 8/100, 46% hidden dislike ratio
Exception: Videos about one-time windfalls (selling a business, inheritance, etc.) are different from claiming repeatable income methods.
2. Excessive Emojis and ALL CAPS
Red Flag: Titles with 5+ emojis (💰🤑💸🔥⚡) or large portions in ALL CAPS
Why It's a Scam: Professional educators don't need to scream for attention. This is textbook clickbait designed to prey on desperation.
Real Example: "💰💰 MAKE $500/DAY WITH THIS SECRET METHOD 🔥🔥 (NO WORK!) 💸" - TruthScore: 4/100
3. Fake Urgency Language
Red Flag: Phrases like "Limited time only," "Spots filling up," "Offer expires today," "Act now"
Why It's a Scam: Artificial scarcity is a manipulation tactic. If the method actually worked, why would they limit access? They create false urgency to prevent you from thinking critically.
Real Example: "Last Chance: Only 10 Spots Left in My Course" (Video posted 3 months ago, same claim) - TruthScore: 15/100
Video Content Red Flags
4. No Mention of Work, Skills, or Time Required
Red Flag: Video promises results but never mentions the actual effort, learning curve, or time investment needed
Why It's a Scam: Every legitimate business requires work, skills, or time. Omitting this information is deliberate deception.
What to Look For: Honest videos say "This took me 6 months of daily work" or "You need to learn X, Y, and Z first."
5. Vague or Zero Explanation of the Actual Method
Red Flag: 15-minute video that never actually explains HOW the method works—just that it works
Why It's a Scam: They're hiding the lack of substance. Real educators teach the method in the free video. Scammers gatekeep information to sell courses.
Red Flag Statement: "I can't reveal everything here, but inside my course..."
6. Fake Income Screenshots
Red Flag: Screenshots of bank accounts, PayPal, Stripe, or platform dashboards showing massive earnings
Why It's a Scam: These are trivially easy to fake using browser developer tools or Photoshop. A screenshot proves absolutely nothing without corresponding tax returns or bank statements (which they never show).
Test: Ask yourself: "Could I fake this in 60 seconds?" If yes, don't trust it.
7. Paid Actor Testimonials
Red Flag: "Student success stories" from people who appear in multiple unrelated videos or whose profiles can't be verified
Why It's a Scam: Scammers hire actors from Fiverr to provide fake testimonials. These same people appear in dozens of different course promotions.
How to Check: Reverse image search the testimonial photos. Often you'll find the same person promoting completely different products.
Engagement Red Flags
8. High Hidden Dislike Ratio
Red Flag: Video has a dislike ratio above 30% (revealed by tools like TruthScore or ReturnYouTubeDislike)
Why It's a Scam: When a significant portion of viewers actively dislike a video, that's a strong signal something is wrong.
How to Check: Use TruthScore to reveal the hidden dislike count YouTube doesn't show you.
Benchmark: Legitimate educational videos typically have dislike ratios below 5%.
9. Comments Disabled or Heavily Filtered
Red Flag: Comments are turned off, or all visible comments are suspiciously positive
Why It's a Scam: They're hiding negative feedback. Legitimate creators welcome both positive and critical comments.
What to Look For: Check if critical comments exist. If you only see "Great video! 🔥" repeated 100 times, it's filtered or botted.
10. Suspiciously Low Engagement for High Views
Red Flag: Video has 500K views but only 2,000 likes/dislikes/comments combined (0.4% engagement)
Why It's Suspicious: Likely bought views. Real videos typically have 2-8% engagement ratio.
How to Check: TruthScore automatically calculates engagement ratios and flags anomalies.
Channel Red Flags
11. Brand New Channel with Sudden Viral Video
Red Flag: Channel is less than 6 months old but has one video with 500K+ views
Why It's a Scam: Organic growth doesn't work this way. This pattern indicates purchased views and promoted scam content.
What to Check: Look at the channel's upload history. Scam channels often have inconsistent content or recently changed their name.
12. Multiple Name or Niche Changes
Red Flag: Channel used to post gaming content, then switched to finance, then to dropshipping
Why It's Suspicious: Scammers buy aged channels to appear established, then pivot to scam content.
How to Check: Use Wayback Machine or SocialBlade to see channel history.
Description & Link Red Flags
13. Undisclosed Affiliate Links
Red Flag: Description contains multiple affiliate links without clear disclosure
Why It's Problematic: FTC requires disclosure. Hiding affiliate relationships is both unethical and illegal in the US.
What to Look For: Legitimate creators clearly state "Links below are affiliate links" at the top of descriptions.
14. Course/Coaching Pitch in Every Video
Red Flag: Every video, regardless of topic, ends with "Join my course" or "Book my coaching"
Why It's a Red Flag: The "free" content is worthless—designed only to funnel you into expensive products.
Honest creators provide value in free content and occasionally mention paid offerings.
15. No Verifiable Online Presence
Red Flag: Creator has no LinkedIn, no website, no verifiable business registration, no social proof outside YouTube
Why It's a Scam: Legitimate business owners have digital footprints. Scammers hide their identity.
How to Check: Google "[Creator Name] scam" and "[Creator Name] review." See what others are saying.
Part 3: How to Check YouTube Videos for Scams (Step-by-Step)
Now that you know the red flags, here's the exact process I use to verify any YouTube video:
Step 1: Check the Video on TruthScore (10 seconds)
- Copy the YouTube video URL
- Go to truthscore.online
- Paste the URL and click "Analyze"
- Review the scam score (0-100) and specific red flags
What TruthScore Reveals:
- Hidden dislike ratio (what YouTube hides)
- Comment sentiment analysis (finds buried negative feedback)
- Engagement anomalies (detects bought views)
- Manipulative language detection (AI scans for scam phrases)
- Channel credibility score
Benchmark Scores:
- 70-100: Likely legitimate
- 40-69: Proceed with caution, research more
- 0-39: High risk, multiple red flags
Step 2: Read Critical Comments (5 minutes)
Don't just read the top comments (often fake). Scroll down and look for:
- Comments mentioning "scam," "didn't work," "waste of money"
- Detailed negative experiences
- Questions the creator never answered
- People asking for refunds
Sort comments by "Newest First" to see recent feedback.
Step 3: Google the Creator + "Scam" (3 minutes)
Search: "[Creator Name] scam" and "[Creator Name] review"
Look for:
Reddit threads discussing them
Reviews on Trustpilot or BBB
News articles or investigations
Other people's experiences
Warning: Scammers sometimes create fake positive reviews. Look for detailed, specific criticisms.
Step 4: Check Channel History (2 minutes)
- When was the channel created?
- Is upload schedule consistent?
- Did they recently change name/niche?
- Do they have social media presence?
- Can you find them on LinkedIn?
Step 5: Verify Income Claims (If Possible)
If they claim income, look for:
- Tax returns (they never show these)
- Time-stamped bank statements (not screenshots)
- Third-party verification
- Multiple consistent sources
Reality: If they won't provide proof, assume it's fabricated.
Part 4: Real Examples of YouTube Scams (Analyzed)
Let me show you real scam videos with TruthScore analysis:
Example 1: The Dropshipping Scam
Video: "How I Made $50K in My First Month Dropshipping (Beginner Friendly)"
TruthScore Analysis:
- Overall Score: 12/100 (High Risk)
- Hidden Dislike Ratio: 44% (!)
- Comments: 89 mention "scam" or "didn't work"
- Channel Age: 4 months
- Red Flags Detected: 8
Why It's a Scam:
- Unrealistic timeframe (first month success is extremely rare)
- No mention of startup costs ($3,000-5,000 typically needed)
- Income screenshot easily faked
- Comment analysis reveals: people bought his $997 course and made $0
What Viewers Didn't See:
- 1,247 hidden dislikes
- Creator has 3 other channels promoting same course
- Actual product: outdated 2018 dropshipping tactics
Example 2: The Passive Income Scam
Video: "This Passive Income Method Made Me $10K/Month (No Work Required)"
TruthScore Analysis:
- Overall Score: 8/100 (Severe Risk)
- Hidden Dislike Ratio: 52% (!)
- Comments: Heavily filtered, critical comments removed
- Channel Age: 2 months
- Red Flags Detected: 11
Why It's a Scam:
- "No work required" is impossible
- Pushes $1,997 "mentorship program"
- Used paid actors for testimonials (verified via reverse image search)
- Same income screenshot appears in 15 other videos
Part 5: Types of YouTube Scams (Know Your Enemy)
1. Course Scams ($500-$2,000 range)
The Promise: "Everything you need to succeed" in one course
The Reality: Outdated, generic information available free on YouTube
How to Spot: Excessive hype, fake urgency, no refund policy
2. Coaching/Mentorship Scams ($2,000-$10,000 range)
The Promise: "Personal guidance" and "accountability"
The Reality: Group calls with 100+ people, generic advice, upsells to higher tiers
How to Spot: Can't verify mentor's credentials, no specific curriculum disclosed
3. "Done-For-You" System Scams ($5,000-$50,000 range)
The Promise: They set up the entire business for you
The Reality: Low-quality setup you could do yourself for $500, no ongoing support
How to Spot: Ridiculous pricing, vague deliverables, no portfolio
4. Cryptocurrency/NFT Pump-and-Dumps
The Promise: "This coin/NFT will 100x"
The Reality: They pump, you buy, they dump, you lose
How to Spot: Specific price predictions, urgency, no risk disclosure
5. Affiliate Marketing Funnels
The Promise: "Free method to make money"
The Reality: Video is worthless without buying tools/courses they're affiliated with
How to Spot: Everything requires a specific paid tool, undisclosed affiliate links
Part 6: What to Do If You've Been Scammed
If you already fell for a YouTube scam:
1. Request Refund Immediately
Contact the seller
State reason: "Product does not match description"
If ignored, proceed to step 2
2. Dispute the Charge
Call your credit card company
File chargeback claim
Provide evidence: video vs. reality
Success rate: 70-80% if done within 60 days
3. Report to Platforms
Report YouTube video: "Scams/Fraud"
Report to FTC: reportfraud.ftc.gov
Report to BBB if business-based
4. Share Your Experience
Post honest review on Reddit
Leave comment on video (warn others)
Share on Twitter/social media
Help others avoid same mistake
5. Learn and Move Forward
Don't feel ashamed (scammers are professionals)
Use the experience to spot future scams
Check videos on TruthScore before trusting
Part 7: Free Tools to Detect YouTube Scams
1. TruthScore (Best Overall)
What it does: Comprehensive scam analysis in 10 seconds
Features:
Hidden dislike ratio
Comment sentiment analysis
Red flag detection
Channel credibility scoring
Manipulation language detection
Link: truthscore.online
Cost: Free
2. ReturnYouTubeDislike Browser Extension
What it does: Shows dislike counts YouTube hides
Platforms: Chrome, Firefox, Edge
Limitation: Only shows dislikes, no other analysis
3. SocialBlade
What it does: Channel growth stats, subscriber history
Use for: Detecting sudden growth spikes (bought subscribers)
Link: socialblade.com
4. FakeSpot (For Product Review Scams)
What it does: Analyzes Amazon/product review authenticity
Use for: Videos promoting physical products
Link: fakespot.com
Part 8: How to Support Legitimate YouTube Creators
Not all YouTube creators are scammers! Here's how to find and support the good ones:
Signs of Legitimate Creators:
✅ Provide value in free content (don't gatekeep)
✅ Realistic timelines and expectations
✅ Clear disclosure of affiliates and sponsorships
✅ Respond to critical comments professionally
✅ Have verifiable credentials or results
✅ Show the work process, not just results
✅ Low dislike ratio (under 5%)
✅ Consistent upload schedule over years
✅ Active social media presence
✅ Reasonable course pricing ($20-200 range)
How to Support Them:
Like, comment, and share their content
Buy their reasonably-priced products if helpful
Leave honest reviews
Join their communities
Refer friends
Conclusion: Stay Safe, Check First
YouTube scams cost victims an estimated $2 billion annually. The good news? They're all detectable if you know what to look for.
Remember the core principles:
If it sounds too good to be true, it is
Check videos on TruthScore before trusting
Look for red flags, not just green lights
Trust the community (hidden dislikes, comments)
Verify credentials independently
The scammers are counting on you to skip due diligence. Don't give them the satisfaction.
Before you click "buy now" on any YouTube course, coaching program, or "system":
Paste the video URL into TruthScore
Review the scam score and red flags
Google "[Creator] scam" and read experiences
Check if income claims can be verified
Sleep on it for 24 hours
Ten seconds of checking can save you thousands of dollars.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can TruthScore guarantee a video is or isn't a scam?
A: No tool can guarantee with 100% certainty. TruthScore provides risk indicators based on data analysis—use it as one data point in your decision-making.
Q: Are all "make money online" videos scams?
A: No. Legitimate educators exist. But the field is heavily saturated with scammers because it's lucrative and easy to fake.
Q: What if a video has a high TruthScore but I still don't trust it?
A: Trust your gut. TruthScore detects patterns, but your intuition matters. If something feels off, don't proceed.
Q: Can creators manipulate their TruthScore?
A: It's extremely difficult. We analyze multiple independent signals (hidden dislikes, comment sentiment, engagement patterns, language markers, channel history). Faking all simultaneously is nearly impossible.
Q: Is checking videos on TruthScore really free?
A: Yes, completely free with no hidden costs. Core features will always remain free.
Q: What should I do if I find a scam video?
A: Report it to YouTube, post honest comments warning others, and share the TruthScore analysis on social media.
Take Action Now
Don't be the next scam victim.
Bookmark this page and return to it whenever you're tempted by a "make money online" video.
Check your next video: truthscore.online
Share this guide with friends and family who might fall for YouTube scams.
Together, we can make YouTube safer and bankrupt the scammers.
About the Author: I'm the creator of TruthScore, built after personally losing $800 to YouTube course scams in 2023. My mission is to protect others from the same painful and expensive mistakes. Connect with me on Twitter/X @TruthScoreAI.
Last Updated: January 5, 2026
This article is 100% free to read and share. If it saved you money, consider buying me a coffee or sharing it with someone who needs it.
Top comments (0)