Solved: Third party attribution solution (Segmetrics) vs Looker Studio connectors (Supermetrics)? What should I use?

🚀 Executive Summary

TL;DR: Marketing data silos complicate ROI measurement, necessitating robust attribution solutions. Organizations can choose between rapid, specialized third-party platforms like Segmetrics, flexible BI tools with connectors such as Supermetrics for Looker Studio, or a highly customizable custom ELT/data warehouse approach, each offering distinct trade-offs in engineering effort, cost, and data control.

🎯 Key Takeaways

• Dedicated attribution platforms (e.g., Segmetrics) provide rapid deployment and pre-built multi-touch attribution models, reducing engineering overhead but introducing vendor lock-in and customization limits.
• Integrating data connectors (e.g., Supermetrics) with BI tools (e.g., Looker Studio) allows for flexible custom reporting and basic attribution logic via calculated fields and data blending, though it can struggle with scale and complex models.
• A custom ELT/data warehouse solution offers ultimate control, scalability, and data ownership, enabling sophisticated, data-science-driven attribution models but requires significant data engineering resources and higher initial investment.

Choosing the right marketing attribution solution can significantly impact an organization’s ability to measure ROI and optimize spend. This post dives into the technical trade-offs between dedicated platforms like Segmetrics, BI tools enhanced with connectors like Supermetrics for Looker Studio, and a custom data warehousing approach.

The Attribution Dilemma: Symptoms of Disconnected Marketing Data

In today’s multi-channel marketing landscape, IT and DevOps teams often find themselves at the nexus of a critical business challenge: consolidating disparate marketing data to provide meaningful attribution. The symptoms are familiar:

• Data Silos: Marketing performance data resides in isolated platforms – Google Ads, Facebook Ads, LinkedIn Ads, CRM systems (Salesforce, HubSpot), email marketing tools, web analytics (Google Analytics), etc.
• Manual Reporting & Error Prone: Business analysts spend an inordinate amount of time manually extracting, merging, and cleaning data from various sources, leading to delays, inconsistencies, and potential human error in reporting.
• Incomplete Customer Journey View: Without a unified data model, understanding the full customer journey—from first touch to conversion—across different channels is nearly impossible. This hinders accurate attribution and optimization.
• Delayed Insights: The time lag between data collection and actionable insights means marketing campaigns might continue suboptimal performance longer than necessary.
• Lack of Granular Control: Relying solely on platform-specific attribution models (e.g., Google Ads’ last-click) often doesn’t align with broader business objectives or the complexity of modern customer paths.
• Scalability Concerns: As marketing efforts expand, manual processes or limited single-source connectors quickly become unsustainable.

These challenges underscore the need for a robust, scalable, and accurate marketing attribution solution that empowers data-driven decisions while minimizing operational overhead for IT.

Solution 1: Dedicated Third-Party Attribution Platforms (e.g., Segmetrics)

Overview

Dedicated attribution platforms like Segmetrics are designed to solve the attribution problem holistically. They specialize in integrating with a wide array of marketing and sales tools, consolidating data, and applying various attribution models (first-touch, last-touch, linear, time decay, W-shaped, custom) out-of-the-box. These platforms typically offer pre-built dashboards and reports tailored for marketing performance analysis.

How it Works

Segmetrics, for instance, connects directly to your ad platforms, CRM, email systems, and web analytics. It then normalizes this data and applies its proprietary or configurable attribution logic to attribute conversions and revenue across your customer journey touchpoints. Data collection often happens via API integrations and client-side tracking scripts.

Example Configuration (Conceptual)

While direct “commands” aren’t applicable as it’s a SaaS platform, the configuration involves:

1. API Key/OAuth Setup: Granting Segmetrics access to your marketing platforms. For example, connecting to Google Ads involves an OAuth flow or providing specific account IDs.
2. Pixel/Tracking Script Deployment: Embedding a JavaScript snippet on your website for web analytics and event tracking.

<!-- Segmetrics Tracking Script Example (Conceptual) -->
<script>
  !function(s,e,g,m,t,r,i){s['SegmetricsObject']=r;s[r]=s[r]||function(){
  (s[r].q=s[r].q||[]).push(arguments)},s[r].l=1*new Date();a=e.createElement(g),
  m=e.getElementsByTagName(g)[0];a.async=1;a.src=t;m.parentNode.insertBefore(a,m)
  }(window,document,'script','https://cdn.segmetrics.io/js/sm.js','sm');

  sm('setAccount', 'YOUR_SEGMENT_ID'); // Replace with your actual account ID
  sm('page');
</script>

1. Attribution Model Selection: Choosing or customizing the desired attribution model within the Segmetrics UI.
2. Dashboard Customization: Building specific reports based on the unified data.

Pros and Cons

• Pros:
  • Rapid Deployment & Time-to-Value: Quick setup with pre-built connectors and models.
  • Specialized Functionality: Deep focus on attribution, often with advanced models and insights.
  • Reduced Engineering Effort: Minimal ongoing maintenance for IT/DevOps once integrated.
  • Unified View: Provides a single source of truth for marketing performance.
• Cons:
  • Vendor Lock-in: Dependence on a single platform for critical business logic.
  • Limited Customization: While configurable, deep customization beyond its offerings can be challenging or impossible.
  • Cost: Can be expensive, especially for large datasets or advanced features.
  • Data Ownership: Raw data is often managed by the vendor, limiting direct access for other use cases.

Solution 2: Data Connectors & BI Tool (e.g., Supermetrics & Looker Studio)

Overview

This approach involves using specialized data connectors (like Supermetrics) to pull data from various marketing sources into a Business Intelligence (BI) tool (like Looker Studio, formerly Google Data Studio). The attribution logic and data transformations are then built directly within the BI tool or a data preparation layer before it.

How it Works

Supermetrics acts as an aggregator, connecting to dozens of marketing APIs (Google Ads, Facebook Ads, HubSpot, etc.) and allowing you to pull this data directly into various destinations, including Looker Studio, Excel, Google Sheets, or data warehouses. In Looker Studio, you create data sources from these connectors, blend data from different sources, and define calculated fields to implement your attribution logic and create custom visualizations.

Example Configuration (Conceptual)

1. Supermetrics Connector Setup: Within Looker Studio, you add a new data source and select a Supermetrics connector (e.g., “Supermetrics for Google Ads”).

<!-- Steps in Looker Studio UI (no direct code) -->
1. Add data > Explore connectors > Search for "Supermetrics"
2. Select desired connector (e.g., "Supermetrics for Google Ads")
3. Authenticate with your Google account and Google Ads account.
4. Configure data source settings (e.g., select specific accounts, date range).

1. Data Blending: To combine data from different sources (e.g., Google Ads and Facebook Ads), you use Looker Studio’s data blending feature. This allows you to join tables based on common keys like Date, Campaign Name, or User ID (if available and consistent).

2. Calculated Fields for Attribution: You define custom fields to implement simple attribution models. For example, to categorize traffic sources:
   

<!-- Looker Studio Calculated Field Example -->
CASE
  WHEN REGEXP_MATCH(Source, "(?i)google|bing") AND Medium = "cpc" THEN "Paid Search"
  WHEN REGEXP_MATCH(Source, "(?i)facebook|instagram|linkedin") AND Medium = "cpc" THEN "Paid Social"
  WHEN Medium = "email" THEN "Email Marketing"
  WHEN Medium = "organic" THEN "Organic Search"
  ELSE "Direct/Other"
END

For more complex models (e.g., first-touch, last-touch across multiple sessions), you might need to blend web analytics data (e.g., Google Analytics 4) with ad platform data and carefully define join keys and logic, which can become challenging directly within Looker Studio.

Pros and Cons

• Pros:
  • Flexibility & Control: High degree of control over data presentation, aggregation, and basic attribution logic.
  • Leverages Existing Skills: Utilizes familiar BI tools and analyst skills.
  • Cost-Effective (for some): Supermetrics has a subscription, but Looker Studio is free. Overall cost can be lower than dedicated platforms for simpler needs.
  • Centralized Reporting: Consolidates various data sources into a single dashboarding environment.
• Cons:
  • Performance at Scale: Looker Studio can struggle with large datasets or complex blends, leading to slow reports.
  • Manual Attribution Logic: Implementing sophisticated attribution models (e.g., data-driven, time decay) can be complex, require significant manual effort, and may not be fully supported by Looker Studio’s capabilities.
  • Data Governance: Data is often cached or pulled directly, making centralized governance and historical tracking harder than with a data warehouse.
  • Limits of BI Tool: Looker Studio is primarily a visualization tool; robust ETL and advanced data modeling are not its core strengths.

Solution 3: Custom ELT/Data Warehouse + BI Tool (DIY Approach)

Overview

This is the most flexible and scalable, albeit the most engineering-intensive, solution. It involves extracting data from all sources, loading it into a central data warehouse (e.g., Snowflake, Google BigQuery, Amazon Redshift), transforming it using SQL or data orchestration tools, and then connecting a BI tool (Looker Studio, Tableau, Power BI) to the warehouse for reporting and visualization.

How it Works

Data engineers use ELT (Extract, Load, Transform) tools like Airbyte, Singer.io, Fivetran, or Meltano to pull raw data from marketing APIs and load it directly into a data warehouse. Once loaded, SQL transformations are applied to clean, combine, and model the data, including implementing custom attribution logic. The BI tool then queries this pre-transformed data for reporting.

Example Configuration (Conceptual)

1. ELT Tool Setup (e.g., Airbyte): Deploy Airbyte and configure connectors for your marketing platforms. This involves defining source and destination connections.

<!-- Airbyte Source Configuration (Partial example for Facebook Ads) -->
<pre style="white-space:pre-wrap;word-wrap:break-word;overflow-x:auto;"><code>
{
  "sourceDefinitionId": "e2c342f5-b74c-4235-866d-1b392a0d0d86", // Facebook Ads Source Connector UUID
  "workspaceId": "your-workspace-id",
  "connectionConfiguration": {
    "account_id": "YOUR_FACEBOOK_AD_ACCOUNT_ID",
    "start_date": "2023-01-01T00:00:00Z",
    "access_token": "YOUR_LONG_LIVED_FACEBOOK_ACCESS_TOKEN",
    "insights_lookback_window": 28, // e.g., for attribution window
    "page_size": 100
  },
  "name": "Facebook Ads Data Source"
}
</code></pre>

1. Data Warehouse (e.g., Snowflake) Schema & Loading: Data is loaded into raw tables in your chosen data warehouse.

<!-- Snowflake Table Creation Example (Conceptual) -->
CREATE TABLE RAW.FACEBOOK_ADS_INSIGHTS (
    date DATE,
    account_name VARCHAR,
    campaign_name VARCHAR,
    impressions INT,
    clicks INT,
    spend DECIMAL(10, 2),
    conversions VARIANT, -- Store flexible JSON data
    _airbyte_extracted_at TIMESTAMP_NTZ
);

1. SQL Transformations & Attribution Modeling: This is where the core attribution logic lives. You define views or new tables that implement sophisticated multi-touch attribution models.

<!-- SQL Example for a simple First-Touch Attribution Model in Snowflake -->
<pre style="white-space:pre-wrap;word-wrap:break-word;overflow-x:auto;"><code>
WITH UserEvents AS (
    SELECT
        user_id,
        event_timestamp,
        channel, -- e.g., 'facebook_ads', 'google_ads', 'organic_search'
        campaign_id,
        ROW_NUMBER() OVER (PARTITION BY user_id ORDER BY event_timestamp) as event_rank
    FROM
        ANALYTICS.TRACKING_EVENTS -- Consolidated table from web, CRM, ad events
    WHERE
        event_type IN ('page_view', 'ad_click')
),
AttributedConversions AS (
    SELECT
        uc.user_id,
        uc.event_timestamp AS conversion_timestamp,
        uc.channel AS conversion_channel,
        ft.channel AS first_touch_channel,
        ft.campaign_id AS first_touch_campaign_id,
        -- Add other attribution models here (e.g., Last Touch, Linear, W-Shaped)
        'First Touch' AS attribution_model
    FROM
        ANALYTICS.CONVERSIONS uc -- Your actual conversion events
    JOIN
        UserEvents ft ON uc.user_id = ft.user_id AND ft.event_rank = 1
    WHERE
        uc.event_timestamp > ft.event_timestamp -- Conversion happened after first touch
)
SELECT * FROM AttributedConversions;
</code></pre>

1. BI Tool Connection: Connect Looker Studio (or any BI tool) directly to the curated attribution tables/views in your data warehouse.

Pros and Cons

• Pros:
  • Ultimate Control & Customization: Full control over data pipeline, transformations, and attribution logic.
  • Scalability: Designed for large volumes of data and complex queries.
  • Data Ownership & Governance: You own and control your raw data, enabling endless analytical possibilities and compliance.
  • Flexibility: Can integrate with any tool or system, future-proofing your data strategy.
  • Advanced Analytics: Ideal for implementing sophisticated data science models for predictive attribution or LTV.
• Cons:
  • High Engineering Effort: Requires significant upfront and ongoing data engineering resources.
  • Higher Initial Cost: Costs associated with ELT tools, data warehousing, and skilled personnel.
  • Longer Time-to-Value: Takes more time to set up and mature the pipeline.
  • Maintenance Overhead: Requires continuous monitoring, updates, and optimization of the data pipeline.

Comparison Table

Feature/Aspect	Dedicated Platform (e.g., Segmetrics)	Connectors + BI Tool (e.g., Supermetrics + Looker Studio)	Custom ELT + Data Warehouse + BI Tool (DIY)
Core Purpose	Out-of-box attribution, marketing analytics	Flexible data aggregation, custom reporting	Holistic data management, advanced analytics, custom logic
Data Granularity	High, but often aggregated in UI; raw access limited.	High, directly from source APIs, but can be complex to blend.	Full raw data access, infinite granularity, ultimate control.
Attribution Models	Pre-built (first/last touch, linear, W-shaped, custom rules).	Basic models possible via calculated fields/blending. Advanced models challenging.	Unlimited custom models via SQL or data science.
Customization	Configurable, but limited by platform features.	High for reporting and visualization; moderate for complex data logic.	Unlimited for data sources, transformations, logic, and reporting.
Engineering Effort	Low (setup, integration).	Medium (connector setup, data blending, calculated fields).	High (pipeline build, schema design, transformations, maintenance).
Cost (Relative)	Medium to High (SaaS subscription).	Low to Medium (connector subscription, free BI tool).	High (ELT tool, DWH, engineering team, maintenance).
Scalability	Good for defined use cases.	Can be limited by BI tool performance for very large datasets/complex blends.	Excellent, built for enterprise-grade data volumes.
Time to Value	Fastest (weeks).	Medium (weeks to a few months for complex reports).	Slowest (months to build a robust pipeline).
Data Ownership	Vendor-managed.	Managed by source APIs, accessed via connectors.	Your own data warehouse; full ownership.
Maintenance	Low (vendor handles infrastructure).	Medium (monitor connector health, update reports).	High (monitor ELT, DWH, transformations; pipeline orchestration).

Which Solution Should You Use?

The choice largely depends on your organization’s specific needs, budget, existing technical capabilities, and long-term data strategy:

• Choose a Dedicated Attribution Platform (e.g., Segmetrics) if:
  • You need a quick, out-of-the-box solution primarily focused on marketing attribution.
  • Your marketing team needs to own the solution with minimal IT intervention.
  • You prioritize speed-to-insight over deep data customization and ownership.
  • Your budget allows for a specialized SaaS subscription.
• Choose Data Connectors + BI Tool (e.g., Supermetrics & Looker Studio) if:
  • You already have a strong BI team familiar with Looker Studio or similar tools.
  • You need flexible reporting and dashboards, and can define attribution rules within the BI tool’s capabilities.
  • Your data volume is moderate, and attribution logic is not overly complex.
  • You want to consolidate reporting without a full-blown data warehouse investment.
• Choose Custom ELT + Data Warehouse + BI Tool (DIY) if:
  • You have a dedicated data engineering team or are building one.
  • You require ultimate control, scalability, and ownership of your raw data.
  • You need to implement highly customized, sophisticated, or data-science-driven attribution models.
  • You envision this marketing data as part of a larger, enterprise-wide data strategy.
  • Long-term flexibility, future-proofing, and the ability to integrate with any tool are paramount.

For many growing organizations, a hybrid approach might emerge. Starting with Supermetrics + Looker Studio can provide immediate value. As complexity and data volume grow, migrating to a custom ELT/Data Warehouse solution becomes a natural progression, often using Supermetrics’ data warehouse connectors or open-source ELT tools like Airbyte to facilitate the transition.

Ultimately, investing in a robust attribution solution is an investment in understanding your customer and optimizing your marketing spend. Carefully consider your technical resources, immediate business needs, and future scalability requirements when making your decision.

---

👉 Read the original article on TechResolve.blog