DEV Community

Shariful Ehasan
Shariful Ehasan

Posted on

Laravel Policies: Do You Really Use Them in Real Projects?

#laravel #php #webdev #beginners

Laravel Policies are a powerful feature for managing authorization logic in a clean, reusable way. They allow developers to define access control rules for specific models, keeping authorization logic separate from controllers and views. But are they really used in real-world projects, or are they just a shiny feature that sounds good on paper? Let’s dive into their practical use, benefits, and when you might skip them.

What Are Laravel Policies?

Policies in Laravel are classes that organize authorization logic for a specific model or resource. They’re typically used with Laravel’s Gate or the authorize() method to control access to actions like viewing, creating, updating, or deleting resources. For example, a PostPolicy might define who can edit or delete a blog post.


namespace App\Policies;

use App\Models\Post;

use App\Models\User;

class PostPolicy

{

public function update(User $user, Post $post)

{

return $user->id === $post->user_id;

}

}
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

You register policies in the AuthServiceProvider and use them in controllers or middleware to enforce access rules.

Why Use Policies in Real Projects?

  1. Organized Code: Policies centralize authorization logic, making it easier to maintain than scattering checks across controllers or Blade templates.

  2. Reusability: A single policy can be reused across multiple controllers, routes, or even API endpoints.

  3. Scalability: As your application grows, policies make it easier to manage complex authorization rules without duplicating code.

  4. Testability: Policies are easy to unit test, ensuring your authorization logic is robust.

In real projects, policies shine in applications with multiple user roles or complex permissions. For instance, in a SaaS app with admins, editors, and viewers, policies ensure that only authorized users can perform specific actions. I’ve seen them used effectively in e-commerce platforms to restrict product management to sellers or in CMS systems to limit content editing to specific roles.

When Are Policies Overkill?

Not every project needs policies. For small apps with simple authorization (e.g., "only admins can do X"), basic middleware or simple if checks might suffice. Policies add overhead in terms of setup and maintenance, so if your app has minimal authorization needs, you might skip them to avoid over-engineering.

For example, in a small blog with just one admin, a simple check like $user->isAdmin() in a controller might be enough. Policies become more valuable when you have multiple models, roles, or fine-grained permissions.

Real-World Usage

In my experience, policies are common in mid-to-large Laravel projects. For instance:

  • Enterprise Apps: Policies are used to enforce role-based access control (RBAC) for different departments or user types.

  • APIs: Policies pair well with Laravel’s resource controllers to secure API endpoints.

  • Open-Source Projects: Many popular Laravel packages and projects, like Laravel Nova or Spatie’s Permission package, integrate with or rely on policies for authorization.

However, some developers opt for alternatives like Spatie’s Laravel Permission package, which provides a more flexible role and permission system. Policies are still relevant but may be combined with such packages for added functionality.

Tips for Using Policies Effectively

  • Keep Them Simple: Don’t overload policies with complex logic; break it down into clear, single-responsibility methods.

  • Use with Middleware: Leverage Laravel’s can middleware to apply policies at the route level.

  • Combine with Gates: Use policies alongside Gates for one-off authorization checks.

  • Document Your Logic: Clearly comment your policies to make them easier to understand for other developers.

Conclusion

Yes, Laravel Policies are used in real projects, especially where clean, maintainable authorization logic is critical. They’re not mandatory for every project, but they’re a fantastic tool for scaling applications with complex access control needs. If you’re working on a Laravel project with multiple roles or resources, give policies a try—they’ll likely save you time and headaches in the long run.

What’s your experience with Laravel Policies? Do you use them, or do you prefer another approach? Share your thoughts below!

Top comments (0)