What is a peer dependency and what is the problem with it?
Peer dependencies are a specific kind of dependencies really useful for reusable modules:
- Ask user to install a dependency your module needs to work without specifying a version in particular
- Prevents having multiple version of a same module in user's app node_modules
- Reduce javascript files size to load on browser side particularly useful for mobile users
The problem with peer dependencies is npm and yarn don't install them at all. This is the right behavior for production purpose but when you are developing you might need to test your module in a host app. npm and yarn provide a command to achieve it called link that basically creates a symlink into the host app node_modules to your module source folder. It works fine but you also need to execute tasks in your module that needs these dependencies. For example, you might want to execute tests. Since they aren't present in your module's node_modules you will experience errors like this:
Cannot find module 'react' from 'index.js'
yarn and npm don't provide tools to install peer dependencies for your development environment. There is an opened issue on yarn repository since 27 October 2016 but yarn has a special script called prepare that is executed after dependencies installation only on development mode maybe we could do something with it 🤔. Let's find a way to set up a work around!
Solve the problem
I made a repository with all the sources to reproduce the problem.
We have the following folder structure:
.
├── LICENSE
├── README.md
├── app
│ ├── node_modules
│ ├── package.json
└── lib
├── node_modules
└── package.json
First of all we will set up a link so the app's node_modules point to the lib folder.
You must install dependencies and you might also need to build your module first
cd lib
yarn link
cd ../app
yarn link lib
At this point if you start your application you could use your module without any trouble. The problem appears when you try to execute things into your module folder as I said before like tests. To solve this we will use prepare script from yarn and the package install-peers-cli.
install-peers-cli is a cli that install peer dependencies of a package. It should be called after dependencies installation. Fortunately prepare is called after dependencies installation and only when you are developing so it won't install the peer dependencies when a user install your module.
First install install-peers-cli package:
yarn add -D install-peers-cli
Then add the prepare script in your module's package.json and call install-peers-cli in it:
// package.json
{
"scripts": {
"prepare": "install-peers"
}
}
Now you could start anything that use your peer dependencies without experiencing errors. Unless your module uses React and his new addition Hooks...
For React using hooks
If you follow previous steps you should have an error with the following message "hooks can only be called inside the body of a function component". This error occurs when you have multiple copies of React in your node_modules folder. In this comment Dan Abramov explain the solution to this well known issue. Let's put it into pratice.
You should go in the react folder that is present in your module's node_modules and create a link. Then go back to your host app folder and use this link.
cd lib/node_module/react
yarn link
cd ../../../app
yarn link react
Now the error should be fixed and you could use your module into your host app!
You're all set 🙌!
See a typo? Don't hesitate to open an issue or make a pull request on the article's repository
Top comments (24)
The
yarn linkimplementation will, from the v2 onward, be able to properly follow peer dependencies. So if you're developingreact-foowhich has a peer dependency onreact, you'll just have to go into your application, runyarn add react,yarn link ~/react-foo, and you'll be ready to go.Really nice to hear Maël! I can't wait to test yarn v2. Is there an alpha version available or something similar?
We're developing it over at github.com/yarnpkg/berry - it's usable, but still developer preview for now 🙂
Is there a way to get this to work with other peer dependencies? It works great when it's just
react, but I have several peer dependencies (such asreact-redux) which is causing conflicts. I've been messing around with this a lot and I'm having trouble getting it to work.You tried to do the same trick described in the article for
react(linked module dependency directly into your host app) ? I agree this is a bit messy. You can use yarn v2 to fix this problem (I guess). See Maël Nison's comment on this article. He explains how it works in yarn v2 and where you can install this new version 👍Oh that's a better solution, thanks. I'd use that but my team uses NPM. I ended up just installing the peer dependencies for our library into
peer_deps/node_modulesso it's not picked up by the app but can still be used by the library during development.Unfortunately, the linking solution for the React library did not work for me. The link seemed to set up just fine, but when I launched the consumer app I got the dreaded "Invalid hook call," same as before setting up the link to react.
It didn't work for me too in the beginning, but after I deleted the node_modules in the library, reinstall and did the linking again between the library and parent App, it works. Maybe something you could try.
I do know to try this, but unfortunately it does not resolve the problem. I have run into this again while trying to develop a library. Very frustrating and link simply doesn't work to resolve this at all.
Do you have experience with this error?
Thanks in advance!
Hi Juan David Nicholls Cardona. Did you have this message using
install-peer-depsin thepreparescript ?yes, but only using npm, it was fixed by using yarn instead, thanks!
It's unfortunate that someone would make a package that only works with yarn! We can't just change our standards to use yarn just for one library. :(
Okay, I got it to work with npm by appending the force flag (-f), so my script command is now "install-peers -f". Seems to be a bug in the library and there is an open github issue already about this.
You can use "postinstall": "install-peers", this command run after the package is installed.
This work for me.
Thanks you, i found that comment from Dan but i really don't understood how to do it
So it works fine for you now?
Yes! It works!
I think a simpler solution is to add the peerDeps also as devDeps. I don't know if it is the best one, but is way simpler than what you propose here.
That is one way to do it. One disadvantage, though, is having to manually keep dev and peer in sync. The advantage is not needing another library to install peers. So it's a matter of which trade-off you prefer. Myself, I'm more worried about the error-prone nature of manually duplicating two lists in my package.json so I'm standardizing on just going and using install peers. But I also understand why someone would want to avoid yet another library.
Thank you for sharing! I'll test it and a note about it in the article 👌
Thanks for the useful guide! The original package read me didn't say much about this usage.
🙌
If its failing in the tests, put 'react' in both peer-dependencies and dev-dependencies.