As a developer, we often face a common question:
👉 Should I stick to MVC or move towards Modular MVC (HMVC)?
Let’s break this down in a simple way with real-life examples.
✨ Why MVC?
🔹 What is MVC and How it Works?
MVC means Model – View – Controller.
- Model → Data & Business logic (example: Database structure)
- View → Traditionally HTML templates (UI)
- Controller → Request/Response handling (connects Model & View)
🔹 Imagine you are building a small restaurant management system.
- Model = Menu Items (stored in DB)
- View = Menu page UI
- Controller = When user clicks on “Order”, controller fetches data from Model & shows in View
🔹 Benefits of MVC
- Clear separation of concerns (Data, UI, Logic)
- Easy for beginners & small teams
- Faster to implement for small projects
🔹 Backdrops (Limitations)
- Controllers become too big (“God Controller” problem)
- Hard to maintain in large projects
- Not team-friendly when many developers work together
- Traditional View layer is outdated for modern frontend needs
✨ Why Modular MVC (HMVC)?
🔹 What is Modular MVC and How it Works?
Modular MVC (HMVC) is an extension of MVC.
👉 Instead of one big MVC structure, we break the project into modules.
Each module has its own MVC.
🔹 Example: You are building an Online Library System.
- Accounts Module → user login, profile
- Books Module → book details, borrowing system
- Reviews Module → user feedback
Each module follows MVC independently, but connects to a core system.
🔹 Benefits of Modular MVC
- Highly maintainable (each module is independent)
- Perfect for large/complex systems
- Multiple developers can work simultaneously (team-friendly)
- Easier to scale & debug
- Works seamlessly with modern frontend (React, Vue, Angular) when backend provides APIs
🔹 Backdrops (Limitations)
- More initial setup compared to simple MVC
- Slightly complex structure for beginners
⚡But in Modern Web Development
Today’s development flow is a bit different:
- Backend (MVC or Modular MVC) → Focuses on Models + Controllers only, and mostly provides REST or GraphQL APIs.
- Frontend (React, Vue, Angular) → Handles the View layer completely.
🔹 Example: In StudySphere project, backend (Django Rest Framework) works as API provider, and React/Vue manages the UI.
So in practice, the “V” in MVC is no longer server-rendered templates; it’s often a separate frontend application.
⚡ When to Use Which?
Use MVC →
If your project is small or medium (like a To-do app, blog site, portfolio, or small e-commerce).
👉 Example: A Personal Portfolio Website → MVC is enough.
Use Modular MVC (HMVC) →
If your project is large, multi-featured, or needs scaling in future.
👉 Example: StudySphere (Tuition Media Platform) or Library Management System → Modular MVC is the better choice.
💡Follow for more insights:
If you enjoyed this article, follow me on Dev.to for more posts on Web Development, MVC, Modular MVC, Backend & Frontend best practices, and scalable projects.
Top comments (0)