Is CUE language a better alternative to YAML not just for Kubernetes?
Photo by David Herron on Unsplash
Meaning of the photo
According to Wikipedia:
A cue stick (or simply cue, more specifically billiards cue, pool cue, or snooker cue) is an item of sporting equipment essential to the games of pool, snooker and carom billiards
Is the tooling for YAML enough?
How is it possible that the tooling for YAML is so lacking?
I always thought that given YAML is so ubiquitous, there would be better tooling than what we currently got in 2023.
Between the many use of YAML, you can run your applications with Kubernetes, deploy your cloud infrastructure with Pulumi, and write automation pipelines with GitHub actions.
Personally, I even use YAML to write my automation scripts with Taskfile, a more user-friendly alternative to Makefile. More on this later.
Was writing JSON so bad that we had to invent a new language, losing in the process the schema validation?
When I started writing Kubernetes manifests in YAML, I found myself many times wondering if my YAML was valid and if I should have added one tab to a list of items. I think I miss JSON sometimes.
Given that DevOps Engineers write more YAML than any other language, and Kubernetes manifests are so verbose, I always thought someone would create a better alternative.
CUE language
I believe they finally did create a better alternative than YAML, or at least I finally discovered it.
Let me introduce CUE language.
CUE is an open-source language, with a rich set of APIs and tooling, for defining, generating, and validating all kinds of data: configuration, APIs, database schemas, code, … you name it.
CUE stands for Configure Unify Execute.
From the official CueLang website you can find all the official use cases of CueLang (that I reported here to make it easier for you to consume):
Data validation. Validate text-based data files or programmatic data such as incoming RPCs or database documents.
Configuration. Just add validation to existing data (CUE, YAML, JSON), reduce boilerplate in large-scale configurations, or both.
Schema Definition. Define schema to communicate an API or standard and validate backward compatibility.
Generate Code and Schema. Keep validation code in sync across code bases, Protobuf definitions, and OpenAPI definitions.
Scripting. Automate the use of your data without writing yet another tool.
Querying. Find the locations of instances of CUE types and values in data.
Given the extensive use of CueLang, I would expect that it would be mentioned more online.
I think the choice of the name is a bit unfortunate since cue is such a common verb in English that searching online for cue would return completely unrelated content.
For this reason, the community is using instead the word CueLang or CUE (all uppercase) to mean the CUE language and not the verb to cue.
Personal note
I first heard about CueLang more than 6 months ago when I bumped into Dagger.io while looking for a better alternative to Makefile. Dagger wasn’t a good match for me, but I liked CueLang as an idea. I didn’t look too much into CueLang at that time, since I have never heard it before and I didn’t need Dagger.io.
I ended up discovering Taskfile instead, and since then I use it every single day to automate anything from setting infrastructure to running integration tests and everything in between. I’ll probably write about Taskfile in the future, that’s not the point right now.
Since that time with Dagger.io, I haven’t heard about CueLang until this week, when I watched a great video by Viktor Farcic.
https://medium.com/media/23175907128d09bb3cc68d51c092fa84/href
In this video, Viktor compared multiple alternatives for writing Kubernetes manifests including Helm, Kustomize, Carvel Ytt, CDK8S, and CueLang.
It’s a great video, I highly suggest you have a look.
Spoiler alert, CueLang was the winner.
Having used or at least tried all the other alternatives, and never been fully happy with any of them, I was at least curious to look deeper into CueLang. Especially if that meant making my life as a YAML Engineer (this is what I call myself these days) a bit less miserable.
So I did a bit of research, and this is what I found out:
- CueLang has over 4k stars on GitHub. It might not seem like a lot but it is a niche tool. That’s a lot more than 1.4k stars for a similar tool Carvel YTT. Sorry, Carvel.
- CueLang integrates with JSON, YAML, Go, Protobuf, OpenAPI, and Kubernetes. More information about integrations.
- Istio uses CUE to generate OpenAPI.
- You can define tasks and scripts with CueLang.
It looks great! How is it not used everywhere?
Looking back at Dagger.io, CueLang seems to be gone from their quickstart documentation since it hasn’t been ported to Dagger Engine 0.3 as highlighted by this PR that was closed for inactivity on December 2022.
I assume that CUE has still to maturate as a language. I hope I am doing my part to spread the word.
Documentation for CueLang
A great short article on how to use CueLang to write and validate Kubernetes manifests has been written by Elton Minetto.
Then there is the official CueLang documentation, which I find good as a starting point and for reference but unfortunately, it doesn’t give lots of details about its use for Kubernetes.
A great resource with lots of documentation is Cuetorials. There is a lot to unpack from this resource.
Finally another great tutorial at Validate Your YAML (with CUE) from Earthly.
Conclusion
I’m still just at the beginning of my learning path into CueLang but it looks very promising.
I hope to write a more hands-on tutorial about CueLang when I learn more about it.
For now, I would appreciate to learn your opinion on the topic. Is CueLang a great tool? Have you used it? Where and how?
Call to Action
Did you enjoy what you’ve read here? Do you find yourself intrigued, inspired, or even challenged by the perspectives shared? If the answer is a resounding yes, then I’d like to personally invite you to join our thriving community by subscribing to my newsletter on Substack.
Subscribe now to Cloud Native Engineer Newsletter
Want to connect? 🐦 Twitter | 🔗 LinkedIn | 👽 Reddit | 📰 My blog
Thanks for reading my article! Before you go:
- 👏 Clap for the story | ✍️ Add a comment | ⚓ Follow me
This article was originally posted at CueLang: a better alternative for Kubernetes manifests
Top comments (0)