DEV Community

Cover image for Top 5 DEV Comments from the Past Week

Top 5 DEV Comments from the Past Week

Peter Kim Frank on October 30, 2018

This is a weekly roundup of awesome DEV comments that you may have missed. You are welcome and encouraged to boost posts and comments yourself usi...
Collapse
 
sandordargo profile image
Sandor Dargo

Just out of curiousity, how do you pick the top 5?

Collapse
 
peter profile image
Peter Kim Frank The DEV Team

I start by taking a list of the comments over the previous seven days that have accrued the most ❤️reactions. However, it's not a strict descending list. I also take into account the comment's place within the broader discussion.

Without a bit of editorial oversight, for instance, something like three of the top five would have originated from the same thread, primarily because it was so popular and controversial.

Collapse
 
sandordargo profile image
Sandor Dargo

Thanks for the honest answer, transparency is always good. So technically it's more like 5 popular comments of the week. Though I understand why you don't want to just pick the top 5. I realized it when I checked the referenced comments and sometimes they are not even the most liked reactions in the given thread.

The same question goes for the "Top7" articles. What are the criteria there? It also doesn't seem like a clear descending list.

Thread Thread
 
jess profile image
Jess Lee The DEV Team

Hey @sandordargo ! Good question. The Top 7 is not a descending list either -- the two main factors we take into consideration are page views and community engagement. We also try to editorialize a bit so a range of topics are represented.

Thread Thread
 
sandordargo profile image
Sandor Dargo

Thanks for the explanation, Jess. Now, I won't scratch my head anymore when I don't make it to the list with an article with more reactions than some of the others. In the end, there might be ones with even more outside the weekly top 7 :D It's really good to know, that it is not a bug, but a decision.

Collapse
 
peter profile image
Peter Kim Frank The DEV Team

Congrats @nezteb , @sergio , @tux0r , @simonhaisz , and @bintlopez for making the list this week!

Collapse
 
sergio profile image
deleteme deleteme

Thanks @peter !

Collapse
 
simonhaisz profile image
simonhaisz • Edited

Next achievement: ^\w+$

Collapse
 
joelnet profile image
JavaScript Joel

I'd like to see a Comment from the Top 5 Comments article make it into the next Top 5 Comments article!

Collapse
 
simonhaisz profile image
simonhaisz

Does Dev.to support tail-end comments?