When you’re building a payment system, data protection and security are always top of mind. You’re constantly figuring out how to protect customer data without hurting system performance. Every transaction carries sensitive information, such as bank account details, card numbers, and personally identifiable information (PII). These are exactly the kinds of details malicious actors want to steal.
You’ve probably heard of data tokenization and encryption as industry standards for processing and securing payment data. While both protect sensitive information and are often mentioned together, they work in very different ways. Knowing how each one functions and when to use them can make your system safer and easier to maintain.
In this guide, we’ll break down the differences between tokenization and encryption, how they work, where they’re used, and how you can combine them in your payment system.
What is Tokenization?
Tokenization replaces sensitive data, such as a debit or credit card number, social security number, or other confidential details, with a random, non-sensitive placeholder called a Token. This token is simply a string of characters with no connection to the original data. Even if a token is compromised, it is useless to an attacker because it does not contain any meaningful information.
These tokens are managed by a tokenization system, typically a secure software service that stores the original sensitive data in a protected database called a token vault. The vault is isolated and heavily protected from unauthorized access. During transactions, the system uses the token instead of the original data. In some cases, the system may need to perform a process called detokenization, which means retrieving the original data to complete certain operations under strict security controls. By design, tokens are irreversible, and the original data cannot be derived without access to the token vault.
How Tokenization Works
Below is an overview of how tokenization works:
When a customer enters sensitive details, like a credit card number, your system doesn’t handle the raw data directly. Instead, it passes the information to a tokenization service. This service replaces the real data with a randomly generated, non-sensitive token and securely stores the relationship between the token and the original information in a protected vault.
From that point on, your application works only with the token, never the actual card number. And if the original data is ever required to complete a transaction, the token can be sent back to the vault, where the true information is retrieved under strict security measures.
What is Tokenization Used For?
Tokenization is widely adopted across industries and has many practical applications. Some common examples include:
- E-commerce Platforms: When customers save their payment methods for future purchases, you store tokens instead of actual card numbers. This protects both your business and your customers from financial losses due to unauthorized access to card data.
- Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS): Tokenization helps you meet PCI DSS requirements by protecting credit card data and reducing the risk of breaches and fraud.
- Subscription Services: Businesses like Netflix or Spotify that rely on recurring billing use tokenization to process monthly charges without storing actual card numbers.
- Healthcare: Tokenization can safeguard patient health information (PHI), such as demographic, administrative, and medical data. This supports compliance with Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) data protection regulations and patient privacy.
- Financial Services: Whether you are building mobile money apps, point-of-sale systems, or peer-to-peer platforms, tokenization protects sensitive financial data involved in transactions.
What is Encryption?
Encryption is the process of transforming readable data into an unreadable format using a cryptographic algorithm. An algorithm is a set of mathematical rules combined with a key that determines how the data is scrambled. Unlike tokenization, encrypted data maintains a mathematical relationship with the original data. Think of it as writing a message in secret code, where only someone with the right key can unlock the original message.
Here’s an example of encrypting a credit card number:
- Customer Data: “4532-1234-5678-9012”
- Key: “TopSecret”
- Algorithm: Advanced Encryption Standard (AES)
- Encrypted Output: Using the key “TopSecret,” the algorithm transforms the plaintext into something like “A7B9C2D4E6F8G1H3J5K7L9M2N4P6.”
In this case, only someone with the correct key and knowledge of the algorithm can decrypt the text back into the original credit card number.
Common encryption algorithms include:
- Symmetric Encryption (e.g., AES-256)
- Asymmetric Encryption (e.g., RSA, ECC)
How Encryption Works
Below is an overview of how encryption works:
When a customer sends sensitive information, it is never transmitted in plain text. Instead, the system generates an encryption key and uses a strong algorithm, such as AES-256, to transform the original data into ciphertext.
This encrypted data is then transferred and stored securely in the database. When the system needs the original information, the same encryption key is applied to decrypt the ciphertext back into its readable form.
What is Encryption Used For?
Encryption helps protect sensitive data, whether it’s being transmitted or stored. Some common use cases include:
- Transmission and Communication: Encrypt payment data sent between your frontend and backend, or between your system and payment processors, using TLS/SSL protocols.
- Data Storage: Encrypt sensitive information like personal data, financial records, and confidential business documents before storing them on devices or servers. This ensures that unauthorized users cannot read the data.
- Virtual Private Networks (VPNs): VPNs use encryption to create secure connections over public networks, allowing users to securely access resources. You can use VPNs to protect data transmitted between offices and remote employees.
- Backup Systems: Encrypt backup data so that even if the backup systems are compromised, the information remains unreadable without the encryption keys.
- Legacy System Integration: For older systems that cannot implement tokenization, encryption provides a way to secure data while maintaining compatibility.
Tokenization vs. Encryption: Which is Better for Payment Data Security?
Tokenization and encryption are complementary techniques, but they differ in how they secure payment data. The table below highlights the key differences:
| Aspect | Tokenization | Encryption |
|---|---|---|
| Reversibility | Not reversible (tokens can’t reveal original data) | Reversible with the right key |
| Security Risk | If attackers get tokens without access to the vault, they’re useless. | If attackers steal both encrypted data and keys, the original data is exposed. |
| Compliance | Reduces PCI scope since raw data isn’t stored | Still counts as storing sensitive data elements, so PCI burden remains |
| Performance | Lightweight, since no cryptographic operations needed in your app | Heavier, since encryption and decryption require processing |
| Data Format | Can preserve the original data format | Transform the original data structure |
The choice between tokenization and encryption depends on your specific use case, but here's what you need to know across key factors:
Security
Tokenization is ideal for payment data because tokens have no mathematical relationship to the original data. Even if tokens are compromised, they are meaningless.
Encryption is still secure, but if both the encrypted data and the encryption key are compromised, the original data can be decrypted.
Compliance Requirements
Tokenization reduces PCI DSS scope because your system does not store actual card details. This lowers compliance costs, reduces audits, and minimizes documentation requirements.
Encryption, on the other hand, requires full PCI DSS compliance, including regular security assessments and controls, since the encrypted cardholder data is still considered sensitive.
Performance Impact
Encryption can be faster for real-time operations because most frameworks and libraries have built-in encryption capabilities that make encrypting and decrypting nearly instantaneous.
Tokenization requires network calls to a token vault for token generation and retrieval, which can add latency to your payment operations.
Application Architecture
Tokenization requires a separate service or vault, which adds components that must be monitored and maintained. This separation improves security through isolated data handling.
Encryption can be implemented entirely within your application stack, without external dependencies. This gives full control, but requires careful management of encryption keys and secure implementation.
As a rule of thumb:
Use tokenization when:
- You're handling credit card numbers, bank account details, or other payment instruments.
- Reducing PCI compliance scope is a priority.
- You don't need to perform operations on the actual payment data.
- You're building customer-facing applications where data breaches would be catastrophic.
- You want to minimize the risk of insider threats accessing sensitive data.
Use encryption when:
- You need to perform searches, sorts, or other operations on the protected data.
- You're securing data in transit between systems.
- You're working with legacy systems that can't integrate with tokenization services.
- You need complete control over your security infrastructure.
- You're protecting data types that don't have established tokenization standards.
While tokenization and encryption have distinct use cases, combining both can create a robust, layered security system for payment data. Let’s explore that next.
Combining Tokenization and Encryption
In practice, most secure payment systems use both tokenization and encryption together, like:
- Encrypt data in transit using TLS when sending information between your frontend, backend, and payment processors.
- Tokenize payment details for long-term storage and recurring transactions.
- Encrypt database backups as an additional layer of protection for tokenized data.
- Use field-level data encryption for sensitive non-payment data, such as customer addresses or phone numbers.
An example of this in practice is when your customer submits a payment form, you can encrypt data during transmission, tokenize the card number for storage, and encrypt other personal details in your database.
Wrap Up
Both tokenization and encryption play vital roles in payment security, but they address different problems. Tokenization is ideal for protecting stored payment data by removing it from your system, while encryption secures data during transmission and processing.
For most payment applications, tokenization should be your primary strategy for handling credit cards and bank account numbers. It reduces your security risks and lowers compliance burdens. Encryption should be used to protect data in transit and for sensitive information that must be processed directly.
Security is not about choosing one approach over the other. The strongest payment systems combine both techniques strategically, using each where it offers the greatest benefit.
Ready to implement secure tokenization and encryption in your payment system? Flutterwave offers built-in tokenization and encryption capabilities that handle the complexity for you, so you can focus on building great payment experiences while staying secure and compliant.
Top comments (0)