Little Choices That Shape User Experience

Hello, I'm Maneshwar. I’m building LiveReview, a private AI code review tool that runs on your LLM key (OpenAI, Gemini, etc.) with highly competitive pricing -- built for small teams. Do check it out and give it a try!

When people interact with digital products, they often take the path of least resistance.

One of the most effective ways to guide them smoothly through an experience is by setting sensible defaults — pre-selected options or settings that reflect the most common or most helpful choice.

Good defaults reduce friction, save time, and prevent confusion.

Let’s dive into why defaults matter, how they influence behavior, and how to use them responsibly.

Why Defaults Work So Well

Human behavior shows a strong tendency to accept what’s already set for us.

A famous study from Cornell University highlighted this with search results:

• When users saw normal search listings, 42% clicked the first link and 8% clicked the second.
• Researchers then secretly swapped the top two results. Even though the “true” best result moved down, users still clicked the new first link 34% of the time and the second link 12% of the time.

The takeaway? Users don’t just pick the objectively best option — they lean heavily on what’s put in front of them first.

Defaults exploit this same principle.

Benefits of Smart Defaults

1. Convenience for users People don’t always want to make decisions for every small step. Defaults remove unnecessary effort, letting them move forward without overthinking.
2. Fewer mistakes Pre-selecting safe or compatible choices helps prevent errors (e.g., wrong formats, mismatched options).
3. Encouraging better behavior Defaults can promote healthier, safer, or more sustainable choices. For instance, setting privacy controls to “high” by default nudges people toward stronger security.

Practical Examples

• Search engines: The top result usually gets clicked most, regardless of actual quality.
• This mirrors how users accept defaults in forms or apps.
• Forms: If someone is registering for a New York event, pre-filling “United States” as the country saves time for the majority of attendees.
• Subscriptions: Many platforms default to the yearly plan because it’s the most common and profitable choice.
• Done ethically, this saves users clicks. Done poorly (e.g., always selecting the priciest option), it erodes trust.

Best Practices for Defaulting

• Know your audience: Research what the most common or useful options are before setting them as defaults.
• Stay transparent: Let users know the system made a choice for them, and always make it easy to change.
• Keep defaults fresh: Review them regularly. What’s “standard” today might not be tomorrow as user needs evolve.

Final Thoughts

Defaults aren’t just about convenience they shape how people interact with products.

When done thoughtfully, they reduce effort, cut down on mistakes, and encourage positive behaviors.

But with great power comes responsibility: if defaults are self-serving or manipulative, users quickly lose trust.

In UX design, the best default is the one that feels invisible it simply makes the experience smoother without the user even realizing it.

LiveReview helps you get great feedback on your PR/MR in a few minutes.

Saves hours on every PR by giving fast, automated first-pass reviews.

If you're tired of waiting for your peer to review your code or are not confident that they'll provide valid feedback, here's LiveReview for you.