Understanding `sometimes` vs. `nullable` in Laravel Validation: When to Use Each

Validation is a crucial part of web development, ensuring data integrity and security. In Laravel, two commonly misunderstood validation rules are sometimes and nullable. While both make fields optional, they behave differently. This article explains their differences, use cases, and best practices.

---

1. What Do sometimes and nullable Mean?

nullable Rule

• Purpose: Allows a field to be null or an empty string ("").
• Behavior:
  • The field must exist in the request.
  • If provided, it can be null or an empty string.
  • Other validation rules (e.g., string, email) are skipped if the value is null or "".

sometimes Rule

• Purpose: Validates a field only if it exists in the request.
• Behavior:
  • If the field is missing, validation is skipped entirely.
  • If the field exists, all other rules apply.
  • Does not allow null unless combined with nullable.

---

2. Key Differences

Feature	nullable	sometimes
Field must exist?	✅ Yes	❌ No (optional)
Allows null?	✅ Yes	❌ No (unless combined with nullable)
Allows empty string ("")?	✅ Yes	❌ No (unless combined with nullable)
Validation applies if field exists?	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
Use case	Field is required but can be empty	Field is completely optional

---

3. Practical Examples

Example 1: Using nullable

$request->validate([
    'name' => 'required|string',
    'bio' => 'nullable|string|max:500', // Must be present but can be empty
]);

• Valid Inputs:

  • {"name": "John", "bio": "Laravel developer"}
  • {"name": "John", "bio": ""}
  • {"name": "John", "bio": null}

• Invalid Input:

  • {"name": "John"} ❌ (Missing bio field)

Example 2: Using sometimes

$request->validate([
    'name' => 'required|string',
    'age' => 'sometimes|integer|min:18', // Optional field
]);

• Valid Inputs:

  • {"name": "John", "age": 25}
  • {"name": "John"} ✅ (No age provided)

• Invalid Inputs:

  • {"name": "John", "age": "twenty"} ❌ (Must be an integer)
  • {"name": "John", "age": null} ❌ (null is not allowed unless nullable is added)

---

4. When to Use Each

Use nullable When:

• A field must be present in the request but can be empty.
• Example:
  • A user’s "bio" field that can be left blank.
  • An optional "phone_number" that should appear in the form but doesn’t require a value.

Use sometimes When:

• A field is completely optional (may not exist in the request).
• Example:
  • An optional "discount_code" in a checkout API.
  • A "preferences" object that only appears if the user modifies settings.

Combining Both (sometimes|nullable)

If a field is optional and can be null or empty:

$request->validate([
    'notes' => 'sometimes|nullable|string', // Optional, can be null/empty
]);

• Valid Inputs:
  • {"notes": "Some notes"}
  • {"notes": ""}
  • {"notes": null}
  • {} (Missing entirely)

---

5. Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Assuming sometimes allows null

   • Without nullable, sometimes fails on null values.
   • Fix: Use sometimes|nullable if null is acceptable.

2. Using nullable when the field should be optional

   • If a field can be omitted entirely, sometimes is better.

3. Not testing edge cases

   • Always test:
     • Missing fields (sometimes).
     • Empty strings (nullable).
     • null values (nullable).

---

6. Best Practices

✔ Use sometimes for truly optional fields (e.g., API parameters that may not exist).

✔ Use nullable for fields that must appear but can be empty (e.g., form inputs).

✔ Combine them (sometimes|nullable) if a field is optional and can be null.

✔ Test all cases (missing, empty, null, valid, and invalid values).

---

Conclusion

• nullable → "This field must exist but can be empty."
• sometimes → "This field is optional; validate it only if provided."
• sometimes|nullable → "This field is optional, and if provided, it can be empty."

Choosing the right rule ensures proper validation while maintaining flexibility. Use sometimes when a field may not exist at all, and nullable when it must exist but can be blank.

Final Tip: Always test with null, empty strings, and missing fields to ensure your validation behaves as expected! 🚀