DEV Community

Cover image for OAuth vs SAML
Rakesh Reddy Peddamallu
Rakesh Reddy Peddamallu

Posted on

OAuth vs SAML

Let's break it down: OAuth and SAML are both protocols used for authentication and authorization, but they serve slightly different purposes and operate in different ways.


πŸ” OAuth (Open Authorization)

  • Purpose: Primarily used for authorization, allowing third-party applications to access user data without exposing passwords.
  • How it Works:

    1. User Consent: The user grants permission for an application to access their information (like email, profile, etc.).
    2. Access Token: The application gets an access token from an authorization server.
    3. Data Access: The application uses this token to access resources from the resource server (like Google APIs).
  • Key Points:

    • Token-based.
    • Mainly used for APIs and mobile/web apps.
    • Scenarios: "Login with Google/Facebook" or allowing apps like Instagram to post on your behalf.
    • Tokens are usually Bearer tokens (like JWT).
  • Flow (Simplified):

    1. User logs into an app via Google.
    2. Google prompts for permission and, upon approval, issues an access token.
    3. The app uses this token to access user's Google data.

πŸ‘₯ SAML (Security Assertion Markup Language)

  • Purpose: Used for Single Sign-On (SSO), especially in enterprise environments.
  • How it Works:

    1. User Access: The user tries to access a service (like Salesforce).
    2. Authentication Request: The service provider redirects the user to the Identity Provider (IdP) (like Okta or ADFS).
    3. Authentication: The IdP authenticates the user.
    4. SAML Assertion: The IdP sends a SAML assertion (an XML document) back to the service provider.
    5. Access Granted: The service provider validates the assertion and grants access.
  • Key Points:

    • XML-based.
    • Works best for enterprise applications (like internal tools, enterprise portals).
    • Focused on SSO for web apps.
    • Reduces password fatigue by allowing one login for multiple services.

πŸ†š OAuth vs. SAML

Aspect OAuth SAML
Purpose Authorization (accessing resources) Authentication (user identity confirmation)
Format JSON tokens (like JWT) XML assertions
Best For APIs, mobile apps, third-party app permissions Enterprise SSO (web applications)
Common Use Login with Google, Facebook, API access Logging into multiple enterprise apps with one login
Token Type Access tokens SAML assertions

🎯 Which One to Use?

  • If you're building APIs or apps that require third-party permissions ➑️ OAuth.
  • If you're setting up Single Sign-On in an enterprise environment ➑️ SAML.

Want me to dive deeper into how one of these works, like explaining OAuth's token flow or how SAML assertions are structured? πŸš€

Top comments (0)

Sentry image

See why 4M developers consider Sentry, β€œnot bad.”

Fixing code doesn’t have to be the worst part of your day. Learn how Sentry can help.

Learn more