DEV Community

sophiaashi
sophiaashi

Posted on

I Posted 29 Times on Reddit, Wrote 46 Articles, and Got 1 Discord Member. Here Is What I Learned.

Sharing because I wish someone had told me this before I spent 36 hours on content marketing.

What I Did

I built TeamoRouter — an LLM routing gateway that auto-picks the cheapest model per task. Saves ~40% on API costs.

To get the first 20 Discord members, I went all in on content:

  • 29 Reddit posts across r/OpenClaw, r/artificial, r/SideProject
  • 143 Reddit comments
  • 46 Dev.to articles
  • 13 GitHub issue comments
  • 44 Reddit DMs
  • 5 awesome-list PRs

What I Got

  • Karma: 86 → 111 (+25)
  • 5 people messaged me on Reddit Chat asking about my setup
  • Several multi-round conversations with interested developers
  • Got banned from r/LocalLLaMA for posting too much
  • Discord: 4 → 5 members. Net gain: 1.

What Actually Worked

  1. Posts outperform comments 10:1. My top post ("what models do you use for different tasks") got 20 comments. Individual comments got zero engagement.
  2. People who messaged ME converted better than people I messaged. 44 outbound DMs = 0 Discord joins. 5 inbound Chat requests = actual conversations.
  3. GitHub issues are underrated. People there have real problems they need solved right now.
  4. Cost savings angle gets the most upvotes. But "auto model selection" is what people actually ask about in DMs.

What Failed

  1. Volume does not equal conversion. 143 comments and 44 DMs produced zero Discord members.
  2. Empty Discord = dead Discord. People clicked the link, saw an empty server, and left.
  3. Template comments get caught. Got called "bad bot" on r/LocalLLaMA and permanently banned.
  4. DMs mostly fail. 60%+ of users have DMs restricted.

What I Would Do Differently

  1. Fix the Discord experience FIRST (channels, welcome bot, seed content)
  2. Post less, engage more — quality conversations over quantity
  3. Focus on inbound (make content so good people come to you) over outbound (DMs)
  4. Launch on Indie Hackers and Hacker News before grinding Reddit

Building in public. Discord if you want to follow the journey or try the tool.

Top comments (0)