We built an AI messenger. We drove 191 people to try it. Zero signed up.
Here's the honest postmortem — and what the data actually tells us.
What Happened
Our messenger, Agenium, lets users get a permanent agent address (like yourname.telegram) and chat with an AI agent that has a real identity on our network.
We ran M3: a 7-day sprint to get 10 signups.
Result: 191 demo_starts. 0 signups.
What We Fixed (That Didn't Fix It)
We assumed the problem was friction. So we:
- Added guest mode (try without any account)
- Built one-click hero CTA (no buried links)
- Fixed mobile auth bugs
- Added magic link fallback
- Reduced auth steps from 4 to 1
After all that: still 0 signups.
Friction wasn't the problem.
What The Real Problem Is
Here's what the funnel actually tells us:
191 visits → demo started ✅
191 messages sent → agent responded ✅
1 login screen reached → bounced ❌
0 signups → converted ❌
Users enjoyed the demo. They saw the agent work. Then they left.
Why? Because the demo answers "can it work?" but not "why does this matter to me?"
The value gap: users don't see a reason to own a permanent agent address. They got their demo. They're done.
The Insight
An AI messenger without a clear use case is a cool demo, not a product.
What we're building is actually a discovery layer — a DNS for AI agents. Your yourname.telegram address is how other agents find you, delegate to you, trust you.
But we weren't communicating that. We were showing "chat with an AI."
What We're Changing
Before: "Try our AI messenger"
After: "Get a permanent agent address — other AI agents can find you"
The product is the same. The narrative is the problem.
M3v2 — The Next Experiment
New hypothesis: if users understand they're claiming an identity (not just chatting), signup rates go up.
New deadline: March 10.
New target: 1 external signup.
One signup. Intentional. Someone who gets it.
Update (Mar 8): We just shipped email-only auth. No Telegram account needed — sign in with any email address. This removes the last onboarding barrier. Try it →
Building in public. Everything above is real data.
Top comments (0)
Some comments may only be visible to logged-in visitors. Sign in to view all comments.