DEV Community

loading...

Discussion on: Golang through the eyes of a Java developer - pros and cons

Collapse
andreidascalu profile image
Andrei Dascalu • Edited

It's not that I don't agree. In fact, I'm familiar with the ideas as they're nearly the same as what I thought coming into Go from PHP. What I'm talking about is a bit of perspective on approaching a different language (and also a bit about separating what makes a language: aka the qualities of the language itself as separate from the platform, including its tooling and again separate from third party support in the form of IDEs).

Thing is, you should define what "idiomatic" means. From what I infer from conversations, it's mostly "the way of doing things that the language enforces or hints at" which is different than "how most people do it through materials/online howto's". I'm sure you also found that quick stackoverflow solutions and straight-to-the-point articles are hardly a collection of best practices. Reusing (or not) is not part of idiom, in this way. You could say that how most people approach solutions should be considered so (particularly because you'll see this in the stdlib, with the caveat that stdlib itself is a collection of tools and ready-made solutions made by people and hardly perfect) but in that case "idiomatic" loses any value since it's not a benchmark for current best practices and merely a mirror or what the majority o developers chose to do some time ago. Following the idiom in this way precludes progress and I've seen this first hand in PHP: it started as a bunch of useful scripts, then grew into a sort of procedural kind of thing before slowly developing OOP-ish ways. What's considered idiomatic has evolved, even if you'd find plenty of people nowadays that swear by procedural spaghetti code of ye olde days.

Thing is, I also liked the try/catch and lots of other stuff in PHP ... but it took learning a few languages that used different paradigms (ranging from slightly different to "other side of the world" different) to put some things into perspective and reconsider the qualities of what was familiar.