DEV Community

Debby McKinney
Debby McKinney

Posted on

Choosing an Evaluation Stack: LangSmith vs Langfuse vs Maxim

#ai #evaluations #aiops #devops

You don't need another fluffy "tool roundup." You need to know which stack helps you ship reliable agents, handle incidents, and pass audits. This is that guide.

Links

TL;DR

If you already know your constraints, jump to the Decision Matrix and the 30-Day Rollout Plan.

What “Good” Looks Like in an Evaluation Stack

Before you pick a tool, lock the outcomes.

Coverage that matches reality

You need session-level success for the full conversation and node-level checks for each agent step. That's how you find the exact failure, not just the vibe of a run. Maxim’s quality and metrics posts break down this two-layer approach and the metrics that track to real outcomes.

Realistic testing, not only single prompt runs

Your agents use tools, call APIs, and fetch context. You want simulations that cover those multi-step flows plus endpoint tests for critical paths. The difference between model evaluation and agent evaluation matters.

Observability that explains failures

Logging tokens is not enough. You need traces that show tool calls, retrieval hops, latency, cost, and failure reasons, with alerts so the right person gets pinged.

Governance that survives audits

Version every prompt. Control access. Keep audit trails. Align to policies. If you work in regulated environments, do not skip this.

A prompt practice that scales

Treat prompts like code. Version them, review changes, test side-by-side, and keep a clean structure.

Platform Snapshots

You want the short version first, then the details.

Langfuse in one paragraph

Langfuse is an open-source LLM engineering and observability platform. You get tracing for LLM and agent apps, evaluations with custom evaluators and LLM as a judge, prompt versioning, and human annotation queues. It is popular with teams that want to self-host and keep costs predictable. If you choose it, plan to build more of the evaluation workflow, alerting, and governance in your own stack.

LangSmith in one paragraph

LangSmith is the commercial platform from the LangChain team. It shines if your app uses LangChain or LangGraph. You get tracing, datasets that capture production traces for evaluation, LLM as a judge, human feedback, live dashboards for costs and latency, and alerts. You can use it outside LangChain through OpenTelemetry, though the smoothest developer experience is inside that ecosystem. Enterprise self-hosting and hybrid deployments are available.

Maxim in one paragraph

Maxim is a unified platform for agent simulation, evaluation, prompt management, observability, and enterprise controls. It covers multi-turn agent simulations, endpoint testing, LLM as a judge and human-in-the-loop evaluation, node-level and session-level metrics, real-time alerts, and governance like SSO, RBAC, and audit logs. It is built for teams that want one workflow from design to production, not a patchwork of tools.

Side-by-Side, the Stuff that Actually Matters

Deployment and Control

Tracing and Observability

Evaluation Depth

Prompt Management

Compliance and Governance

Decision Matrix

Score each from 1 to 5. Circle your non-negotiables.

  • Multi-turn agent simulation
  • API endpoint testing
  • Dataset-backed evals using prod traces
  • Node-level evaluation
  • LLM as a judge and human feedback
  • Prompt versioning with side-by-side review
  • OpenTelemetry support
  • Real-time alerts into Slack or PagerDuty
  • Audit trails and fine-grained RBAC
  • Hybrid or in-VPC deployment
  • Cost predictability at scale

How to read the scores:

  • If open-source control, self-hosting, and low cost score highest, pick Langfuse.
  • If LangChain native DX, datasets, and team collaboration matter most, pick LangSmith.
  • If simulation, ops alerts, and governance lead the list, pick Maxim.

For deeper comparisons, check these neutral-style pages from Maxim that map features and fit:

A Rollout Plan You Can Ship in 30 Days

Week 1, make unknowns visible

  • Instrument traces across your top three user flows.
  • Build a seed dataset from production traces or recordings.
  • Define six to eight core metrics: Task success, groundedness, tool use success, escalation correctness, latency, and cost.

Week 2, build the first evaluation loop

  • Create your first eval suite. Use LLM as a judge for relevance and safety, plus a five to ten percent human sample.
  • Version prompts and run side-by-side output comparisons before rollout.
  • Turn on three alerts: Error spikes, latency over SLO, and tool failure rate.

Week 3, simulate real work

  • Simulate a full multi-step workflow with tools and RAG, including flaky APIs and long contexts.
  • Fix the top two failure modes. Validate fixes against the eval suite and a fresh dataset.

Week 4, lock in quality gates

  • Wire CI to run evals on pull requests that touch prompts, tools, or retrieval.
  • Publish a weekly quality note: Wins, regressions, rollbacks, and cost trends.
  • Plan the next quarter: Expand datasets, add domain-specific metrics, and start red team tests.

You can run this entire plan inside Maxim. If you choose Langfuse or LangSmith, pair them with your CI and incident tooling for alerts and governance.

Where Each Tool Shines

Best for open source and control: Langfuse

You want to self-host, tweak the stack, and avoid vendor lock-in. Your team can extend evaluators and wire governance.

Best for LangChain-heavy teams: LangSmith

Your core pipelines run on LangChain or LangGraph. You want dataset-based evals, prompt collaboration, dashboards, and a path to enterprise self-hosting.

Best for enterprise-grade agent systems: Maxim

You need multi-turn simulations, endpoint testing, mixed evals, real-time alerts, and enterprise controls in one place. You prefer one workflow from design to production.

Case Patterns from Real Teams

These public case studies show how teams operationalize evaluation and observability.

If You Want the Long Version

For a deeper, in-one-place comparison of evaluation and observability platforms, including Langfuse and LangSmith, read this piece that breaks down simulation, observability, governance, and pricing patterns.

The Pragmatic Call

  • Starting from scratch with a strong platform team and strict budgets: Go Langfuse.
  • Deep inside LangChain with lots of prompt and pipeline iteration: Go LangSmith.
  • Owning SLAs, audits, and agent roadmaps that need to work every time: Go Maxim.

If you want to see a full evaluation and observability workflow end-to-end, get a live walkthrough and copy the 30-day plan.

Top comments (0)