Doubt gets treated as a failure of faith, and the framing is both unkind and unscriptural. People who doubt are usually the ones taking the question seriously. The alternative, which is to simply not think about it, is easier to live with and is not what the biblical writers do anywhere in the psalms.
Scripture records doubt constantly and without embarrassment. Job argues. The psalm writers ask where God is. Thomas will not believe until he sees. These are not exceptions to the rule of faith, they are part of its literature, and a reading tradition that treats them as embarrassing has quietly removed the most honest material in the book.
The argument is usually against the doubt, not the faith
The more useful distinction is between doubt about God and doubt of yourself, because they need different answers. Doubt of yourself is usually the result of having counted your own evidence honestly, and it does not get resolved by finding a stronger argument. Doubt about God is a different kind of question and it usually gets answered by something that happened rather than by something that was proved.
The practical advice in most churches, which is to read more, works because reading gives you more of the case rather than less. It does not require you to suppress the question, and a person who has been told to suppress it will usually end up not reading either.
If you are in this, this set of Bible verses for when you feel doubtful is gathered from the passages that argue rather than the ones that reassure, which is deliberate. The one to start with is usually the one that sounds most like your own objection.
Top comments (0)