DEV Community

BeFisc
BeFisc

Posted on

Circular Trading: How Lenders Detect Round-Tripped Turnover in Bank Statements and GST Data


Circular trading is the practice of moving money or invoices in a loop between related or controlled entities so that turnover looks larger than real economic activity. In GST, it creates fake input tax credit; in bank statements, it inflates credits that lenders use to size loans. Both leave traceable patterns.

A borrower shows Rs 4 crore of annual credits in a current account. The GST returns roughly agree. The bureau file is clean. On paper, this is a comfortable MSME working capital case.

Then an analyst notices that six counterparties supply most inflows, three share a registered address, and money arriving on Monday leaves for the same names by Thursday. The money is real; the business is not.

This guide covers how circular trading works in GST and bank statements, what enforcement data shows, and the tests credit teams can run before round-tripped turnover becomes a sanctioned limit.

What circular trading means in Indian lending

Circular trading is a closed loop of transactions in which value leaves an entity and returns to it, directly or through intermediaries, without a matching movement of goods or services.

Tax authorities use the term for invoice chains among shell firms that generate input tax credit without supply. Lenders use it for fund flows between related accounts that manufacture credit turnover or balances.

The two often appear together: a business inflating GST turnover with circular invoices needs matching bank credits, because lenders reconcile the two. That dependency makes the scheme detectable.

Circular trading in GST: fake ITC rings and what enforcement shows

In a typical fake ITC ring, GSTINs registered with borrowed or forged identity documents invoice each other and a beneficiary. No goods move; the beneficiary claims credit.

What the enforcement numbers say

Government Disclosures Highlight the Scale of Fake GST Registrations

Government disclosures provide an indication of the scale of fake GST registrations and suspected Input Tax Credit (ITC) evasion in India:

  • Lok Sabha Reply – 5 February 2024: In a written reply to the Lok Sabha, the Ministry of Finance stated that a special drive against fake registrations, which began in mid-May 2023, had detected 29,273 bogus firms involved in suspected ITC evasion worth Rs 44,015 crore. The operation also resulted in 121 arrests.
  • Second Special Drive – 24 September 2024: According to a report by Press Trust of India (PTI), the second drive conducted in 2024 had detected approximately 10,700 bogus firms involved in tax evasion exceeding Rs 10,000 crore.
  • Lok Sabha Reply – 15 December 2025: In a parliamentary reply reported on this date, the government stated that fake registrations created using forged PAN or Aadhaar numbers included:
    • 2023–24: 5,699 cases involving Rs 15,085 crore.
    • 2024–25: 3,977 cases involving Rs 13,109 crore.

How the Government Is Addressing Fake GST Registrations

The government's response has focused on strengthening verification and identifying suspicious tax activity through measures such as:

  • Aadhaar Authentication: Verifying the identity of applicants during GST registration.
  • Physical Verification: Conducting on-ground checks to confirm business addresses and operations.
  • Return-Mismatch Alerts: Identifying discrepancies between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B filings.
  • ITC Mismatch Detection: Comparing GSTR-2B data with the Input Tax Credit claimed by businesses.

What This Means for Lenders: A borrower's GST data may appear internally consistent while its counterparties are connected to a fraudulent business network or tax evasion ring. Therefore, lenders should look beyond individual GST records and assess the wider business ecosystem, including supplier and customer relationships.

Circular trading in bank statements: round-tripping to inflate turnover

Round-tripping in a bank statement means money leaves the borrower’s account and comes back, usually through one or more related accounts, so that it is counted as fresh business credit.

Credit turnover, average balance, and transaction counts, the inputs lenders use to size limits, can all be inflated by cycling the same funds.

Common mechanics

Common Patterns of Circular Trading and Fund Round-Tripping

  • Sister-Concern Loops: Funds move from the borrower to a group company and then return a few days later as "sales receipts," creating the appearance of genuine business revenue.
  • Director or Family Accounts: Promoters transfer personal savings or borrowed money into and out of business accounts to artificially increase account balances around month-end.
  • Multi-Hop Chains: Money passes through two or three intermediary accounts so that no single counterparty appears as both the payer and the payee.
  • Cheque and RTGS Swaps: Two associated businesses exchange cheques or bank transfers of similar values on the same day, creating the appearance of independent financial activity.

Why Round-Tripping Is Different from a Forged Bank Statement

Round-tripping differs from a forged bank statement because the transactions actually take place. The money genuinely moves between accounts, but the underlying economic purpose or meaning of those transactions is misleading.

As a result, basic document verification may not identify the problem. The bank statement can be genuine, and the transactions can be accurately recorded. This is why behavioural analysis and transaction-pattern monitoring are essential for identifying suspicious financial activity.

Why it matters under RBI’s fraud framework

RBI’s Master Directions on Fraud Risk Management (July 2024) require regulated entities to run an early warning signals framework. As summarised by Economic Laws Practice, the indicative EWS list includes “substantial related party transactions”, “large number of transactions with interconnected companies” and “high-value RTGS payment to unrelated parties”. Circular flows tend to trigger several of these at once.

How lenders detect circular trading in bank statements

How to Detect Circular Trading Through Bank Statement Analysis

No single ratio proves circularity. Detection works by combining multiple financial signals:

  1. Normalise Counterparties: Clean transaction narrations into consistent names across NEFT, RTGS, IMPS, UPI, and cheque transactions. Otherwise, counterparty concentration may be understated.
  2. Measure Concentration: Calculate the share of credits received from the top 5 and top 10 payers, along with the share of debits made to the top 5 payees.
  3. Find Bidirectional Counterparties: Identify names that appear as both payer and payee, and calculate the transaction value in each direction.
  4. Match Credit-Debit Pairs: Look for credits followed within a few days by similar-value debits to the same or a linked counterparty.
  5. Check Cut-Off Timing: Compare balances and inflows during the last five days of each month with activity during the rest of the month.
  6. Compare Inflow Quality with Declared Business: A distributor should typically receive payments from multiple buyers in varied amounts. A circular transaction pattern may show a few payers making payments in round or repeating amounts.
  7. Reconcile with GST: Compare bank credits with GSTR-1 outward supplies and GSTR-3B turnover for the same months.

Illustrative Review Thresholds: A credit policy might use the following thresholds as triggers for further investigation, rather than treating them as definitive rules:

  • Top-five payer share above 60% of total credits.
  • More than 20% of credit value coming from bidirectional counterparties.
  • Repeated same-amount inflow and outflow pairs within seven days.

Signal Reference Table

Signal What It Looks Like Innocent Explanation to Rule Out
High Counterparty Concentration A handful of payers account for most credits. A genuine anchor-customer model, such as a vendor supplying one OEM.
Bidirectional Counterparty The same entity sends and receives payments. Legitimate trade with a supplier who is also a customer.
Credit-Debit Pairs Similar amounts move in and out within a few days. Pass-through collections received on behalf of a principal.
Month-End Balance Spikes Balances rise sharply before the statement cut-off. Seasonal business receipts.
Round and Repeating Amounts Rs 5,00,000 credits arrive every week from the same name. Fixed-value contracts or rental payments.
Bank-GST Mismatch Bank credits are significantly higher or lower than declared turnover. Advance receipts, exempt supplies, or loans received.

Cross-Checking with GST and Related-Party Data

Bank statements show money movements, GST returns show invoices, and corporate records reveal business relationships. Circular trading rarely remains undetected when all three views are examined together.

Related-Party Matching

Lenders can map major counterparties against the following records:

  • Directors and shareholders of the borrower and its group companies using MCA records.
  • GSTINs registered against the same PAN, business address, or authorised signatory.
  • Udyam registrations operating from the same address as the borrower.

When a top-five payer turns out to share a director with the borrower, the apparent customer is actually a related party. Its credits should be carefully reviewed and may need to be excluded or discounted in eligibility calculations.

GST Status of Counterparties

Checking the GST status of major counterparties adds another layer of verification. Cancelled or suspended registrations, very recent registration dates, and gaps in return filing can be warning signs of entities potentially created for invoice rings.

Linking to Transaction Laundering

When incoming funds are unrelated to the borrower's declared business activity, the pattern may overlap with transaction laundering. This makes it important to examine the source, purpose, and movement of funds rather than relying only on reported turnover.

Use Cases: Two Illustrative Patterns

The following scenarios are illustrative and do not describe specific borrowers.

1. The Sister-Concern Carousel

A trading firm applies for a Rs 50 lakh credit limit. Forty percent of its credits come from two firms that share a director with the borrower. Each credit is followed within four days by a debit to the same firms.

After excluding these related-party transactions, the firm's eligible turnover falls by more than one-third.

2. The Month-End Lift

A services firm's bank balance increases sharply between the 27th and 30th of each month. The increase is funded by transfers from a promoter's savings account, and the balance falls again by the 2nd of the following month.

Analysing full-month daily balances instead of relying on the closing balance helps identify this temporary inflation.

Where BeFiSc Fits

Finnalyzer by BeFiSc analyses bank statements across 100+ formats and converts raw transaction entries into structured financial data. Credit teams can use these insights for counterparty reviews, balance analysis, and turnover assessment.

Start with a free Finnalyzer trial using your own sample bank statements.

Key Takeaways

  • Circular trading moves money in a loop between related entities to create artificial turnover in GST records, bank statements, or both.
  • Government disclosures show that tens of thousands of bogus GST firms have been detected since 2023, highlighting why counterparty legitimacy should never be assumed.
  • Round-tripped bank credits can pass document checks because the transactions are genuine. Detection depends on analysing transaction behaviour rather than relying only on forgery tests.
  • The strongest warning signals include counterparty concentration, bidirectional counterparties, matched credit-debit pairs, and month-end balance spikes.
  • Related-party matching using MCA, GST, and Udyam data helps lenders turn suspicious transaction patterns into informed underwriting decisions.

Conclusion

Circular trading is hard to see one document at a time and much easier when bank flows, GST filings and corporate relationships are read together. The enforcement record since 2023 shows how many entities exist to manufacture paper trade, and lenders inherit that problem whenever they size a turnover limit.

The practical answer is a layered review: normalise counterparties, measure concentration and loops, then confirm relationships and GST standing for the names that matter. Teams that make this routine catch inflated turnover at sanctions rather than at the first missed EMI.

Top comments (0)