DEV Community


Discussion on: Why I can't recommend Clean Architecture by Robert C Martin

d4e666 profile image

I locker at the source code, i ready clean code, i crawled the entire cleancoder website and even read clean architecture and what frustrates me the most is that he keeps babbling about how clean code should Express intent, just to find out that his own code does everything but that, than in my opinion he does not have a right to judge us. I'm trying to create a framework in .net based on the items he talks about, in the sense that he intends them(which is completely correct btw) and my implementation looks very different from his. Just to make things clear I chopped my code into separate assemblies instead of separate name spaces, and when I were to do that, just like java revs do, then my implementation would still be more expressive than his. So this rather disappoints me. I truly believe that his vision is correct, just not the way he presents it as being the holy grail. As soon as I am satisfied with the result, I'll place it in a gift repo for others to judge.

bosepchuk profile image
Blaine Osepchuk Author

Please post your code when it is ready. If be interested to see what you come up with.