True, and he also forgot to mention the dependency of SDK, .env isn't bad, if steps are taken to secure it, and infact there's no way people are going to directly update the code or version the .env, they are going use it for local development, and rather build validation in code to check for environment variables and add up new vars progressively, Secret Managers are special purpose services, they add up complexity for small systems, but solve the problem of scattered and untracked env for large systems, obviously with overhead of using client sdks. Still if you still wish use some secret store for even local dev, use Doppler.
A software engineer that specializes in serverless microservices. I love creating helpful content about programming and reverse-engineering.
I am employed at Google; all opinions are my own.
not commiting it to version control is the right thing to do, but using it as source of truth for your variables is simplest thing to do, if one needs unified way of injecting secrets, from various sources there are tool out there like tlr.dev/ which can source secrets from AWS, Vault, etc. all in one place without even using any SDK. That totally depends on choice of the devs.
For further actions, you may consider blocking this person and/or reporting abuse
We're a place where coders share, stay up-to-date and grow their careers.
True, and he also forgot to mention the dependency of SDK, .env isn't bad, if steps are taken to secure it, and infact there's no way people are going to directly update the code or version the .env, they are going use it for local development, and rather build validation in code to check for environment variables and add up new vars progressively, Secret Managers are special purpose services, they add up complexity for small systems, but solve the problem of scattered and untracked env for large systems, obviously with overhead of using client sdks. Still if you still wish use some secret store for even local dev, use Doppler.
Depending on which service you use, you could slide by without an SDK.
I've never heard of a
.env
used for build validation, can you give an example.Then why do the people who made dotenv explicitly tell you to NOT commit .env to version control? github.com/motdotla/dotenv#should-...
People never stop to disappoint me with their clinging to bad practices.
not commiting it to version control is the right thing to do, but using it as source of truth for your variables is simplest thing to do, if one needs unified way of injecting secrets, from various sources there are tool out there like tlr.dev/ which can source secrets from AWS, Vault, etc. all in one place without even using any SDK. That totally depends on choice of the devs.