DEV Community

FileFreight
FileFreight

Posted on

Selling printable Underwater Cities final-scoring logs as downloads: the log your buyer trusts when a bare city still scores

A printable Underwater Cities log lives or dies on the one record nobody keeps: what each player's final scoring actually added, and in what order, because the game does not end with a single pile of points but with four lines scored in order, the final-scoring metropolis first, then end-scoring cards, then the network, then leftover resources, and the order is where the game is won or lost. Nobody at the table argues about the game they played; they argue about whether a metropolis connected by one tunnel paid anything, whether an unconnected city scored, whether card buys happened before the resource conversion, and whether biomatter sold for one credit or two. The only evidence is the log: a line for each of the four scores, with the network broken out city by city and the resource pool written out before it is divided, or a single final total that was written at the end and can be defended by nobody.

The metropolis is the first trap, because it pays only when it is fully connected. The metropolis in the upper left corner of your board gives its points only if you have connected it to your network with both tunnels, so a metropolis reached by a single tunnel pays nothing, however impressive the network behind it looks. Score a half-connected metropolis at full value and a player gains points they never earned, quietly, with no line on the sheet showing where they came from. A log that writes the metropolis line as tunnels connected, one or two, with the tile's points beside it, makes the line checkable; a bare metropolis total does not, because the total alone cannot tell you whether the second tunnel was ever built.

The network is the second trap, because a connected city scores even with nothing on it, and an unconnected city scores nothing at all. Every city connected to your network is worth points by the number of different building types beside it: two points with no buildings, three with one type, four with two types, and six with all three types, and only cities in your network count, because a city that is not connected has no people in it yet. Score every city on the board, connected or not, and the player with the biggest unbuilt sprawl gains points for empty domes. Score a bare connected city at zero and the player who connected it loses points they earned. A log that lists each city on its own line, connected or not, with its building types and its two, three, four, or six beside it, keeps the network visible; a log that writes a single network total hides whether an unconnected city slipped in or a bare city was zeroed out.

The card buys are the third trap, and they must happen before the resource conversion, because buying points through a card is always more efficient than converting the same resources afterwards. End-scoring cards can give points for what you built, or let you spend resources to buy points, and those buys are scored on the end-scoring line, before the network and before leftover resources are converted at four resources to one point. Spend the card-buy resources in the conversion first and the points they would have bought are gone, converted at a quarter of their value or worse. A log that writes the end-scoring line before the resource line, with each card buy and its cost beside it, stops the order from drifting; a log that totals resources first invites the error, because nothing on the sheet says the cards were ever scored.

Leftover resources are the fourth trap, because biomatter doubles before the division and leftovers are ignored after it. First sell all your biomatter for two credits each, then buy one point for every four credits, kelp, science, or steelplast you spend, in any combination, and leftover resources do not count. Sell biomatter at one credit each and the pool shrinks; count leftovers as points and the pool grows; either way the final line is wrong by a point or more, which is often the game. A log that writes the pool as credits plus kelp plus science plus steelplast plus twice the biomatter, with the division and the remainder beside it, makes the conversion checkable; a bare resource total does not, because the total alone cannot tell you whether the biomatter doubled or the remainder was dropped.

Take a game that ends with A trailing on the track and winning on the final lines: A sits on thirty track points and B on thirty-four. A scores eight from a fully connected metropolis, eleven from end-scoring cards, twenty-one from the network, two cities with all three types for twelve, one city with two types for four, one city with one type for three, and one bare connected city for two, and six from resources, a pool of twenty-six, sixteen credits plus one kelp plus one science plus two steelplast plus three biomatter at two credits each, divided by four with two left over, for a final-scoring total of forty-six and a game total of seventy-six. B scores nothing from a metropolis connected by only one tunnel, seven from end-scoring cards, twenty-seven from the network, three cities with all three types for eighteen, one city with two types for four, one city with one type for three, and one bare connected city for two, and six from resources, a pool of twenty-six, ten credits plus five kelp plus three science plus two steelplast plus three biomatter at two credits each, divided by four with two left over, for a final-scoring total of forty and a game total of seventy-four. A wins by two. Count B's half-connected metropolis at eight and B rises to eighty-two against A's seventy-six, a false B win by six. Count B's unconnected city with two building types at four and B rises to seventy-eight against A's seventy-six, a false B win by two. Score A's card buys after the resource conversion, so the ten resources spent on eleven card points convert at four to one instead, for two points, and A falls to sixty-seven against B's seventy-four, a false B win by seven. Four different single-line errors, three different wrong results, and only the line-by-line log shows which one happened.

An Underwater Cities final-scoring log that a buyer prints, fills in, and trusts is not a sheet of blank lines but a checklist of the scoring card in order: the metropolis line, tunnels connected and points, then the end-scoring cards with each buy and its cost, then the network city by city at two, three, four, or six, connected cities only, then the resource pool, biomatter at two credits each, divided by four with the remainder written and ignored, and then the tiebreak line, Federation track position at the end of the final round, written before any winner is declared. That is the download worth selling: not the arithmetic, which any player can do, but the structure that stops the arithmetic from drifting, one line at a time, until the winner changes.

Disclaimer: This log is a player aid for Underwater Cities and is not affiliated with Delicious Games or Vladimír Suchý. Final scoring uses the official scoring order; check the rulebook for your edition before play.

Top comments (0)