DEV Community

Fundacja Dobre Państwo
Fundacja Dobre Państwo

Posted on Originally published at dobrepanstwo.org

Indicator Architecture vs. Value: Measurement Traps

The article analyzes the issue of flawed indicators in scientific activity, pointing out that bibliometric measures often fail to reflect the actual value of research. The author references the San Francisco Declaration and the Leiden Manifesto to emphasize the necessity of combining quantitative analysis with expert assessment and protecting interdisciplinary and replication projects. The text warns against the phenomenon of reward hacking, where researchers adapt their work to meet the requirements of scoring systems rather than striving for the advancement of knowledge. This is complemented by a perspective from organizational theory and institutional isomorphism, explaining why institutions adopt superficial reporting systems to gain legitimacy, leading to the primacy of measurable outputs over actual scientific impact.

Top comments (0)