Comparing supplement prices should be simple. Two bottles, two prices, pick the cheaper one. In practice, it is one of the hardest calculations in the supplement aisle — because almost no two brands use the same serving size. One brand's serving is one capsule; another's is two; a third's is three. One bottle holds thirty servings; another holds fifteen. The price on the shelf tells you almost nothing until you have done the arithmetic, and the brands know it.
The first step is to find the price per serving. Divide the price of the bottle by the number of servings it contains — not the number of capsules, but the number of servings, which is the capsule count divided by the serving size. A bottle that costs 30 and contains 60 capsules at two capsules per serving costs 1 per serving. A bottle that costs 20 and contains 30 capsules at one capsule per serving costs about 0.67 per serving. The second bottle is cheaper, even though the first looks like better value on the shelf. This single calculation, done for every product you consider, will save you more money than any discount.
The second step is to compare the dose per serving, not just the price per serving. A cheap product that delivers half the dose of an expensive one is not cheaper — it is half a product at half the price. To compare fairly, divide the price per serving by the dose of the main ingredient, and compare the cost per milligram. Two products with the same headline dose can have very different costs per milligram once you account for serving sizes, and the difference is often large. The Supplement Rating covers this calculation in its label-checking guide, and it is the single most useful piece of arithmetic a supplement buyer can learn.
The third step is to check what counts as a serving in the first place. Some brands define a serving generously — three capsules, a heaped scoop, a full dropper — so that the dose per serving looks impressive and the price per serving looks low. Others define a serving as a single capsule, which makes the dose look small but the price look honest. Neither is wrong, but they cannot be compared directly. Always convert to the same basis: the cost of one day's dose, at the dose you actually intend to take, for each product. That is the only fair comparison.
The fourth step is to watch for the serving-size trick in reverse. A brand can make its product look cheap per serving by defining a serving as a tiny amount — a quarter scoop, half a capsule's worth of powder — that no reasonable person would take as a daily dose. The price per serving looks excellent. The price per effective day's dose is a different story. If the serving size on the label is smaller than the dose used in the research the brand cites, the product is being sold at a dose that its own evidence does not support. A tea-based weight-loss review shows how to check whether the serving size on the label matches the dose in the evidence.
The fifth step is to include the hidden costs. Shipping, subscriptions, and the cost of the products you buy to replace the ones that did not work all count. A product that costs more per serving but works reliably can be cheaper, over a year, than a product that costs less per serving but is abandoned after a month. Price is not just the number on the bottle. It is the total cost of the routine, over time, for a product you actually take.
Comparing supplement prices is arithmetic, not instinct. Price per serving, dose per serving, cost per milligram, and the total cost of the routine — four numbers, and the cheapest product on the shelf is rarely the cheapest of the four. Do the sums, and the bargains will find themselves.
Top comments (0)