DEV Community

Cover image for HeadshotPro review: a solid tool, but PFPMaker is the better buy
Illeana Vowies
Illeana Vowies

Posted on

HeadshotPro review: a solid tool, but PFPMaker is the better buy

HeadshotPro is a solid AI headshot service, and its $39 Professional plan is the only individual tier I'd pay for. For one person who just needs a good profile photo, though, PFPMaker is my top pick. It starts from a single photo and opens 50+ styles on every plan, at a few dollars adjusted to your country.

That's the short version of this HeadshotPro review. The longer version is mostly arithmetic, plus one admission HeadshotPro makes about its own output that changes how you should read every price on its page.

Three tiers, and the cheap one is the slow one

All three individual plans are one-time purchases with no subscription, and each comes with one free redo within 60 days. Here's the spec sheet as HeadshotPro publishes it:

Plan Price Headshots Turnaround Edit credits Extras
Basic $29 30 about 2 hours 6 none
Professional $39 50 about 30 minutes 26 none
Executive $59 70 about 15 minutes 46 4K downloads, portrait and landscape formats

What I kept coming back to on the pricing page is where the speed lives. The 15-minute turnaround and the 4K downloads don't appear anywhere below the $59 tier. Pay $29 and you wait roughly two hours for 30 shots with 6 edit credits, while $10 more buys 20 extra headshots, more than four times the edit credits and a wait about a quarter as long.

So Basic is basically there to make Professional look good.

Executive's harder to dismiss. Still, 4K is an odd thing to pay up for when the photo usually ends up as a GitHub avatar or a LinkedIn circle a few hundred pixels across.

Cost per photo, then cost per photo you keep

Here are the numbers in a form you can rerun (price divided by images delivered, nothing clever):

# one-time individual plans, USD: (price, images delivered)
plans = {
    "PFPMaker Pro (displayed price, varies by country)": (7, 60),
    "HeadshotPro Basic": (29, 30),
    "HeadshotPro Professional": (39, 50),
    "HeadshotPro Executive": (59, 70),
}
for name, (price, n) in plans.items():
    print(f"{name}: ${price / n:.2f} per image")

# PFPMaker Pro (displayed price, varies by country): $0.12 per image
# HeadshotPro Basic: $0.97 per image
# HeadshotPro Professional: $0.78 per image
# HeadshotPro Executive: $0.84 per image
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

On delivered images alone, HeadshotPro Professional costs about six and a half times as much per image as PFPMaker Pro. PFPMaker adjusts its prices by country, so treat the $7 as illustrative rather than a universal sticker.

Those figures flatter everyone, though, because they count every image a model produces. HeadshotPro's own refund page is unusually frank about this. It warns that you'll get some "wacky" photos and that most photos in an order won't be keepers (credit to them for putting that in writing, most vendors would rather you found out on your own). Keep ten of the 50 images in a Professional order and you've paid $3.90 for each photo you'd actually use. PFPMaker's FAQ says most of its customers find 60 to 80% of a batch great. That's a vendor's number and I'd discount it the way I discount any vendor's number, but even if you halve it the gap per usable image stays enormous, and a 60-image batch gives you a lot more chances at the one shot you need.

To be fair, HeadshotPro's refund terms are generous. You get 30 days, a complete refund with no conditions and a self-serve page that clears most requests within one business day. PFPMaker's guarantee is narrower: you email within 7 days of receiving your photos, and it pays out if you didn't get at least one usable photo. At a few dollars a batch I doubt the shorter window matters much to anyone, but it's a real difference.

One photo is enough to start

PFPMaker starts from one photo. Two to ten from different angles gives the model more to work with, sure, but you don't need a curated folder of well-lit selfies before anything happens, and it reads HEIC straight off an iPhone.

The style range is the part I'd underrated. Every plan opens the full 50+ styles, so the same order can return a clean corporate headshot, a full-body portrait and something looser for a personal site or a Discord server. Plenty of developers want both kinds of photo, and it's irritating to pay two vendors for them. Commercial rights come with every PFPMaker order too, with no attribution needed, which is handy if the photo lands on a company site or a conference page. The HeadshotPro alternative page sets both price ladders next to each other with the date they were checked, if you want the raw comparison.

headshotpro review

Where HeadshotPro has the stronger setup

Teams are a different story, and pretending otherwise would be silly. HeadshotPro sells team credits from $19.50 per person at volume. Each credit is one person's shoot of 40 headshots plus a retry, and the discounts start at 20% off at five credits and climb to 50% at 1,000 or more. Around that sits an admin dashboard, a REST API rate-limited at 300 requests per minute, a SOC 2 Type II report and SSO as a paid add-on.

PFPMaker doesn't have that admin layer yet. There's no dashboard, no SSO and no consolidated invoice, and the company says it's building them. For an IT department that wants SSO before anyone uploads a selfie, that's a blocker today, and no per-photo saving changes it.

On reputation, HeadshotPro shows 4.7 on Trustpilot from 3,638 reviews, while PFPMaker's own site shows 4.9 from 7,623+ reviews. Different places entirely. I wouldn't stack one against the other.

My pick for one person is PFPMaker

For an individual profile photo it's PFPMaker, and honestly it isn't close. The Pro plan returns 60 photos in about ten minutes at a displayed $7, with every style open on every plan. HeadshotPro Professional is a decent product at $39, kind of the sensible middle of its own ladder, but on price per image and entry-level speed PFPMaker comes out ahead by a wide margin.

HeadshotPro's download links for the photos you keep expire after 7 days, and the uploads and generated results are deleted automatically at 30.

Top comments (0)