DEV Community

MetaDuro
MetaDuro

Posted on Originally published at metaduro.com AI-assisted

Buy-and-Hold vs. a 50-Day Moving Average Rule on Bitcoin (2014-2026)

This test compares a simple timing rule with buy and hold on BTC/USD daily data from Coinbase: 4,314 daily bars, from 1 December 2014 to 26 October 2026. The question is whether filtering market exposure through a 50-day simple moving average changes the return path and the downside, compared with staying invested the whole time.

The rule is mechanical. Go long when the daily close crosses above the 50-day SMA; exit when it crosses below. Signals are read on completed daily closes, and exposure starts from the next interval, so the cross day's own move is never part of the trade. A crossover is an event; being above the average is a state. That distinction decides when trades actually happen.

Verified results

Metric Rule Buy and hold
Trades 104 closed trades -
Total return +93,483.8% +21,481.4%
CAGR 77.7% 57.1%
$10,000 becomes $9.36M $2.16M
Win rate 29.8% (31 of 104 trades) -
Average win / loss +47.8% / -3.5% -
Profit factor 5.79 -
Median trade 5 days; in market 56.7% of days -
Best / worst trade +414.7% / -12.1% -
Max drawdown -49.6% at trade exits; -57.6% daily -83.8%

The rule wins rarely but big: 73 of 104 trades lose money, and the edge comes from riding a few long trends rather than calling the market often.

Costs and limitations

Zero fees assumed. The published model assumes no fees and no slippage, with about 8.7 trades per year. Costs change the picture: at 0.1% per side the final return drops by 18.8%, and at 0.5% per side by 64.8%. These cost scenarios are illustrative; actual results depend on fees, slippage and execution.

This is one asset, one period, and one rule. Sideways markets produce repeated crossovers and small losses. Historical results are not a forecast or a guarantee. This research is for information only, not investment advice.

All figures were reproduced independently from the raw daily data before writing; the reproduced equity curve matches the published model's 104 trades point for point. The original page's summary panel shows a slightly different CAGR (79.9%) that could not be reconciled, so the re-run figures are used here. The Sharpe figure shown on the site was not independently verified and is not reported here.

The model and its full equity curve are public on MetaDuro, a market-research platform for seasonality statistics and rule backtests.

Figures independently re-run 27 Oct on 4,314 Coinbase BTC/USD daily bars (1 Dec 2014 - 26 Oct 2026).

Top comments (0)