DEV Community

Mirage Cloud IA
Mirage Cloud IA

Posted on

Online Customer Reviews: What French and EU Rules Allow

Customer reviews are among the most persuasive things a small business can show, and also among the most regulated. The rules are mostly common sense, but the penalties are not small, and several common habits, from writing a few reviews yourself to inviting only happy customers, sit closer to the line than owners realise.

What is banned outright

Since the EU Omnibus directive was transposed in France, with effect from 28 May 2022, two practices count as misleading in all circumstances. The first is publishing or commissioning fake reviews or endorsements, or distorting genuine ones, in order to promote products. The second is stating that reviews come from consumers who actually bought or used the product without taking reasonable and proportionate steps to check that they did. Misleading commercial practices carry up to two years in prison and a fine of 300,000 euros for an individual, with higher maximums for companies.

What sites that publish reviews must disclose

Article L111-7-2 of the Consumer Code applies to anyone whose activity, even as a side activity, consists of collecting, moderating or publishing consumer reviews online. They must give users clear information on how reviews are published and processed. Under the implementing decree, in force since 2018, that information covers, among other things, whether reviews are checked and how, whether any reward was given in exchange for a review, how reviews are ranked and why a review can be rejected. The law was written to stop fake reviews, altered publication dates and the delaying of negative reviews. If you display customer reviews on your own site, you are in that category, so say plainly how you collect and show them.

Collecting reviews safely
➠ Invite every customer, not only the satisfied ones. Choosing whom to ask so that bad experiences never reach the page distorts the picture, and it is the kind of practice that attracts scrutiny.
➠ Do not write your own reviews, ask staff or family to post them, or pay for positive ones.
➠ If you thank reviewers with a reward, say so next to the reviews, and never make the reward depend on a positive rating.
➠ Do not edit a review, change its date or sit on a negative one.
➠ Use a platform that checks that the reviewer is a customer, or say that reviews are not verified.

Showing reviews
➠ Quote reviews accurately, in full or with a link to the original. Cutting a sentence so that it says the opposite is distortion.
➠ Show a rating or score only if you can show where it comes from, with a working link to the profile it refers to. A score nobody can trace is a claim you cannot support.
➠ Show dates, and do not present old reviews as current.
➠ Keep exports or screenshots of the source for any score you display.

Replying to reviews
➠ Reply to positive and negative reviews alike, calmly, specifically and soon.
➠ Do not reveal personal details about the customer in a public reply. Mentioning the order, a health detail or an address can breach data protection rules.
➠ Do not pressure reviewers to delete. Ask the platform to remove a review only when it breaks the platform's rules, for instance because it is fake or off-topic.
➠ Offer to continue privately after one public reply.
➠ Use the reply to say what you changed, which readers value more than an apology.

The data protection side

Reviews and reviewers' names are personal data. Tell customers when you invite them to review, keep review request lists only as long as you need them and make sure that a reply does not disclose more than the reviewer did. Tools that send review requests on your behalf are processors, so you need a data processing agreement with them.

Where AI helps

Drafting replies is a good use of an assistant, because it removes the blank page. Generating the reviews themselves is the opposite: fake testimonials, AI-written or not, fall under the ban above, and so does rewriting real ones. Mirage Cloud includes a customer relations agent that can draft replies for you to edit. Edit them until they mention the actual order or issue, because generic replies read as generated and do more harm than silence.

Top comments (0)