I keep two official hero trays open in the same browser maker, and the mistake I keep catching is not a wrong portrait. It is the assumption that an S-through-D row is a neutral container. It is not. One of these games ranks a fixed role contract. The other ranks a lane-and-item economy, aimed at a single objective, in a game that is still forthcoming. If I drag both pools onto one board, the row labels stay readable and the decision becomes mush.
The first game is a team shooter whose standard player-versus-player mode is built around a hard composition. Official Overwatch news on the coming PvP changes is explicit: standard PvP shifted to teams of five, and each team contains one Tank, two Damage, and two Support (First look at the player-versus-player changes coming to Overwatch 2). That is not flavor text. It is a contract. When I queue, I am not asking who is the strongest hero in a vacuum. I am asking who I trust in one of five slots, under one role, against a matching 1/2/2 on the other side. A Tank tile and a Support tile can both be "strong" and still be incomparable if I have not declared which slot the board is for. The S row does not store that declaration. I have to write it down myself.
I do that work in Tierlist, a free browser tier list maker. I start from a ready-made template or a blank board, drag tiles into rows, and then share or download the result. I do not need an account to begin, and because the board stays editable I can keep a wide ranking and fork a narrower copy without rebuilding the pool. That is the part I actually use. I am not here to repeat homepage marketing counts.
The Overwatch template is useful because the unranked tray is already filled with official hero portraits. I open the Overwatch tier list and the first job is not to rebuild a roster from memory. It is to write the lens in one line before any tile moves: role-queue value for a Tank slot tonight, or Damage value into a dive, or Support value when the other Support is already locked. The portraits arrive as a contact sheet. I treat them as a fixed item set. If I later want a different lens, I fork the board. I do not let a general S row quietly answer three different slot questions.
The second board looks similar and is not the same problem. Wikipedia describes Deadlock as an upcoming third-person shooter and MOBA: two teams of six, three lanes, with the goal of destroying the enemy Patron (Deadlock (video game)). I am not going to treat an encyclopedia page as a patch note, and I am not going to invent a roster size, a player count, or a release date on top of it. What the description does give me is a different ranking unit. A six-player, three-lane shooter-MOBA asks who impacts a lane, who spends an item economy well, and who still matters when the fight walks toward the Patron. Those questions can share an S row only if I have already said which one I am asking. They do not map onto "one Tank, two Damage, two Support." The team shape is different. The win condition is different. The scarce resource is not a single contracted slot in a 1/2/2 queue; it is influence across a lane map and an economy that has to close out an objective.
That is why I keep a separate Deadlock tier list. The official template tray already includes named cards — Abrams, Apollo, Bebop, Billy, Calico, Celeste, Drifter, Dynamo, Graves, Grey Talon, Haze, Holliday, Infernus, Ivy, Kelvin, Lady Geist, Lash, McGinnis, Mina, Mirage, Mo & Krill, Paige, Paradox, Pocket, among the first tiles on the page. I can mention those names because they are on the template. I cannot pretend I have a frozen meta for a game Wikipedia still calls upcoming. The honest move is to date the board, label the lens — lane impact, item timing, or "who I would actually try in this snapshot" — and leave the Overwatch contract on its own page.
It is tempting, when both trays are sitting in one maker, to build a single "hero shooter" mega-board and be done. I have tried a version of that, and it fails in a predictable way. The Overwatch Tank who holds the one-Tank contract is not answering the same question as the Deadlock hero who is being ranked for lane pressure toward a Patron. Both can sit in an S row. Only one of those S labels is telling the truth at a time. A display schema of S through D does not encode the rule that produced the team. Overwatch 2's standard mode hands you the 1/2/2 contract before the first round starts. Deadlock, at least in that public description, hands you six players, three lanes, and a Patron to destroy. If I merge those axes, I get a pretty image and a dishonest ranking.
The habit I want is small, and it is the whole point of keeping both templates in one place. Write the lens above the first row, or keep two boards. Do not let one S tile mean both "this Tank holds the role-queue contract" and "this hero wins a lane and spends the economy well." A role queue is a contract. A lane MOBA-shooter is an economy. One S–D board should not be asked to carry both.

Top comments (0)