DEV Community

Neural_Ethos
Neural_Ethos

Posted on

Two ensemble templates, two ranking problems: a shonen power debate vs a volleyball lineup

A pre-filled character template is not just a shortcut for making a pretty board. It is a closed item set with an implied question. I have been comparing two anime templates on Tierlist for that reason: both live under the same homepage index of ready-made boards, but they ask you to do different work once the tiles are on the table.

The first question is a power-scaling problem. Gege Akutami's Jujutsu Kaisen finished in Weekly Shonen Jump in 2024, and Anime News Network reported Shueisha's announcement that the manga had reached 100 million copies in circulation (including digital copies; ANN notes that Shueisha did not specify Japan versus worldwide). A finished, widely circulated series leaves behind a large, argumentative roster — sorcerers, curses, and villains — whose relative standing people already debate in terms of technique and feats. That is exactly the job the Jujutsu Kaisen tier list is built for. The template page itself frames the board as a place to drag the cast by raw strength, technique, and feats, and it even asks whether you want to rank by arc or include curses and villains. The item set is fixed; the axis is yours to declare.

Unranked official character tiles from the Jujutsu Kaisen template page

The second question is a lineup problem, not a "who would win" problem. The official Haikyu!! anime portal describes Haruichi Furudate's series as a long-running Weekly Shonen Jump volleyball story about high-school players and rival schools, later adapted for television and film (the official Haikyu!! anime site). A roster like that is organized by team and position as much as by popularity. The Haikyuu tier list starts from that ensemble — Hinata, Kageyama, Oikawa, Bokuto, and the rest of the league — and the template page itself offers two different axes: rank by position (setters against setters, aces against aces) or rank by character rather than on-court skill. Those are incompatible sorts, and pretending they are the same board is how arguments stall.

I treat the two templates as contrasting schemas. In the shonen power-scaling case, S through F are bands of comparable threat under one declared rule. In the volleyball case, a single total order across the whole league often hides more than it shows; a setter-only row structure, or a "growth versus current skill" split, is usually the better model. The useful habit is the same in both: name the axis before the first tile moves, and do not reuse one finished PNG as if it answered every question the roster can ask.

Top comments (0)