From Flaky Cypress Tests to a Maintainable Playwright Strategy
Changing the testing framework was only part of the solution. The bigger challenge was building automation we could actually trust.
When Rerunning Tests Becomes Normal
If you've worked with automated testing long enough, you've probably experienced this:
A test fails in CI.
You investigate, rerun it, and suddenly everything is green.
Problem solved, right? 😅
Unfortunately, not really.
During my journey into QA and test automation, I've learned that flaky tests are more than just an annoying technical problem. They slowly affect how much confidence developers and QA engineers have in their test results.
When failures become normal, people eventually stop taking them seriously.
And that's a dangerous place for a regression suite to be.
Why We Started Moving Away from Cypress
We had been working with Cypress for our end-to-end testing, but as our automation grew, we started looking at how we could improve reliability, maintainability, and the overall testing architecture.
Playwright became our choice for moving forward.
It offered useful capabilities such as automatic waiting, powerful locators, browser tracing, and cross-browser testing.
But one thing became clear:
Migrating from Cypress to Playwright wouldn't magically fix our testing problems.
We could easily recreate the same issues in a different framework if we continued writing and maintaining tests the same way.
The framework was only one part of the equation.
Building a Strategy, Not Just Migrating Tests
Instead of simply rewriting Cypress tests into Playwright, we wanted to rethink how our automation should work.
A few things became particularly important.
1. Make tests independent
Tests should not rely on another test having executed successfully beforehand.
Each test needs a predictable starting point, so failures are easier to reproduce and investigate.
2. Stop relying on arbitrary waits
Waiting three seconds and hoping an element is ready isn't exactly a reliable testing strategy.
We want tests that wait for meaningful conditions rather than guessing how long an application needs.
3. Establish shared conventions
As more engineers contribute to automated tests, consistency becomes increasingly important.
How should we structure tests? How should we handle test data? When should we use API setup, and when should a test remain entirely UI-driven?
Having clear conventions helps prevent every engineer from inventing a different approach.
4. Make failures easier to investigate
A failed test should provide useful information.
Screenshots, traces, logs, and clear assertions can help us understand whether we're dealing with a real application bug or a problem in the automation itself.
The Real Challenge Is Maintaining Trust
One lesson I've taken from this experience is that test automation isn't just about increasing coverage.
You can have hundreds of automated tests, but if developers don't trust the results, how valuable are they?
A reliable regression suite should help teams make decisions.
When something fails, we should investigate it rather than automatically press rerun.
And when everything passes, we should have confidence that the tests actually verified meaningful behavior.
Final Thoughts
Moving from Cypress to Playwright has been an important part of improving our test automation approach.
But the biggest lesson wasn't about choosing one framework over another.
It was about recognizing that good test automation requires more than good tools. It requires good engineering practices.
Playwright gives us useful capabilities, but architecture, consistency, and maintainability are what make an automation strategy sustainable.
And let's be realistic: a new testing framework won't save us from writing bad tests. 😅
I'm curious how other teams have approached this.
Have you migrated from Cypress to Playwright? Did it improve test reliability, or did you discover that the bigger challenges weren't related to the framework at all?
Top comments (0)