DEV Community

Soma Wellness
Soma Wellness

Posted on

The Old Injury Behind Your Painful Ankle: Why Ankle Arthritis Is Different

When people picture joint replacement, they usually think of hips and knees worn down by age. The ankle follows a different story. Dr. Sagar Desai, a Toronto orthopaedic surgeon who specializes in the foot and ankle, explains that most ankle arthritis is post-traumatic. In other words, it begins with an injury, often one the patient had nearly forgotten.

An injury from decades ago

Many patients are surprised to learn that a fracture or a run of bad sprains from 10, 20 or even 30 years earlier can surface as arthritis much later. At the time, the ankle may seem to heal well. But cartilage damaged during that original event can slowly break down until the bones begin rubbing against each other. Ligament injuries, repeated sprains and direct cartilage injuries are all common starting points. Less often, the cause is osteoarthritis without injury, an inflammatory condition such as rheumatoid arthritis, a past infection, or an unusual ankle shape or alignment.

How it shows up day to day

The first signs tend to be pain while walking, standing for a long time or climbing stairs. Stiffness becomes more obvious first thing in the morning or after sitting, and swelling builds as the day goes on. Some people notice grinding, clicking or catching. In advanced cases, the ankle can hurt even at rest. Hills, uneven trails and high-impact sports usually aggravate symptoms.

Getting the right pictures

Dr. Desai considers weight-bearing X-rays the most important test, because they show joint-space narrowing and bone spurs while the ankle carries load. A CT scan adds detail once surgery is on the table. MRI is rarely helpful for routine ankle arthritis; he will look at one if a patient already has it, but says it seldom changes the plan.

Lost cartilage does not grow back

Arthritis in the ankle is generally progressive, yet that does not mean steady decline or inevitable surgery. Many people enjoy long stable stretches with activity changes, weight management, stronger surrounding muscles, good footwear and bracing. Dr. Desai encourages patients who love running or demanding sports to keep going while pain is manageable, using treatment to extend that time. Low-impact choices such as cycling, swimming, rowing and the elliptical are excellent ways to stay fit.

The non-surgical toolkit

Before surgery, he recommends exhausting conservative options: activity modification, supportive shoes, custom orthotics, bracing, physiotherapy, anti-inflammatory medication and injections. Corticosteroid injections can give temporary relief. He also offers hyaluronic acid injections, noting that evidence in the ankle is limited but that he has seen some benefit. PRP may help too, though he does not perform it himself.

When replacement enters the conversation

Surgery becomes reasonable when pain interferes with work, exercise or everyday life despite good conservative care. At that point the two main options are fusion and total ankle replacement. A replacement removes the damaged surfaces and substitutes metal and polyethylene components, preserving much of the ankle's motion. Dr. Desai notes that good candidates usually have significant arthritic pain, reasonable bone quality, good alignment and realistic expectations, and that overall health and activity level matter more than age alone.

Questions to bring to an appointment

  • Could an old fracture or sprain explain my current symptoms?
  • Have my X-rays been taken standing?
  • Which conservative treatments have I not yet tried?
  • If surgery is needed, what makes me a better fit for fusion or replacement?

Seeing a surgeon does not have to mean booking an operation. Many consultations focus on confirming the cause, reviewing options and building a long-term plan for keeping the ankle working as well as possible.

About the author: This article was prepared from patient education material published by Dr. Sagar J. Desai, MD, MSc, FRCSC, a foot and ankle orthopaedic surgeon in Toronto. It is general information, not medical advice.

Top comments (0)