DEV Community

StagingBench Team
StagingBench Team

Posted on AI-assisted

Test how sensitive a pass threshold is before you trust it

A threshold makes a measurement actionable. It also creates a boundary that deserves testing. If moving that boundary changes many classifications, a reader needs to know how much the conclusion depends on the chosen cutoff.

StagingBench requires at least 25 inlier matches for alignment to clear its count requirement. You can examine that choice by holding the observed counts fixed and asking what would happen at other thresholds. This is sensitivity analysis: change a decision rule, then measure how the resulting classifications change.

Start by separating two questions. One asks whether alignment was recorded as successful. The other asks whether a known inlier count reaches a proposed threshold. The calculation below answers the second question. It does not rerun alignment or evaluate whether the estimated transformation is plausible.

Keep missing measurements separate

The published set contains 119 records. Of these, 98 have known inlier counts and 21 have empty counts. An empty count must stay unknown. Replacing it with zero would turn missing information into a measured result and force it to fail every positive threshold.

Recorded alignment status contains different information. There are 85 successful statuses, 26 failed statuses, and eight empty statuses. All 85 successful records have known counts. Among the 26 failed records, 13 have known counts and 13 have empty counts. The eight records with empty status also have empty counts.

This distinction explains why a threshold calculation can report 21 unknown records while the published status column contains only eight empty entries. A known failure can still have an unknown inlier count.

Run the count

The script reads a flat export of each room record's alignment_ok and alignment_inliers fields from results.json, saved as inliers.csv with the columns tool, room, photo, alignment_ok and alignment_inliers (empty cell for a missing value). It uses only the standard library.

import csv

with open("inliers.csv", newline="", encoding="utf-8") as source:
    records = list(csv.DictReader(source))

counts = []
unknown = 0

for record in records:
    value = record["alignment_inliers"].strip()
    if value == "":
        unknown += 1
    else:
        counts.append(int(value))

print("threshold pass fail unknown")
for threshold in (15, 20, 25, 30, 35):
    passed = sum(count >= threshold for count in counts)
    failed = len(counts) - passed
    print(threshold, passed, failed, unknown)
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

The exact output for the published counts is:

threshold pass fail unknown
15 91 7 21
20 89 9 21
25 85 13 21
30 81 17 21
35 79 19 21
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Here, "pass" means the count reaches the trial threshold. "Fail" means a known count falls below it. Every row accounts for all 119 records, and the unknown count stays at 21 throughout.

Read the changes

At a threshold of 15, 91 known counts would pass and seven would fail. Raising the threshold to 20 moves two records into the failing group. Raising it again to 25 moves another four.

The next step, from 25 to 30, moves four more records. These are the aligned records with counts from 25 to 29: two at 25, one at 27, and one at 28. Raising the threshold from 30 to 35 moves another two.

Across the tested thresholds, the passing count ranges from 79 to 91. The failing count ranges from seven to 19. These ranges show the effect of the count rule on the observed measurements. They do not measure how accurate each alternative alignment decision would be.

Understand what remains unchanged

Lowering the threshold does not create additional image features or repair a poor transformation. Raising it does not undo an architectural change. Both operations reclassify existing counts.

Likewise, the 21 unknown records remain outside the numerical comparison. No threshold in this exercise supplies the missing measurements. Keeping them separate preserves the difference between observed evidence and absent evidence.

The published threshold is a methodological choice about how much matching evidence is required. A sensitivity check makes its consequences visible, but cannot identify the best choice without examining whether accepted alignments are reliable. The published methodology provides the wider context: when alignment fails, framing is unknown and drift uses an unaligned fallback.

Use the output to identify cases worth inspecting. Records near the boundary deserve comparison with their original images because their classification changes under a small threshold adjustment. The calculation shows where the rule matters. Visual inspection helps determine whether those changed classifications would support a useful comparison.

Top comments (0)