A few months ago I published an article here about how Claude Code changed the way I work — how 20 years of SEO led me to prompt engineering, MCP servers, and building open-source tooling on top of Claude. It was an optimistic piece. This one isn't.
Two weeks ago I opened Claude and saw a restricted page instead of my workspace. My account — one personal organization, 8 months of daily work, roughly 86 billion tokens of research, client projects, and tooling — was suspended for "unusual activity."
I want to be clear about what this post is and isn't. It isn't a rant, and it isn't a demand. It's a description of a process that, in my experience, gives a paying user no realistic way to be heard. If someone from Anthropic reads it — even better.
What I lost
Context matters here, so briefly: I've been in technical SEO for 20 years. For the last 8 months, Claude wasn't a toy for me — it was my research environment. I built and open-sourced global-design-skill, an MCP-based design rule system. I ran large-scale SEO research through Claude Code. I prototyped tools I'd been imagining for years and never had the engineering bandwidth to build.
86 billion tokens sounds like abuse. I get that. But it was real, visible, consistent work — the same kind of usage, day after day, month after month. If my account history were a resume, it would be the most boring resume in the world.
What those 86 billion tokens actually produced
Here's the part I wish someone at Anthropic would look at before calling my activity "unusual." In these same 8 months I published a series of open research preprints on Zenodo — every one with data, code, and replication scripts attached. All of them were built with Claude as my main research environment:
- A study of nine popular prompting techniques (chain-of-thought, chain of draft, and friends) tested against a plain instruction across three real LLM stacks — including Claude Haiku through Claude Code. Result: on deployed stacks, fancy prompting mostly loses to a clear instruction, and the metric often rewards degenerate answers. 7,937 valid model responses, all published.
- Two blind-scored studies on whether covering a search query's intent predicts ranking in Yandex results — the second one preregistered before data collection. Spoiler: it doesn't. Median correlation with rank was statistically indistinguishable from zero.
- A snapshot study of what separates Google's top 20 from positions 21–50 — 7,370 URLs, 160 queries, with an LLM assessor scoring intent coverage blind to rank, and a comparison against Yandex.
- A measurement of how stable AI search citations actually are — whether Perplexity cites the same sources when you ask again, or ask the same thing in different words. 200 answers, bootstrap over all resamples.
- A comparison of AI citation factors across Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, Perplexity, and Yandex Alice — 2,400 Russian-language queries, 38 ranking factors from vendor SEO studies tested against what actually gets cited.
- Two studies on machine-text detection moved to Russian and to the SEO genre — what perplexity-based detectors actually measure, and how formatting instructions alone shift machine-likeness scores when the text's origin stays fixed.
I'm not listing these to brag. I'm listing them because this is what "unusual activity" looked like on my account: a researcher using the tool heavily, in the open, and publishing everything — including the hypotheses that failed. The token volume that probably triggered the flag is the research. If my usage pattern looked anomalous, that's what the anomaly was made of.
The ban, and the page that says nothing
The restricted page told me my organization was suspended for unusual activity and that I could request a review. I did. I wrote honestly: I said I couldn't rule out that the trigger was my login geography. My work involves accessing client server environments in various regions — that's a normal part of SEO and site maintenance. If a session routed through client infrastructure looked like access from an unsupported region, that's on my setup, not on any intent to bypass restrictions. I never used Claude for anything against the usage policy. It was all my own work.
Then I clicked through to the appeal form — and found a dead end. The form showed my organization's status: suspended, "final decision." No active buttons. No text field. No way to submit anything at all.
Since then I've sent more than 6 emails. Every single one came back with the same automated reply: a link to the appeals form. The form that has no way to appeal.
That's the loop. The email bot sends you to the form. The form says the decision is final. There's no human anywhere in the circle.
What actually bothers me
If Anthropic's Trust & Safety team looked at my account and decided the geography pattern or the volume was a genuine policy violation — I can disagree, but I can accept it. Companies get to enforce their rules.
What I can't accept is the architecture of the process:
You never learn what you did. "Unusual activity" is not a reason. It's a category. I can only guess — was it the logins? The volume? Something else entirely? A user who doesn't know the actual reason can't fix it, can't explain it, and can't even properly apologize for it.
The appeal channel is a façade. An appeals form that displays "final decision" with no input fields isn't an appeals process. It's a status page. And an email address that only replies with a link to that status page isn't support — it's a loop.
Eight months of history counts for nothing. No human glanced at my usage pattern and thought, "hold on, this looks like a heavy but legitimate user who maybe logged in from a weird place." Or if one did, there's no trace of it — no question asked, no clarification requested, nothing.
I'm not entitled to an account. But I'd argue any paying user is entitled to one human conversation before the door closes.
The lesson nobody wants to learn
Here's the uncomfortable part, and it applies to you even if you never get banned: if your work lives on a platform, the platform's appeals process is part of your infrastructure. I had 8 months of research context, project history, and workflows tied to a single account with a single provider. I exported nothing. I assumed the door would stay open because I was a good customer.
Good customer, bad customer — the automation doesn't care, and right now there is no reliable path past the automation.
So: export your context. Mirror your prompts and tooling. Keep your workflows portable across models. Not because Anthropic is evil — they aren't, and Claude is genuinely the best tool I've used — but because "the best tool" and "a tool you can lose silently in one click" are the same tool.
What I'm asking for
If anyone from Anthropic reads this, my case is TS-01a19256-f63b-7354-9328-5982c459399b. I'm not asking for special treatment. I'm asking for a human review where I can actually explain my situation once — and if the answer is still no, at least I'll know a person said it.
And if you work on Trust & Safety tooling anywhere: please build an appeals flow that includes a text field. That's it. A text field, and a human on the other end, at least once per case.
I still think Claude is a remarkable product. I spent 8 months building on it and I'd go back tomorrow if the door opened. That's exactly why this process stings — you don't write posts like this about products you don't care about.
If you've been through a similar suspension — with Anthropic or any other AI provider — I'd genuinely like to hear how it ended. Comments are open.
Top comments (0)