DEV Community

Cover image for Classic trend EA on 7 majors: -5.2 % a year.
Arnold Holm
Arnold Holm

Posted on

Classic trend EA on 7 majors: -5.2 % a year.

Classic trend EA on 7 majors: -5.2 % a year.

My test loss would cost you about 5,200 USD in a year on your 100,000 USD challenge account, which alone would use up your total loss room. I ran a long trend test on past MT5 ticks, which are past price moves, and it lost money year by year. If you check a plan before you pay a fee, this is what you want to see right away.

You asked if an old trend idea still earns on the big dollar pairs. An Instagram reel asks the same thing in plain words (Is it true that a classic multi-timeframe trend system works on the majors?). I will answer with my own test, not with talk.

What you have heard

You have heard that an old multi-period trend plan still pays on the big dollar pairs. The claim is simple and it sounds safe. A classic multi-timeframe trend system works on the majors. I thought the same before I ran the numbers, so I put it on past ticks to see what it would have kept.

What my test did

I used an EA, which is a program applying rules in MT5, to run the same plan on past ticks. A 21/63/126-day trend EA on seven USD majors lost 5.16 % a year in real MT5 ticks and paid out 176 USD once. The run covered May 2025 to August 2026. For each unit of ups and downs the account kept minus 0.55.

Chart from my trend test on the majors

What it means for your challenge

You pay a fee to enter a challenge and you get clear loss limits in return. Your account must stay above those limits every day. A plan that loses money year by year makes that job hard. It pulls your account value down while you wait for a good run that comes too late. You would need fresh gains just to climb back to start, and each new drop would push you closer to the end. That is why I look at the loss path early, not at the win talk.

What I do

I do not trust win talk without a loss path. I never pay a challenge fee for a trend program that lost money on past ticks. I want to see how far the account value fell and how long it stayed down.

Your own check

Take your own test report and look at the account value line, not just the closed wins. Find the deepest fall from a high to a low. Open your own test report and compare the largest past drop in account value with the total loss limit in your rules. If that drop is bigger than your limit, that plan would have ended your challenge. Do this before you pay, while it costs you nothing but five minutes.

How to read your report

Many reports show only closed trades. That view hides the pain in between. Your account value can fall far while trades stay open, then come back before the close. You never see that fall if you look only at wins and losses at the close. So open the account value line. Look for the deepest fall. Look at how long the line stayed down. Look at what costs took on the way. A plan can look calm at the close and still have spent weeks under water.

Why the fee makes this matter

You pay before you trade in a challenge. The fee is gone even if you fail on the loss limit. Your time is gone too. That is why a quick look at past ticks helps. It does not tell you what comes next. It tells you what this plan did when prices moved in the past. If it lost money then, you know to pause and think before you pay.

What past ticks can and cannot tell you

Past ticks show what did happen, not what will happen. They use old price moves, with costs taken the way MT5 saw them. That makes them useful for a fee choice. You see if a plan fell far or stayed calm. You see if costs ate the small wins. You do not see what comes next. A good past run does not make the next run good. A bad past run tells you to stop and ask why you would pay to try it.

These are historical test results, not a live account.

To guard your own rules before you pay, try the free Prop Rule Guard.

Top comments (0)