DEV Community

dev game
dev game

Posted on

Why Lies of P Bet on Unreal Engine 4: The Puppet-String Tech Behind a 3M-Copy Soulslike

Short answer

Lies of P runs on Unreal Engine 4, not Unreal Engine 5. Neowiz and Nough — formerly Round8 Studio — list Unreal Engine 4 in the game's infobox, and shipped it on that base across macOS, Windows, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S on September 18, 2023 and PlayStation 4 and PlayStation 5 on September 19, 2023, with a Nintendo Switch 2 port following on August 6, 2026 Lies of P.

That looks late. UE4's last stable release was 4.27 in August 2021 Unreal Engine 4, while Unreal Engine 5 formally launched for developers on April 5, 2022 with Nanite virtualized geometry and Lumen dynamic global illumination Unreal Engine 5. By the time the prequel expansion Overture arrived in June 2025, the game had passed 3 million units sold Lies of P — all on the old engine.

My reading, labeled as analysis rather than a Neowiz quote: UE4 was not a graphics compromise. It was a puppet-string budget. For a first AAA Soulslike from a Korean studio famous for DJMax, boring tech bought readable parries, cheap puppets, and a combinable-weapon content factory.

Fast facts for searchers

  • Game: Lies of P, single-player action role-playing Soulslike, third-person Lies of P Soulslike
  • Developer / publisher: Neowiz and Nough (formerly Round8 Studio) / Neowiz Lies of P. Neowiz is a South Korean developer founded in 1997, best known for DJMax and Lies of P Neowiz
  • Engine: Unreal Engine 4 Lies of P
  • Releases: macOS, Windows, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S September 18, 2023; PS4, PS5 September 19, 2023; Nintendo Switch 2 August 6, 2026 Lies of P
  • Sales: over 3 million units by June 2025 Lies of P
  • Setting: fictional city of Krat, Belle Epoque-inspired, built on Ergo-powered Puppets Lies of P
  • Expansion + sequel: Overture prequel expansion released June 2025; Switch 2 version August 6, 2026; sequel in development Lies of P
  • PC bar: Windows 10 64-bit, Ryzen 3 1200 / i3-6300, 8 GB RAM minimum, GTX 960 4 GB minimum / GTX 1660 6 GB recommended, 50 GB storage Steam store
  • If you searched “lies of p unreal engine 4.27,” “UE4 crash,” or “UE4 or 5”: you are seeing the exact version-confusion this article clears up. It is UE4. Crash guides are UE4-game crashes, not proof of UE5.

Why UE4 was locked, not chosen in 2023

Most roundups treat the engine as a 2023 decision. It was not.

Neowiz revealed Lies of P in 2021 as a Round8 project built on UE4, when UE5 was still in early access from May 26, 2021 to April 2022 Unreal Engine 5. UE4 by then had been in production since 2003, released March 19, 2014, and was a known quantity for PS4 / PS5 / Xbox One / Series X/S Unreal Engine 4.

Three practical reasons to stay:

  1. Hireable Seoul talent. Korea in 2020-2022 had a deep bench of UE4 C++ and Blueprint developers from PUBG, mobile ports, and parallel UE4 productions. UE5 Nanite / Lumen specialists were scarce and expensive.
  2. PS4 + PS5 + Switch 2 in one codebase. UE4.27 officially lists Windows, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Series X/S, Switch and Switch 2 among supported targets Unreal Engine 4. For a Soulslike that must ship at 60 fps on last-gen CPUs and still downport to a handheld in 2026, that old target list is insurance.
  3. No mid-production re-light. Switching to UE5 in 2021-2022 would have meant re-authoring lighting for every Krat alley to use Lumen, re-tuning Nanite LODs, and re-validating parry timing. A Soulslike lives or dies on animation priority and stamina discipline Soulslike — every engine upgrade is a re-tune of your only fun.

My take: UE4 was schedule armor for a studio attempting its first console Soulslike. Neowiz came from rhythm and online games, not FromSoftware-style action. Boring wins when your credibility gap is larger than your graphics gap.

What UE4 gave Krat that UE5 marketing never mentions

1. Puppets are cheaper than people — and UE4 loves rigid bodies

Lies of P is about automat-like Puppets central to life in Krat Lies of P. Narratively it is Pinocchio. Technically it is a gift.

Human faces need complex facial rigs, cloth sim, and skin scattering. Puppet faces are porcelain masks, jointed fingers, and greatcoats that can be stiff by fiction. UE4's mature physically based materials and manually authored LODs Unreal Engine 4 let artists fake Belle Epoque richness with metalness / roughness and cavity shadowing, instead of paying UE5's Lumen bounce for every chandelier.

This is my contrarian claim: Krat's beauty is costume jewelry, not masonry. Gas lamps, wrought iron, puppet joints — all high-contrast, low-deformation assets that read well under baked / probe lighting. UE5's pitch of importing film-quality ZBrush sculpts directly without manual optimization Unreal Engine 5 is wonderful for static ruins. It does nothing for a game where bosses must telegraph clearly at 60 fps.

2. Blade + handle as a content compiler

Every weapon except boss weapons consists of a blade and handle that can be upgraded and combined, granting a Fable Art when the bar fills Lies of P. Add Legion Arms with tools including a grappling hook Lies of P, grindstones that restore durability plus temporary buffs Lies of P, and Quartz-bought skill-tree passives Lies of P.

That is not just design. It is UE4 modularity expressed as gameplay.

UE4's pitch was Blueprints visual scripting on top of full C++ source plus a material library where artists layer pre-made materials instead of re-authoring every use Unreal Engine 4. Lies of P does the same to weapons: dozens of blades times dozens of handles equals hundreds of plausible combos from dozens of authored meshes. No Nanite needed. A spreadsheet becomes content.

My analysis, labeled as mine: other Soulslikes sell you new swords; Lies of P sells you a grammar. That grammar is cheap to test in UE4's animation + Blueprint sandbox, expensive to balance, but almost free to render. Indie lesson: if you cannot afford 200 unique weapons, afford 40 halves.

3. Perfect Guard needs boring frame times, not Lumen

Lies of P lets you light / heavy attack, parry or block, with parry staggering enemies and block trading a little health refunded on counterattack Lies of P. It is stricter than dodge-heavy Soulslikes, closer to deflect timing — but built by a team without a proprietary engine.

UE5's Lumen and Virtual Shadow Maps assume SSD bandwidth and ray-tracing headroom that make locked 60 fps harder on PS4 / Switch 2. UE4's traditional LODs and probe lighting are easier to budget. The Steam minimum of a GTX 960 and recommended GTX 1660 Steam store tells you the target: mainstream PCs, not demo rigs.

Soulslike combat is methodical, stamina-gated, and animation-priority — you cannot cancel out of a swing Soulslike. If frames hitch, parries feel like lies. Staying UE4 bought legibility. The first major UE5 titles in 2023 — Layers of Fear remake, Remnant 2, Immortals of Aveum Unreal Engine 5 — all shipped with stutter discourse. Lies of P avoided that by being old on purpose.

4. Corridors as streaming honesty

Krat is not an open world. It is a string of plague districts linked by Stargazers that restore health, allow fast travel and respawn Lies of P — the bonfire formula Soulslike with a Belle Epoque skin.

That linearity is often criticized versus open-world peers. Technically it is UE4 honesty: stream one gothic street, cull the rest behind a gate, reset enemies on rest. Ergo lost on death and retrievable at the death spot, shrinking if you take damage on the way back Lies of P, is the classic recoverable-currency loop Soulslike — but in a corridor it is cheap to implement and cheap to debug.

My distinctive view: Krat is a museum with a one-way rope. You never get lost enough to need UE5 World Partition. The riddle phones rewarding Trinity Keys Lies of P and Cryptic Vessels with hidden chests Lies of P create exploration inside a budget, not across a continent.

What staying on UE4 cost

Honest accounting:

  • No dynamic bounce. Interiors rely on placed lights. Compared to UE5 Lumen night cities, Krat can feel baked. The art direction hides it with fog, blood, and gold trim.
  • Manual LOD work. UE4 requires artists to author LODs; Nanite automatically manages LODs by scaling dynamically Unreal Engine 5. Every puppet coat costs artist time.
  • Version-confusion tax. Players Google “UE5” and find UE5 crash fixes for other games. Support forums pay that cost.
  • Resume signal. By 2024 hires want Nanite on their portfolio. Staying UE4 forces Neowiz to sell stability while building the sequel.

None of those stopped 3 million sales by June 2025 Lies of P or the Overture expansion. Reviews praised combat, visuals, sound and voice while mixed on level design and narrative — exactly what you expect when tech budget goes to feel, not lore systems.

UE4 vs UE5 for this specific game

Question UE4 (what they shipped) UE5 (what they skipped)
Available at prototype 2020-2021? Yes, mature since 2014 Unreal Engine 4 Early access only, launch April 2022 Unreal Engine 5
Last-gen + handheld targets? Native PS4 / PS5 / Switch 2 list Unreal Engine 4 Supported but heavy features must be disabled
Puppet readability? Manual LODs + PBR, tunable Nanite helps statics, not skinned parry tells
Weapon-combo iteration? Blueprints + C++ proven Same Blueprints, plus new tools to re-learn
60fps Perfect Guard? Easier to budget Lumen overhead risks stutter
Hiring in Seoul 2020-2022? Deep UE4 pool Thin UE5 pool

The lying system is anti-wiki retention — my most subjective claim

Lies of P presents timed choices to lie or tell the truth, branching plot and endings, with NPC dialogue trees and side quests Lies of P. Most Soulslikes gate progress behind stats. This one gates it behind social performance.

I label this as my own idea, not a verified fact: lying is version control for mystery. Stats can be datamined. A lie cannot be patched without replaying the feeling. In an era where every boss is on YouTube in 24 hours, forcing players to decide whether to comfort someone in sorrow creates a second, unsearchable walkthrough. UE4 did not build that — but UE4's cheapness left budget to voice it.

Compare New Game Plus, which carries over gear Lies of P. Stats persist. Lies do not. That asymmetry is why people still argue about endings instead of just builds.

What indie devs can actually steal

  1. Make rigidity fiction. If you cannot afford faces, make masks lore. Puppets, robots, helmets — any fiction that justifies stiff joints saves rigging budget UE4 rewards.
  2. Ship a grammar, not a list. Blade times handle, Ergo times Quartz times Wishstones that grant temporary buffs Lies of P. Two small pools multiply into hundreds of builds QA can test in Blueprints.
  3. Lock the engine at vertical slice. Lies of P kept UE4 from reveal through Overture and Switch 2. If parry is your fun, every renderer upgrade is a re-tune.
  4. Use corridors to fund bosses. One readable street plus one two-phase boss with a summonable spectre and Rare Ergo for boss weapons Lies of P beats an empty field.

Train your Perfect Guard without a PS5

You cannot practice Krat's Fable Arts or Legion Arm timing in a browser, but you can train the underlying greed control:

  • If you parry early and mash, try 3D Block Gladiator: Sword Draw. It forces you to draw precise lines to attack, block and dodge in an arena instead of button-mashing — the same “every slash counts” discipline as Lies of P's perfect guard.
  • If you die to second phases because you get greedy, try Assassin Hero: Infinity Blade. Its roguelike loop about refining hit-and-run skills against hordes and bosses maps directly to learning when not to heal in a Soulslike.
  • If you love the blade-plus-handle itch of combining parts between attempts, try Blade of Dimensions. It is a clicker-adventure about leveling swords and evolving blades against monster waves — a low-stakes way to feel why Neowiz gated power behind combinations rather than raw stats.

None of these are UE4 demos. They are timing and build-craft trainers, which is what a Soulslike actually tests.

Verdict

Lies of P bet on UE4 because in 2021 UE5 was unfinished, in 2022 migration was suicide for parry timing, and in 2023-2026 stability shipped 3 million copies plus an expansion and a Switch 2 port Lies of P Unreal Engine 4 Unreal Engine 5. The old engine bought rigid-puppet cheapness, a combinable-weapon factory, lockable 60 fps for Perfect Guards, and corridor streaming that never needed Nanite.

UE5 would have bought prettier bounce light. Neowiz correctly bought readable lies.

Engine, date, sales, staffing and system-requirement facts above are cited to public sources; the puppet-budget, grammar-as-compiler, corridor-honesty and lying-as-retention arguments are explicitly my own analysis.

Top comments (0)