DEV Community

dev game
dev game

Posted on

Why No Man's Sky Bet on a Custom Engine: The Procedural Math Behind 18 Quintillion Planets

No Man's Sky runs on a proprietary internal engine built by Hello Games for deterministic procedural generation — not Unity, not Unreal. That choice explains both the 2016 disaster and the decade-long comeback: over 18 quintillion planets from a single 64-bit seed, almost nothing stored on servers, and a tiny Guildford team still patching the same tech into Light No Fire today.

The short version: Hello Games rented attention from Sony but refused to rent technology. A licensed engine in 2013 could not promise 18 quintillion consistent planets on PS4. Their own math could — at the cost of having to invent multiplayer, base-building, VR, and cross-play on top of it later, in public.

The facts that force the engine question

Hello Games was founded in February 2008 by Sean Murray, Grant Duncan, Ryan Doyle and David Ream in Guildford, and No Man's Sky was developed by only a small four-person team led by Murray before its VGX 2013 reveal, with Sony Interactive Entertainment handling promotional and publishing help for PS4 Hello Games history.

It launched worldwide for PlayStation 4 and Windows in August 2016 — NA August 9, EU August 10, PC August 12 — then Xbox One in July 2018, PS5 and Xbox Series X/S in November 2020, Switch in October 2022, macOS in June 2023, Switch 2 in June 2025, and iOS on October 28-29, 2026 release history.

The defining technical claim has never changed: nearly all stars, planets, flora, fauna and encounters are created through deterministic algorithms and random number generators from a single seed, with that 64-bit value leading to over 18 quintillion planets to explore how the universe is generated. Very little data is stored on servers — elements are recalculated when you approach them, so other players see the same planet if they travel to the same coordinates server model.

Ten years later, the scale is still absurd: as of August 2026, Murray said players had visited less than 1% of the planets in the game tenth anniversary note.

Light No Fire, announced at The Game Awards 2023 and in development since 2018, uses the same internal engine as No Man's Sky, and optimizations made for it enabled Hello Games to port No Man's Sky to iOS by October 2026 shared engine. Hello Games describes itself simply as a small studio that likes to harness technology to make creative, ambitious games studio statement.

That last line is the tell. This was never an Unreal shop that pivoted. It is a technology-first shop that kept the same hull for a decade.

Why not Unity or Unreal in 2013-2016?

In 2013 Unity 4 and Unreal Engine 4 could ship beautiful corridors. They could not ship this promise: land on any dot you see, with fauna, flora, trading and combat, on a base PS4 with no loading screen between space and surface.

Three practical reasons pushed Hello Games to go custom:

1. The seed is the server. A licensed engine expects content to exist somewhere — on disk or on a server. No Man's Sky stores almost nothing. Your PS4 recalculates the planet from math. That is why cross-platform play, added in July 2020 cross-play timing, and the 32-player Space Anomaly hub advertised on the official site multiplayer model were possible at all for a 50-person studio — the studio reported 50 employees in 2023 team size. They did not have to pay to host 18 quintillion planets. They only had to host discoveries, bases and sessions.

2. Hiring leverage ran the other way. Most “Why Unreal?” stories are about hiring: rent UE5, hire anyone who knows it. Hello Games did the opposite. With four people at reveal and still tiny years later, a custom engine was a filter. You joined to write planet math, not to wire Blueprints. That kept the team small enough to survive the flood that destroyed much of their hardware on December 24, 2013 flood setback and the launch backlash that followed.

3. The launch wound required an owned engine to heal. No Man's Sky received mixed reviews at launch, with critics praising technical achievement but calling gameplay lackluster, and backlash focused on missing multiplayer and Hello Games going quiet launch reception. Since then Hello Games added multiplayer, base-building, freighters, VR and cross-play through free major updates, now widely cited as one of gaming's greatest redemption stories redemption arc.

My read — and this is analysis, not a Hello Games quote: infinity was customer support. When you cannot handcraft an apology big enough for 2016, you generate it. Every free update — Beyond, Origins, Worlds Part I and II, Voyagers — was cheaper to build because the universe was already math. New biomes, storms and water effects are new functions fed into the same seed pipeline, which is exactly why work on Light No Fire could flow back into No Man's Sky instead of forking.

What 18 quintillion actually means in play

Procedural generation is creating data algorithmically through human-guided rules plus randomness, used in games to automatically create large amounts of content with smaller file sizes and more variety definition. No Man's Sky is listed there as the extreme case: a game all based upon procedurally generated elements.

The same page warns about “procedural oatmeal” — thousands of bowls that taste the same oatmeal critique.

Here is where I break from the standard critique. Most reviewers treat oatmeal as failure. For No Man's Sky, oatmeal is the menu.

The four pillars are exploration, survival, combat and trading, with mining, scanning, documenting flora/fauna for units, buying and selling, building bases and expanding fleets core loop. None of those verbs requires a hand-authored planet. They require a legible planet: see resource, mine resource, survive hazard, sell, upgrade, leave. Oatmeal is fine when you are hungry for a loop, not a story. The 30+ hours of Atlas story exists, but the retention engine is the commute between dots.

If you want to feel that mining loop in 30 seconds, try Adventure Miner in a browser. You gather ore, haul it to the dock, buy pickaxe power and capacity, and unlock richer islands. It is the same gather-sell-upgrade-push rhythm as the Multi-tool, stripped of planets — which is why it works as a trainer for NMS discipline: capacity before power, routes before grinding.

The <1% visited stat is usually framed as bloat. I read it as insurance. A handcrafted open world depletes. A seeded universe cannot be finished, so it cannot be proven empty. That let Hello Games sell time, not content, while they rebuilt trust update by update.

The honest comparison: 18 quintillion vs 1,000 vs 22 minutes

Starfield, built on Creation Engine 2 and released September 6, 2023 for Windows and Xbox Series X/S (PS5 April 7, 2026), offers more than 1,000 planets, with most landscapes procedurally generated around handcrafted points of interest like New Atlantis Starfield scope. Bethesda heavily modified Creation to add procedural systems.

Outer Wilds does the opposite: a tiny handcrafted planetary system stuck in a 22-minute time loop that resets when the sun goes supernova loop premise.

Three philosophies:

  • Outer Wilds: tiny and knowable. You memorize orbits, gravity and Nomai ruins. Meaning comes from density.
  • Starfield: 1,000 and menu-driven. You fast-travel through loading screens to curated dungeons. Meaning comes from authored quests.
  • No Man's Sky: 18 quintillion and seamless. You pulse from space to surface with no menu. Meaning comes from the trip.

My take: seamlessness beats fidelity for space fantasy. Starfield tells you space is far by showing you a menu. No Man's Sky tells you space is far by making you fly through colored clouds while your pulse drive spools. That is not a graphics win. It is an engine-architecture win — atmosphere entry, terrain LOD and creature spawning all had to be one continuous system, which a general-purpose engine would have split into levels.

When you want to practice that continuous-flight patience without booting NMS, Build Your Rocket captures the core fantasy in miniature: hold to accelerate, release to coast, climb to reach new planets. NMS is that hold-and-release stretched across galaxies with hazard protection and fuel as the throttle.

Combat, building, and what the engine taxed

Space combat and Sentinel dogfights were thin at launch and still arcade-simple compared to dedicated flight sims. That is the custom-engine tax: Hello Games wrote a universe generator first, a shooter second.

For quick dogfight reflexes — leading targets, breaking off, re-engaging — a browser round of Aces of the Sky: Epic Dogfights is a useful warm-up. Waves of fighters, bombers, helicopters and zeppelin bosses train the same skill NMS space combat actually tests: positioning while tracking multiple projectiles, not complex maneuvers.

Base-building and freighters, by contrast, were cheap to add precisely because the engine is deterministic. A base is just a small list of player edits pinned to seed coordinates. The official site now sells that as the fantasy — from outposts to multi-planet colonies and mobile freighter bases building pitch. The engine did not have to learn persistence. It only had to remember exceptions.

What indie devs should actually steal

  1. Make the seed do server work. If your world can be recalculated from coordinates, you do not pay to host it. You only pay to host what players change. That is how a 50-person team ships cross-play and VR without a platform-holder backend.

  2. Ship infinity, patch meaning. Launch with systems (mining, scanning, trading, surviving), then add verbs (exocraft, settlements, fishing, corvettes) as functions over the same math. Each update revalues old planets without rebuilding them.

  3. Use ugliness as compression. Early NMS creatures were meme-ugly because the generator combined parts freely. Players forgave it because discovery — naming the beast and uploading it to the Atlas for units discovery economy — paid in social currency. Let players laugh, then let them name the joke.

  4. Do not rent what differentiates you. If your pitch is “every planet different,” your engine must own planet generation. Renting Unreal would have made hiring easier and the game impossible. Hello Games chose the harder hiring path to keep the one feature no license could guarantee.

  5. Plan your second game as engine interest. Light No Fire is described as one Earth-size procedural planet with denser content than NMS planets Light No Fire scope. That is not a sequel. It is the same internal engine pointed at depth instead of breadth — and its optimizations already paid for an “impossible” iOS port. Build tech that funds its own sequel.

My contrarian bet: the next meaningful NMS competitor will not offer more planets. It will offer fewer, denser ones on someone else's engine — and lose the long game, because it will have to handcraft every apology. Hello Games can generate apologies forever.

Bottom line

No Man's Sky bet on a custom engine because only custom math could turn 18 quintillion planets from a marketing line into a shipping build on 2016 hardware, then into a decade of free updates and a second game on the same codebase. The cost was a brutal launch and years of building standard features from scratch. The payoff is a universe that still has 99% left to see — and an engine team small enough to keep going.

If you came here asking “what engine was No Man's Sky made in” — it was not Unity, not Unreal, not Creation. It was Hello Games' own procedural engine, iterated since Joe Danger, hardened by flood, hype and backlash, and now stretched toward an Earth-size fantasy world.

Top comments (0)