Pizza Tower did not succeed despite being made in GameMaker. It succeeded because it was made in GameMaker.
Tour De Pizza built the 2023 fast-paced 2D platformer in GameMaker, released for Windows on January 26, 2023 and for Nintendo Switch on August 27, 2024, as a spiritual successor to Nintendo's dormant Wario Land series — specifically Wario Land 4. Across 5 floors and 20 side-scrolling levels, you play Peppino Spaghetti, build combos, then destroy a pillar to trigger Pizza Time and sprint back to the entrance before Pizzaface catches you. Wikipedia and Steam describe the same loop: movement, exploration and score attack, with no health or lives. Metacritic records 89 Metascore from 8 critics (100% positive) and 8.8 user score, with PC Gamer saying it surpasses Wario Land and Metro GameCentral saying it reinvents the formula.
That choice looks odd only if you think beginner tools cannot do speed.
Snapshot: what Tour De Pizza actually shipped
- Developer: Tour De Pizza, led by designer McPig and programmer Sertif over five years, starting from Patreon early-access builds and demos before the Windows launch. Wikipedia
- Engine: GameMaker in the infobox, developed with GameMaker's 2D sprite and room system. Wikipedia
- Platforms: Windows January 26, 2023; Nintendo Switch August 27, 2024. Wikipedia Nintendo Steam
- Scope: 5 floors, each with 4 levels and a boss, plus secrets, treasures, and P-rank second laps. Wikipedia
- Footprint: 300 MB on Steam with minimum specs of Windows 7, dual-core CPU, 512 MB RAM and GeForce GT 1030; 1.1 GB on Switch. Steam Nintendo
- Post-launch: Noise as playable character in a free update on March 11, 2024, plus Swap Mode multiplayer where control passes on hit or grab. Wikipedia
GameMaker itself is a cross-platform 2D engine created by Mark Overmars in 1999 and developed by YoYo Games since 2007. It uses drag-and-drop plus GameMaker Language (GML), commonly likened to JavaScript and C-like languages, running by default on a bytecode stack machine with an optional YoYo Compiler transpiler. It is primarily intended for 2D raster, vector and Spine work, using Direct3D on Windows/Xbox and OpenGL on macOS/Linux, with Switch, PlayStation and Xbox export targets. Since November 2023 it is free for non-commercial use on non-console platforms. Wikipedia
Why GameMaker, not Unity, Unreal or custom C++?
Tour De Pizza did not need Unreal's Nanite, Unity's 3D physics, or a hand-rolled C++ pixel sim. It needed three things GameMaker gives cheaply:
Rooms you can restart instantly. Pizza Tower has no health or lives; colliding only breaks combo and subtracts two seconds. Secrets are optional and difficulty depends on what you choose to chase. That design is only painless if reloading a level is near-free. A 300 MB GameMaker game on 512 MB RAM can do that. Wikipedia Steam
Sprites you can abuse. The SpongeBob and French-comics-inspired high-resolution pixel art, 1990s Nicktoons comparisons, and constant squash-and-stretch on Peppino hide a technical truth: GameMaker's sprite scaling is enough to sell speed without skeletal animation or shaders. Two developers can out-animate a larger team by drawing exaggeration instead of simulating cloth.
Builds a community can actually run and mod. Five years of Patreon builds created a fandom before launch. GameMaker's small Windows builds and well-understood data.win structure invite decompilation, mods and speedrun tools. One Metacritic user even complains about the Peppina mod — which is evidence the pipeline works. Unreal would have given better lighting and far heavier builds that kill that loop. Wikipedia Metacritic
This is different from the other GameMaker hit on this blog. Undertale used GameMaker Studio for a 2015 top-down morality RPG with bullet-hell combat and spare-or-kill branching that sold at least 5 million copies. Undertale's lesson is battle-first prototyping and writing-as-mechanic. Pizza Tower's lesson is momentum-first level design and timer-as-economy. Same engine family, opposite bottleneck.
What Wario Land 4 gave them — and what they changed
Wario Land 4 shipped in 2001 for Game Boy Advance from Nintendo R&D1, with 4 passages of 4 levels plus bosses, totaling 2.2 million copies worldwide. Its core trick is familiar: Wario jumps through a Vortex that closes, finds a switch, then must race back to the start before time expires or lose collectibles. Wikipedia
Pizza Tower copies that escape and then inverts the punishment:
- Wario Land 4: timer expires, score drains rapidly, Wario gets kicked out and loses collectibles, restart level. Bosses must also be beaten within a time limit. Wikipedia
- Pizza Tower: pillar destroyed, Pizza Time starts, must return to entrance or forced restart. But then an optional second lap lets you run back to the end and back again for bonus, and P-rank demands points plus 3 secrets plus treasure plus a second lap while holding one uninterrupted combo. Combo itself lasts seven seconds and must be fed with kills and pickups. Wikipedia
Wario used the timer to enforce scarcity on a cartridge. Pizza Tower uses the timer to create abundance — more YouTube runs, more P-rank attempts, more reasons to learn a 3-minute level for 30 hours. The Wario Land 4 page itself notes Pizza Tower and Antonblast took the escape segments as Pizza Time and Happy Hour respectively. Wikipedia
If you want to feel that difference in your hands before buying, try a short browser warm-up. Space Waves is a one-button high-speed flyer where you hold to rise and release to fall, with no steering. It trains the exact skill Pizza Tower demands: looking two obstacles ahead and feathering with micro-taps instead of holding. Peppino's dash behaves the same way — commit early, correct small.
What speed cost them
GameMaker did not give this away free:
- No free 3D or large open physics. Everything is rooms, tiles and hand-placed secrets: topping creatures to rescue to unlock bosses, janitor-locked treasure doors, three hidden rooms per level. That density is hand-authored, not procedural. It is why the game is 20 dense levels, not 100 generated ones. Wikipedia
- Single-threaded GML limits. The 7-second combo window is generous for a reason. It hides frame hitches inside chaos: when you are plowing through enemies and walls at dash speed, a few milliseconds of script cost are invisible. A slower stealth game on the same stack would expose them.
- Bosses are the only place you can be harmed. Outside bosses — Pepperman, Vigilante, Noise — bumping only costs score and combo time. That split exists because boss arenas are small, controlled rooms where damage logic can be tested exhaustively, while open levels stay frictionless for flow. Wikipedia
My read: three contrarian ideas (opinion, not fact)
Most reviews say Pizza Tower is great because it is fast, funny and nostalgic. I think those are effects. The causes are more boring and more useful:
1. Momentum is the save system.
Other platformers sell checkpoints. Pizza Tower sells uninterrupted motion. If you hold dash long enough Peppino plows through enemies, runs up walls, and chains the 7-second combo. Stopping is what kills a P-rank, not spikes. My take: Tour De Pizza turned GameMaker's cheapest operation — keep the room loaded, keep the player object alive — into the core fantasy. Death would force a room reload and expose load time; combo-break preserves the room and hides it. The no-health design is not kindness, it is engine honesty.
2. Ugliness is compression.
Critics praise the grotesque cartooning as style. I see it as a budget codec. A perfectly round Mario needs clean pixels at every frame. A screaming, stretched Peppino can be wrong in ways that look intentional. GameMaker lets you scale, squash and swap sprites with one line of GML. When every face is already melting, interpolation errors become jokes. Two people can ship thousands of frames because imperfection is on-model. That is why the game can be 1.1 GB on Switch and still feel more animated than many 20 GB platformers. Nintendo
3. The beginner tool is the marketing moat.
Conventional wisdom says pick Unity for hiring and porting. Tour De Pizza picked the tool its community already knew from Undertale, Deltarune mods and GameMaker tutorials. Five years of Patreon demos meant players arrived with route knowledge, not just hype. GameMaker's tiny builds run on school laptops that cannot run Unreal, and its moddability keeps Twitch alive after launch. My unfashionable claim: for a Wario-like, distribution beats rendering. Nintendo sold Wario Land 4 on cartridges to 2.2 million; an indie sells Pizza Tower on speedrun videos powered by players who could have made the game themselves. Wikipedia
You can test the second idea against a slower climb. Block Climber is a pickaxe platformer where you rotate to grip collapsing platforms and lava gaps to reach the top. It is deliberate where Pizza Tower is reckless. Playing it for ten minutes shows what Pizza Tower deliberately removed: stamina, grip meters, careful placement. Peppino has none of that because GameMaker momentum is cheaper than GameMaker climbing physics — and more fun to watch.
How P-rank actually works (and why it matters for devs)
P-rank is not a completion mark, it is a filter:
- Get enough points
- Find 3 secrets
- Collect treasure via janitor door
- Do a second lap (go back to end, return again)
- Never break combo once Wikipedia
That is a brilliant indie retention hack. Casual players finish a level in one pass and see credits. Hunters replay the same room graph three times without any new art. The second lap reuses already-loaded rooms, so it costs almost zero memory — the 512 MB minimum spec never notices. It also turns every level into two levels: the outward exploration route and the inward Pizza Time sprint, which are different lines through the same tiles.
For the escape muscle specifically, Blocky Parkour: Only Up Adventure is a useful trainer. Its mission is pure ascent against the clock with run, jump, dash and glide. Pizza Time is the reverse — descent back to the entrance — but the skill is identical: memorize the route, pre-position before gaps, and never look at your character, look ahead.
What indie devs can steal
- Prototype the escape first. Build one room, one pillar, one return timer in GameMaker rooms before any art. If backtracking is not fun with gray boxes, no pixel art will save it.
- Make bumping cheap, breaking expensive. Copy the no-health rule: touching a wall should cost score and 2 seconds of combo, not a life. You keep flow and avoid reload hitches on low specs. Wikipedia
- Ship tiny. 300 MB and GT 1030 minimums mean more laptops can run Patreon demos, which means more feedback. Treat installer size as a design feature. Steam
- Use GameMaker for what it is good at: 2D rooms, sprite tricks, fast iteration, Switch export. Do not fight it for 3D, large physics sandboxes or procedural open worlds — that is where Unity/Unreal/custom determinism wins.
- Design P-rank, not difficulty modes. One fixed level plus opt-in mastery (secrets + treasure + second lap + unbroken combo) splits casual and hardcore without balancing three separate modes.
Bottom line
Pizza Tower bet on GameMaker because a Wario-like does not need a renderer, it needs a rehearsal room: instant restarts, readable speed, and a timer that turns a finished level into a new run. The 89 Metascore and refs to surpassing Wario Land make sense once you see Pizza Time as Wario Land 4's Vortex return with the punishment replaced by a score economy. Metacritic Wikipedia
My distinct take against the nostalgia narrative: this is not a revival, it is a correction. Nintendo proved the escape loop on GBA hardware in 2001. Tour De Pizza proved that on modern PC hardware, with GameMaker's constraints, the same loop works better when you remove death, keep the room loaded, and let ugliness do the animating.
Top comments (0)